Brendan Fraser's Batgirl Role Can Fix A DCEU Villain Problem
Brendan Fraser has been cast as the main antagonist in Batgirl, and the actor’s debut in the DCEU can fix its villain problem. Fraser is enjoying an entirely deserved career resurgence, with acclaimed roles on the likes of DC’s Doom Patrol and Danny Boyle’s FX series Trust. He was recently cast alongside Leonardo DiCaprio and Robert DeNiro in Martin Scorsese’s Killers of the Flower Moon and headlines Darren Aronofsky’s upcoming drama The Whale.
Not much is currently known about Batgirl. It will be directed by Adil El Arbi and Bilall Fallah, from a script by Christina Hodson, who also penned Birds of Prey and 2022’s The Flash. Leslie Grace will star as Barbara Gordon, member of the Bat-Family and daughter of Commissioner James Gordon, with J.K. Simmons reprising his Justice League role. Jacob Scipio has also been cast in an undisclosed role. Batgirl has been teased as an origin story, with Fraser playing villainous pyromaniac Firefly.
Firefly is hardly the most well-known member of Batman’s rogues’ gallery, but he could be exactly what the DCEU needs to correct its villain problem. The DCEU has suffered a multitude of setbacks since its conception with 2013’s Man of Steel. DC Comics boasts many fantastic villains, but Warner Bros. has struggled to properly incorporate the characters in recent years. Many DCEU villains have been divisive and underutilized within their respective films. Fraser’s Batgirl casting can change this by harnessing his natural charm and underrated dramatic talent to introduce the most surprising villain yet, while also avoiding the pressure of adapting the more infamous rogues’ gallery foes.
Batgirl should take note of previous missteps, given the majority of the DCEU’s current villains range from controversial to forgettable. Man of Steel delivered a suitably intense General Zod (Michael Shannon). Still, his twisted motivations for saving the Kryptonian race were sidelined in favor of CGI destruction in Zack Snyder’s overblown third act. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice introduced Jessie Eisenberg’s Lex Luthor, who was instantly met with derision and singled out as one of the film’s weakest components. Although he initially failed to reflect the intimidating, highly intelligent incarnation in the comics, Luthor’s Justice League cameo rectified this issue by teasing a more mature and subdued persona. He could evolve into a worthy adversary, but there are currently no plans to continue his arc. Jared Leto’s Joker suffered a similar fate, with a divisive character design and severely edited role in Suicide Squad preceding a welcome but fleeting appearance in the Snyder Cut's Knightmare scene.
Luthor and the Joker could yet become compelling villains if not for the DCEU's reluctance to rectify its mistakes. Too often, villains have been added as an obstacle for heroes to overcome, while their own relationships with fellow allies and enemies have seldom been explored. Bland, oppressively gray CGI monsters like Doomsday and Steppenwolf (Ciarán Hinds) were uninspired, and the DCEU's move into lighter territory only partially improved upon its villains. Shazam! didn't spend much time getting under Dr. Sivana's (Mark Strong) skin, and Orm's (Patrick Wilson) environmental motivations in Aquaman quickly gave way to a typical showdown between hero and mad tyrant. However, Batgirl can benefit from what’s likely to be a more grounded story than in previous entries, providing its villain is allowed a proper foundation in Gotham.
This was a missed opportunity with Birds of Prey and its overt focus on Harley Quinn (Margot Robbie). The movie wisely opted for a small-scale plot but struggled to juggle its ensemble of lesser-known characters. Black Mask (Ewan McGregor) and Victor Zsasz (Chris Messina) brought a sinister flamboyance that enlivened an overly simplistic narrative. Unfortunately, their relatively small roles and unceremonious deaths meant they couldn't evoke the deadly adversaries from the comics. Black Mask's rise to power and implied rivalry with the Joker may never be explored, and his supposed queerness was disappointingly absent from the film. Both characters were colorful bursts of energy but were essentially robbed of their identities. The DCEU has focused on Batman's villains but ignored much of the rich history these characters possess. Rarely have they been depicted as fully existing within this universe, which hinders their long-term impact. Batgirl, which was teased at DC FanDome, presents the perfect opportunity to reverse this trend.
Firefly is widely reported to be Batgirl’s villain, which could prove a smart move for the DCEU. He’s not a particularly well-known rogue, especially for general audiences, which removes the pressure that hangs over each take on the Joker or Penguin. Firefly is an unexpected choice, but one that can effectively serve Batgirl’s story as he doesn’t boast any explicit connection to Batman. Focusing on a villain audiences may be unfamiliar with supports the notion Batgirl will be a smaller, more personal film, with a compelling antagonist free from expectations. Fraser's involvement is a welcome surprise and by no means an obvious development. He’s a beloved actor best known for charming comedies and starring as Rick O’Connell in The Mummy, meaning his Batgirl casting can cleverly misdirect viewers. He could lean into his charisma to deliver the DCEU’s most likable, even sympathetic villain, or he could use it to catch the heroes off guard.
Brendan Fraser knows how to be intimidating. His supporting turn as prison guard Gunther in The Affair showed he could be incredibly unsettling, effortlessly shifting from his amiable movie persona to a violent, hulking terror. Fraser’s ability to subvert his humble, friendly reputation could even be Batgirl’s greatest resource. His CIA agent in The Quiet American manages to elicit sympathy even after revealing his cold, duplicitous nature. This is largely due to Fraser’s skill at coloring even his most conflicted characters. Fraser is no stranger to blockbuster territory and has happily thrown himself around during action set pieces. However, he’s older now, and Fraser previously revealed he underwent multiple surgeries that will likely prevent him from performing many stunts. This only makes his role more intriguing and means the film will likely rely on instilling Batgirl’s villain with quiet menace instead of agility or brute force.
Batgirl’s filmmakers could utilize Fraser’s affable persona to deter suspicion during Barbara and her father’s investigation. He may be the most charming and, crucially, unpredictable villain yet, which is exactly what the DCEU needs. Previous antagonists have been motivated, rather typically, by greed or world-domination, whereas others have lacked an engaging justification for their crimes. Fraser’s casting suggests Batgirl plans to go down a different route with its villain. Just as Batman mentors Batgirl, Fraser’s middle-aged foe might desire a successor in the form of Jacob Scipio’s undisclosed character. This would provide a more personal narrative and even tie into a reported Batman appearance - whether it's Ben Affleck or Michael Keaton - focusing on the legacy of the Dark Knight and his rogues’ gallery.
Fraser’s Batgirl casting might prompt questions about continuity with DC’s Doom Patrol, in which he portrays Cliff Steele/Robotman. Although the HBO Max show isn’t part of the DCEU, the Multiverse is being introduced in The Flash, which will supposedly make all current and previous DC films and shows canon in their respective worlds. Some may wonder if Fraser playing two separate characters would cause conflict, but this isn’t an issue that needs to be officially addressed. For one thing, Fraser’s villain could look and act entirely different from Cliff. It’s hardly novel for a franchise to cast a performer in multiple roles. The MCU is also delving into the Multiverse, wherein actors like Chris Evans have already starred in films based on Marvel properties. The MCU has reused actors in the past, with Gemma Chan featuring in Captain Marvel and Eternals, while Martin Starr appeared in both The Incredible Hulk and Spider-Man: Homecoming.
So little is known about Batgirl’s plot that it’s difficult to determine how Brendan Fraser’s villain will impact its story. However, the casting alone is a refreshing change of pace from depicting younger, more muscular antagonists. The DCEU has underutilized several talented actors in the past. Still, the potential for Fraser to debut as a largely untouched Batman rogue provides hope that the filmmakers will break a disappointing trend and fix one of the DCEU’s biggest mistakes.