Добавить новость
smi24.net
News in English
Март
2023

AI tool users beware: Copyright Office’s denial of protection for graphic novel underscores new legal vulnerabilities for creators

0

Analysis

From text generators like Chat GPT to AI art generators like DALL·E, the recent explosion in the popularity of AI tools has led to creators exploring ways to incorporate AI tools into their work. But this opens them up to a whole host of legal issues. 

As previously reported by Passionfruit, creators have become divided over the use of AI in making art, with several online artists claiming that the algorithm stole and reproduced artists without credit in order to produce its creations. 

And after a few months of speculation, the law is sparking new debate among creators, with the U.S. Copyright Office releasing a letter explaining their decision to cancel a portion of the copyright registration it previously issued for Kristina Kashtanova’s graphic novel, Zarya of the Dawn

The graphic novel first hit headlines in September 2022 after becoming the first AI-generated work to receive a copyright certificate. Kashtanova created the graphic novel’s artwork using Midjourney’s text-to-image AI tool, as they publicly documented on Instagram and Facebook in 2022. 

The Copyright Office, which was not aware of this at the time of granting the graphic novel’s certificate, soon began an investigation into the creative process upon discovering this information.

Now, the Copyright Office confirms in its letter the use of an AI tool fails to meet the human authorship requirement under U.S. copyright law. The result is that any AI-generated materials would be considered public domain.

“The process by which a Midjourney user obtains an ultimate satisfactory image through the tool,” the Copyright Office explains in the letter, “is not the same as that of a human artist, writer, or photographer.”

Additionally, the Copyright Office agrees the text of the story and the selection and arrangement of the text and images into a graphic novel format, referred to as compilations, are protected by copyright. 

"This is a great day for everyone that is creating using Midjourney and other tools," Kashtanova wrote in a tweet and statement to Passionfruit regarding the ability to maintain protection over their arrangement and story elements. "My lawyers are looking at our options to further explain to the Copyright Office how individual images produced by Midjourney are a direct expression of my creativity and therefore copyrightable," they confirmed separately.

The public record for the copyright certificate will be updated, and a new certificate will be issued, to reflect the registration covers only those copyrightable elements.

While registration of a work with the Copyright Office offers additional benefits and protections for a creator, registration is not a requirement to establish copyright. 

“Registrations should clearly delineate the aspects of the work that were the subject of creative (human) expression,” copyright expert and attorney Aaron Moss told Passionfruit. “Unless you’re actively looking to end up as the next test case, you should make the copyright examiners’ jobs easier. Believe it or not, they’re trying to help you!”

However, the fact that generative art has now been explicitly identified as not copyrightable for lack of human creation, it doesn’t matter, legally, whether or not a creator seeks to register their AI-generated content or not.

How does this impact Zarya of the Dawn?

A potential issue for Kashtanova is their use of an AI tool to create the visual look of the titular character. This is because copyright law allows for the protection of the drawings, pictures, and descriptions of a character. 

However, that protection is potentially at risk for character images and similar depictions that are generated by an AI tool, absent future insights or guidance from the Copyright Office.

“If I was Mx. Kashtanova, this would be my primary concern,” noted IP attorneys Ash Kernen and Eliana Torres in a joint Twitter thread. “A given image can be replaced, but a character guides the entire ecosystem.”

For Zarya of the Dawn, Kashtanova was also very public about using references to actress Zendaya as part of the prompt engineering process. Such actions potentially open the door for additional issues beyond copyright, such as violations of the right of privacy and the rights of name, image, and likeness (NIL).

“The future of creativity depends on creators being able to distinguish what is an appropriate use of AI from what is not,” Peterson explains. “Usually we have regulations to guide us, but right now we're in a legal gray area. We have to think really critically about what's ethically sound and responsible until the laws catch up.”

What can creators learn from this?

“It's important to learn about [AI] in a balanced way,” Hannah Peterson, founder of AI Daily, told Passionfruit. “Make sure you're not only focusing on all the ways it can make your life easier but also really being honest with yourself about the risks you're taking on.”

If a creator is using AI tools as part of their production process, the most important question becomes the amount of human authorship, if any, that can be attributed to the final work. But this might be difficult until the Copyright Office releases more explicit guidance about how much human authorship is required for an AI-generated work to qualify for copyright protection. 

In the meantime, Adobe Stock, a stock asset licensing service through which Kashtanova licenses generative art, recently released its own set of requirements for the submission of generative art that creators may find helpful. 

A potential starting point for creators that are using AI-powered tools in their workflow is to ask: “What is the end goal for this content?” If a creator is building evergreen content, such as a course, blog, or book, then it may be worth limiting the incorporation of AI content. If a creator is trying to maximize their workflow to produce a high volume of content, such as a video for TikTok, without concern regarding the ability to protect the content over the long term, then it may not matter as much. 

Creators can also identify the most important elements of their work that they would want to protect, and then, ensure those elements include as much organic creative direction and as little AI involvement as possible.

Both creators and their brand partners should be working closely together if AI or similar generative tools are part of a production workflow for advertisements. The key is to ensure transparency and disclose to any partners from the beginning if you’re using AI in your product and how.

How will this case impact creator-oriented technology?

Many creator-focused software companies are expanding their offerings to incorporate AI capabilities, often powered by third-party startups such as OpenAI. For example, Kajabi’s AI Creator Tools product helps creators generate course outlines, email content, landing pages, and course lessons.

“The hardest part about content creation is simply getting started and AI is solving this problem in a big way for creators,” Vinay Mysoor, VP of Corporate Development and Legal at Kajabi, told Passionfruit. “[Creators are] using the AI outputs for inspiration and then modifying them to make the content their own.”

However, tools like this could potentially spark legal debate. A creator that uses the course outline tool, for example, may be able to claim ownership of a final course and the content within any such course, since there would arguably be significant human creative involvement to get from an outline to a more robust course offering. 

However, the other three tools that can be used to output entire works may cause issues if used without any additional human involvement. Kajabi explained in a written statement to Passionfruit it does not claim ownership rights over the final course output and leaves that for creators, pointing to its Terms of Service. The company also points to OpenAI’s terms that align with that stance. 

For Kajabi, the future involves making AI an accessible tool for creators. “Rather than backing away from innovation out of fear,” Mysoor said, “we're empowering creators to unlock the good that can come from AI, which in our case is helping them turn their knowledge into thriving online businesses."

Another example of an AI tool for creators is Revoice, a text-to-speech algorithm released by podcasting platform Podcastle that is tailored to a specific host, actor, or personality’s voiceprint—what the company calls a “Digital Voice.” 

According to the website, creators read 70 sentences to train the AI model and are then able to generate anything, “from podcast intros to ad segments, voiceovers to entire episodes.”

“Creators who use Podcastle are unequivocally the owners of their generated content, using Revoice or any other tool,” a spokesperson for Podcastle told Passionfruit in a statement. “Podcastle is a content creation platform, and we do not own any of the content produced by our users.”

However, the legal terms and privacy policies that are agreed to when creators use a production platform only cover the relationship between those two parties and don’t override protections that may or may not be available under current copyright laws.

Text-to-content tools arguably now fall within a legal gray area based on the Copyright Office’s analysis in its letter. When using tools that output content of any kind, like Revoice, the content created as the input, such as a written script, may be copyrightable, but it is currently unclear what, if any, rights the creator will have to the output. 

Does the resulting audio file generated by an algorithm qualify as sufficient human involvement? Does it even matter if the underlying content, such as the script, can be protected and used as part of a creator’s IP strategy? 

The Copyright Office’s letter may not be the end of the road for obtaining protections over AI-generated works, as it may likely face a challenge in court. The Copyright Office arguably leaves the door open to potentially obtaining some level of protection. However, creators and brands should proceed with caution while using AI-powered tools until specific guidance is released or laws change to recognize non-human authors.

Sign up to receive the Daily Dot’s Internet Insider newsletter for urgent news from the frontline of online.

The post AI tool users beware: Copyright Office’s denial of protection for graphic novel underscores new legal vulnerabilities for creators appeared first on The Daily Dot.








Marins Park Hotel Ростов – это больше, чем просто отель

Летние каникулы в духе патриотизма

Анимационная программа нового пляжа «Изумрудный»

Коллекция Marc Jacobs осень-зима 2025/26


ICE is 'supercharging detention' with 'flagrantly unlawful' policy: lawyers

First confirmed death during Trump ICE raid is a farmworkers at a California cannabis facility

Son Of British Boxing Legend Retires From The Sport Aged Just 24: “Won’t Be Fighting Again”

Trump's cuts force Texas food banks to ration supplies for flood survivors


Каршеринг BelkaCar запустил новый сезон проекта «Умные путешествия»

Чилим на позитиве...

Врач-офтальмолог Элина Санторо: как выбрать идеальные солнцезащитные очки

Победили лучшие – выиграли все! В Санкт-Петербурге состоялся Международный конкурс «Мастер — Золотые руки 2025»


Гайд на Fuqiu из Etheria Restart: навыки, PvE-билд, расклад в PvP и дубликаты

I've swapped modern live service games for a browser game that's been running since 2009

The Expanse RPG's developers are 'humbled' by comparisons to BioWare's heyday, but don't expect it to be a straight Mass Effect clone: 'We make our story a little bit differently'

Those shadow giants in the distance in Elden Ring Nightreign are over 2 miles tall⁠—almost as big as the Erdtree⁠—and nobody even mentions them in the game



Врач-офтальмолог Элина Санторо: как выбрать идеальные солнцезащитные очки

Косметолог Наталья Рябинова: в чем разница между эстетическим и медицинским трихологом

Вот билет на контент, на эксплойт билетов нет

Росгвардейцы из Чеченской Республики стали победителями и призерами чемпионата Северо-Кавказского округа Росгвардии по комплексному единоборству


Участники «Активного гражданина» выбрали лучшую заправку для окрошки

Росгвардейцы из Чеченской Республики стали победителями и призерами чемпионата Северо-Кавказского округа Росгвардии по комплексному единоборству

Татарстан вошел в число лидеров по количеству заявок на конкурс брендов «Знай наших»

Врач-офтальмолог Элина Санторо: как выбрать идеальные солнцезащитные очки


«Сила в команде»: судебные приставы Кузбасса приняли участие во всероссийских хоккейных соревнованиях среди силовиков

Андрей Воробьев рассказал об открытии новых школ в Подмосковье к 1 сентября

Франция предупредила о риске крупного конфликта в Европе к 2030 году

Эквадор выдал россиянина, подозреваемого в мошенничестве.


Минниханов о победе Кудерметовой на Уимблдоне: мы гордимся!

Кудерметова завоевала свой первый титул Уимблдона в парном разряде.

Тарпищев объяснил причины неудачного выступления Анисимовой против Швентек.

Медведев стал обладателем Кубка короля в Испании.


Татарстан вошел в число лидеров по количеству заявок на конкурс брендов «Знай наших»

Из трёх музеев Томской области томичи отправили по почте 500 «тёплых открыток»

Раскрыто расписание Олимпийских игр 2028 года в Лос-Анджелесе.

Москва прощается с жарой: жителей столицы предупредили о ливнях и грозах


Музыкальные новости

Суд Петербурга начал административное дело против группы «Порнофильмы»

«Все считают»: Успенская рассказала, почему не будет встречаться с американцами

Самые знаковые песни группы Queen

Эксперт оценил стоимость американской недвижимости Орбакайте: миллионы долларов


Вот билет на контент, на эксплойт билетов нет

Пора пригласить певца A.SERGIO для участия в теле- и радиопрограммах, подкастах и шоу!

Косметолог Наталья Рябинова: в чем разница между эстетическим и медицинским трихологом

Росгвардейцы из Чеченской Республики стали победителями и призерами чемпионата Северо-Кавказского округа Росгвардии по комплексному единоборству


Трамп ушел от ответа, ждать ли новых ограничительных мер против России

Трамп вновь заявил о своем разочаровании Путиным

Тренер "Спартака" Станкович: у Барко вышел волнообразный сезон

Молния убила трех человек на пляже в России


Мобильный интернет перестанут массово отключать в России

КАМАЗ-4280 начал тестовую эксплуатацию на маршруте в Подмосковье

В Москве мужчина ограбил магазин на АЗС, угрожая пистолетом

Вскрытие без последствий – сервис «Спас-замков»


Путин отметил успех школьников на Международной химической олимпиаде.

В РФ раскрыли замысел Трампа после его попыток шантажировать Путина

"Пока Путин не заметит это безобразие": Пономарев резко высказался о легионерах в РПЛ

Посол Акира Муто: Япония будет приветствовать возможную встречу Путина и Трампа




Косметолог Наталья Рябинова: в чем разница между эстетическим и медицинским трихологом

Клинический психолог Юлия Тарибо: каким типам личностей сложно было вместе

Травмированного на репетиции в цирке Москвы акробата выписали из больницы

Врач-трихолог Мадина Осман: как часто можно делать пересадку волос


ВСУ атаковали дронами женщин под Сумами: Били за надпись "Мы русские"


Раскрыто расписание Олимпийских игр 2028 года в Лос-Анджелесе.

«Турбозавры» поучаствовали в Дне московского транспорта

"Пока Путин не заметит это безобразие": Пономарев резко высказался о легионерах в РПЛ

Травмированного на репетиции в цирке Москвы акробата выписали из больницы


Лукашенко заявил о необходимости проверки чиновников за манипуляции с ценами.

Лукашенко предложил Петербургу ремонтировать всю белорусскую технику

Лукашенко встретился в Минске с делегацией Петербурга для обсуждения сотрудничества

Петербургская делегация провела переговоры с президентом Беларуси в Минске


Сергей Собянин: роботы и электромашины на страже московских улиц

Сергей Собянин: В Москве появятся три новых пешеходных моста к 2027 году


РЭО проведет акселератор для экоцентров на базе Плехановского университета

Губернатор Андрей Бочаров принимает участие в образовательной программе Сбера

ГК «АСНА» внедрила систему продвинутой аналитики «Дельта BI»

Позднякова: температура в Москве останется выше климатической нормы


Москва прощается с жарой: жителей столицы предупредили о ливнях и грозах

«Союз-Аполлон» — вторая встреча над Эльбой. А можем повторить?

В Видном арестовали мать мальчика, которого отчим избил битой

В Городском округе Пушкинский в образовательных комплексах полным ходом идёт подготовка к новому учебному году


В городе Барнауле стартовал третий этап смотра-конкурса на звание "Лучшее звено газодымозащитной службы" среди Главных управлений МЧС России

Фестиваль духовых оркестров пройдет в трех городах Поморья по случаю Дня ВМФ

Беспроводной сканер штрих-кодов SAOTRON P05i промышленного класса

Алтайский край оказался в числе регионов-аутсайдеров по доступности вторичного жилья


Феодосия получила 150 миллионов на ремонты дворов - где начнут работы

Симферополь частично остался без света утром 14 июля

Десятки улиц Симферополя остались без света 14 июля

Крыму и еще 24 регионам России спишут долги на миллиарды рублей


«Ηичeгο οб Apмeнии бeɜ Apмeнии» – Зaпaд οбeщaeт Εpeвaну тο жe, чтο и κοгдa-тο Κиeву

Раскрыто расписание Олимпийских игр 2028 года в Лос-Анджелесе.

Жители Прикамья активно покупают билеты на транспорт в отделениях Почты России

Апелляция: Экс-замминистра обороны Иванов и растрата 3,9 млрд рублей














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *