Black franchisees at McDonald’s file new discrimination lawsuit
October 29, 2020
By Jonathan Stempel
(Reuters) – McDonald’s Corp was hit on Thursday with a potentially multi-billion dollar lawsuit by Black franchise owners who accused the fast-food giant of racial discrimination for steering them to underperforming stores.
The proposed class action led by James and Darrell Byrd, who are brothers with four McDonald’s restaurants in Tennessee, was filed by the same law firm representing 52 Black former franchisees who filed a similar lawsuit on Aug. 31.
McDonald’s was accused of placing Black franchisees in undesirable inner-city locations with high security and insurance costs and below-average sales, and driving many away by failing to support them as debts rise and profits fall short.
Jim Ferraro, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, estimated that McDonald’s has 186 Black franchisees in the United States, down from a peak of 377 in 1998, who own “700-plus” stores.
The lawsuit filed in Chicago federal court seeks damages of $4 million to $5 million per store, potentially totaling more than $3 billion overall.
Chicago-based McDonald’s has taken steps this year to address concerns about its workplace culture and treatment of franchisees, including by updating its corporate values for the first time since 2008.
It has denied treating Black franchisees differently and said it wants them to succeed, while acknowledging that it wants its franchisee ranks to become more diverse.
McDonald’s has also denied racial discrimination claims in a separate lawsuit filed in January by two Black executives.
“They’ve been on a massive PR campaign to clean up their image,” Ferraro told reporters on a conference call. “This is actually a good thing, at some level, but not a good enough thing.”
McDonald’s sought last week to dismiss the lawsuit by the former franchisees, saying it disclosed the risks of owning stores and did not set anyone up for failure. That lawsuit sought up to $1 billion in damages.
The case is Byrd et al v McDonald’s USA LLC et al, U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois, No. 20-06447.
(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Aurora Ellis)