Добавить новость
smi24.net
News in English
Март
2023

What You Can’t Say on YouTube

0

Recently, on a YouTube channel, I said something terrible, but I don’t know what it was. The main subject of discussion—my reporting on the power of online gurus—was not intrinsically offensive. It might have been something about the comedian turned provocateur Russell Brand’s previous heroin addiction, or child-abuse scandals in the Catholic Church. I know it wasn’t the word Nazi, because we carefully avoided that. Whatever it was, it was enough to get the interview demonetized, meaning no ads could be placed against it, and my host received no revenue from it.

“It does start to drive you mad,” says Andrew Gold, whose channel, On the Edge, was the place where I committed my unknowable offense. Like many full-time YouTubers, he relies on the Google-owned site’s AdSense program, which gives him a cut of revenues from the advertisements inserted before and during his interviews. When launching a new episode, Gold explained to me, “you get a green dollar sign when it’s monetizable, and it goes yellow if it’s not.” Creators can contest these rulings, but that takes time—and most videos receive the majority of their views in the first hours after launch. So it’s better to avoid the yellow dollar sign in the first place. If you want to make money off of YouTube, you need to watch what you say.

[From the November 2018 issue: Raised by YouTube]

But how? YouTube’s list of content guidelines manages to be both exhaustive and nebulous. “Content that covers topics such as child or sexual abuse as a main topic without detailed descriptions or graphic depictions” is liable to be demonetized, as are “personal accounts or opinion pieces related to abortion as a main topic without graphic depiction.” First-person accounts of domestic violence, eating disorders, and child abuse are definite no-no’s if they include “shocking details.” YouTube operates a three-strike policy for infractions: The first strike is a warning; the second prevents creators from making new posts for a week; and the third (if received within 90 days of the second) gets the channel banned.

For the most popular creators, the site can bring in audiences of millions, and financial rewards to match. But for almost everyone else, content production is a grind, as creators are encouraged to post regularly and repackage content into its TikTok rival, Shorts. Although many types of content may never run afoul of the guidelines—if you’re MrBeast giving out money to strangers, to the delight of your 137 million subscribers, rules against hate speech and misinformation are not going to be an issue—political discussions are subject to the whims of algorithms.

Absent enough human moderators to deal with the estimated 500 hours of videos uploaded every minute, YouTube uses artificial intelligence to enforce its guidelines. Bots scan auto-generated transcripts and flag individual words and phrases as problematic, hence the problem with saying heroin. Even though “educational” references to drug use are allowed, the word might snag the AI trip wire, forcing a creator to request a time-consuming review.

Andrew Gold requested such a review for his interview with me, and the dollar sign duly turned green—meaning the site did eventually serve ads alongside the content. “It was a risk,” he told me, “because I don’t know how it affects my rating if I get it wrong … And they don’t tell me if it’s Nazis, heroin, or anything. You’re just left wondering what it was.”

Frustrations like Gold’s rarely receive much attention, because the conversation about content moderation online is dominated by big names complaining about outright bans. Perversely, though, the most egregious peddlers of misinformation are better placed than everyday creators to work within the YouTube rules. A research paper last year from Cornell University’s Yiqing Hua and others found that people making fringe content at high risk of being demonetized—such as content for alt-right or “manosphere” channels—were more likely than other creators to use alternative money-making practices, such as affiliate links or pushing viewers to subscribe on other platforms. They didn’t even attempt to monetize their content on YouTube—sidestepping the strike system—and instead used the platform as a shop window. They then became more productive on YouTube because demonetization no longer affected their ability to make a living.

The other platforms such influencers use include Rumble, a site that bills itself as “immune to cancel culture” and has received investment from the venture capitalist Peter Thiel and Senator J. D. Vance of Ohio. In January, Florida’s Republican governor, Ron DeSantis, announced that Rumble was now his “video-sharing service of choice” for press conferences because he had been “silenced” by Google over his YouTube claims about the coronavirus pandemic. Recently, in a true demonstration of horseshoe theory, Russell Brand (a left-wing, crunchy, COVID-skeptical hater of elites) posed with Donald Trump Jr. (a right-wing, nepo-baby, COVID-skeptical hater of elites) at a party hosted by Rumble, where they are two of the most popular creators. Brand maintains a presence on YouTube, where he has 6 million subscribers, but uses it as exactly the kind of shop window identified by the Cornell researchers. He recently told Joe Rogan that he now relies on Rumble as his main platform because he was tired of YouTube’s “wild algebra.”

[Read: Why is Joe Rogan so popular?]

For mega-celebrities—including highly paid podcasters and prospective presidential candidates—railing against Big Tech moderation is a great way to pose as an underdog or a martyr. But talk with everyday creators, and they are more than willing to work inside the rules, which they acknowledge are designed to make YouTube safer and more accurate. They just want to know what those rules are, and to see them applied consistently. As it stands, Gold compared his experience of being impersonally notified of unspecified infractions to working for HAL9000, the computer overlord from 2001: A Space Odyssey.

One of the most troublesome areas of content is COVID—about which there is both legitimate debate over treatments, vaccines, and lockdown policies and a great river of misinformation and conspiracy theorizing. “The first video I ever posted to YouTube was a video about ivermectin, which explained why there was no evidence supporting its use in COVID,” the creator Susan Oliver, who has a doctorate in nanomedicine, told me. “YouTube removed the video six hours later. I appealed the removal, but they rejected my appeal. I almost didn’t bother making another video after this.”

Since then, Oliver’s channel, Back to the Science, which has about 7,500 subscribers, has run into a consistent problem—one that other debunkers have also faced. If she cites false information in a video in order to challenge it, she faces being reported for misinformation. This happened with a video referencing the popular creator John Campbell’s false claims about COVID vaccines being linked to brain injuries. Her video was taken down (and restored only on appeal) and his video remained up. “The only things in my video likely to have triggered the algorithm were clips from Campbell’s original video,” Oliver told me. Another problem facing YouTube: COVID skepticism is incredibly popular. Oliver’s content criticizing Campbell’s brain-injury rhetoric has just more than 10,000 views. His original video has more than 800,000.

Oliver wondered if Campbell’s fans were mass-reporting her—a practice known as “brigading.”

“It appears that YouTube allows large, profitable channels to use any loophole to spread misinformation whilst coming down hard on smaller channels without even properly checking their content,” she said. But a Google spokesperson, Michael Aciman, told me that wasn’t the case. “The number of flags a piece of content may receive is not a factor we use when evaluating content against our community guidelines,” he said. “Additionally, these flags do not factor into monetization decisions.”

YouTube is not the only social network where creators struggle to navigate opaque moderation systems with limited avenues for appeal. Users of TikTok—where some contributors are paid from a “creator fund” based on their views—have developed an entire vocabulary to navigate automated censorship. No one gets killed on TikTok; they get “unalived.” There are no lesbians, but instead “le dollar beans” (le$beans). People who sell sex are “spicy accountants.” The aim is to preserve these social networks as both family- and advertiser-friendly; both parents and corporations want these spaces to be “safe.” The result is a strange blossoming of euphemisms that wouldn’t fool a 7-year-old.

Not everyone finds YouTube’s restrictions unduly onerous. The podcaster Chris Williamson, whose YouTube channel has 750,000 subscribers and releases about six videos a week, told me that he now mutes swearing in the first five minutes of videos after receiving a tip from a fellow creator. Even though his channel “brush[es] the edge of a lot of spicy topics,” he said, the only real trouble has been when he “dropped the C-bomb” 85 minutes into a two-and-a-half-hour video, which was then demonetized. “The policy may be getting tighter in other areas which don’t affect me,” he said, “but as long as I avoid C-bombs, my channel seems to be fine.” (While I was reporting this story, YouTube released an update to the guidelines clarifying the rules on swearing, and promised to review previously demonetized videos.)

[Read: Social media’s silent filter]

As a high-profile creator, Williamson has one great advantage: YouTube assigned him to a partner-manager who can help him understand the site’s guidelines. Smaller channels have to rely on impersonal, largely automated systems. Using them can feel like shouting into a void. Williamson also supplements his AdSense income from YouTube’s adverts with sponsorship and affiliate links, making demonetization less of a concern. “Any creator who is exclusively reliant on AdSense for their income is playing a suboptimal game,” he said.

Aciman, the Google spokesperson, told me that all channels on YouTube have to comply ​​with its community guidelines, which prohibit COVID-19 medical misinformation and hate speech—and that channels receiving ad revenue are held to a higher standard in order to comply with the “advertiser-friendly content guidelines.” “We rely on machine learning to evaluate millions of videos on our platform for monetization status,” Aciman added. “No system is perfect, so we encourage creators to appeal for a human review when they feel we got it wrong. As we’ve shown, we reverse these decisions when appropriate, and every appeal helps our systems get smarter over time.”

YouTube is caught in a difficult position, adjudicating between those who claim that it moderates too heavily and others who complain that it doesn’t do enough. And every demonetization is a direct hit to its own bottom line. I sympathize with the site’s predicament, while also noting that YouTube is owned by one of the richest tech companies in the world, and some of that wealth rests on a business model of light-touch, automated moderation. In the last quarter of 2022, YouTube made nearly $8 billion in advertising revenue. There’s a very good reason journalism is not as profitable as that: Imagine if YouTube edited its content as diligently as a legacy newspaper or television channel—even quite a sloppy one. Its great river of videos would slow to a trickle.








Победительница «Голоса» показала в Кремле татуировки

Искусство как память: в Театре Российской Армии прошел уникальный балетный марафон

Аналитика МТС Банка и Ozon fresh: россияне все чаще предпочитают занятия спортом, активный отдых и протеиновую продукцию

Жена Дмитрия Колдуна столкнулась с проблемами со здоровьем в Испании


Dive into these six summer reads, recommended by BI's editors

The shopping wars are heating up this July as Dollar General and Walmart offer discounts ahead of Amazon's Prime Day

Edgbaston breached: India break duck in England’s storied fortress, win by 336 runs

At Hewlett Packard Enterprise, CEO Antonio Neri is facing off against an activist investor with a history of forcing out chief execs


«Деловые Линии» открыли подразделение в Магадане

ВЦ «Раздолье» реализовал масштабный проект автоматизации крупного пищевого комбината «Ви Фрай»

QR-платежи: от простого к сложному — полный гид по современным способам оплаты

Ю.Ф.Патриотизм по-московски


Capcom cancels a presentation on Monster Hunter Wilds performance at CEDEC 2025 amid ongoing developer harassment

Ballz 2 Beat 1.1.9

Arkane Studios founder slams Microsoft for its Game Pass focus: 'At some point reality has to hit'

100 Дверей - Побег из Тюрьмы 3.7.0



Аймед — лидер в микрохирургии: премия «I’M FAMOUS» отметила достижения

Нужно ли праздновать патриотические праздники в колониях-поселениях?

Киберпреступность эволюционировала, защита не может строиться только на поиске вредоносного кода

Глобальное масштабирование: компания «Газинформсервис» участвует в обсуждении применения электронной транспортной накладной с ЕЭК ООН


Трое туристов на катамаране «Быстрый удод» пропали на Камчатке

Нужно ли праздновать патриотические праздники в колониях-поселениях?

Гарбузов: Столичный завод расширит выпуск авиадвигателей при поддержке города

Барнаул оказался в хвосте рейтинга российских городов по отраслевым зарплатам


Каникулы с Росгвардией

BABR MONSTER из Иркутска: робот как монстр «Бабр» с вертикальным спиннером на 8000 об/мин

Летний отдых по-московски: горожан ждут фестивали «Дачное Царицыно» и «Сады и огороды»

Собянин: Технополис Москва вновь лидирует среди инновационных зон России


Российские теннисистки Андреева и Шнайдер проиграли в третьем круге Уимблдона

Рублев: Нельзя показывать никаких слабостей Алькарасу

Теннисист Рублев проиграл Алькарасу в четвертом круге Уимблдона

Теннисистка Павлюченкова заявили, что судьи на Уимблдоне украли у нее гейм


Почему игра в городки становится популярной

BABR MONSTER из Иркутска: робот как монстр «Бабр» с вертикальным спиннером на 8000 об/мин

ДТП в Подмосковье: 15 пострадавших после переворота автобуса близ Старой Ситни

Экс-министр транспорта России покончил с собой после сообщения об отставке


Музыкальные новости

Музей Свиридова в Фатеже станет филиалом федерального музея и расширит свои площади

Русский кутюр и последний день перед декретом: как Ксения Собчак и Ида Галич провели время на VK Fest

«Одуванчик добра» стал одним из символов VI Семейного Форума Леонида Агутина

Певица Алена Свиридова снялась в бикини в Крыму


Аймед — лидер в микрохирургии: премия «I’M FAMOUS» отметила достижения

Киберпреступность эволюционировала, защита не может строиться только на поиске вредоносного кода

Глобальное масштабирование: компания «Газинформсервис» участвует в обсуждении применения электронной транспортной накладной с ЕЭК ООН

Искусство как память: в Театре Российской Армии прошел уникальный балетный марафон


Киберспортсмены Хакасии завоевали серебро чемпионата России

Сергей Собянин рассказал, каким будет новый детский сад в районе Внуково

В Центральном округе Росгвардии прошли мероприятия, приуроченные ко Дню семьи, любви и верности

В честь 13-летия компании «ЛокоТех» в сервисном локомотивном депо Сольвычегодск прошла праздничная лотерея


Память о монорельсе и трамваи будущего. Последние новости транспорта Москвы

Новые китайские авто на механике: топ-5 по мнению экспертов

Baza: несколько автомобилей горят у дома на Бескудниковском бульваре в Москве

Вероятная причина пожара восьми автомобилей на севере столицы


Алиев просит русских остановиться, но уже поздно: Идут аресты, депортация, бьют по экономике

Сергей Собянин рассказал, каким будет национальный центр «Россия» на Пресне

Пособия и ранний выход на пенсию: Алексей Путин — о мерах поддержки семей с детьми

«Всё для Победы!» — трёхлетие движения, объединившего страну




Кофе.net. Врач Клименко назвала напитки, которые запрещены в жару

В Москве открыты еще шесть центров женского здоровья

Врач-косметолог Мадина Осман: можно ли справиться с гравитационным птозом без пластики

В Грозном отметили 25-летие отдельного медико-санитарного батальона Росгвардии


В Раде поставили под сомнение стремление Киева к миру


Престижная награда в сфере IT-достижений досталась калининградскому тренеру

Спортсмены Росгвардии стали победителями соревнований по стрельбе из пневматического оружия

«Лето в Москве»: какие мероприятия для детей и родителей пройдут на этой неделе

Премия «Спорт и Россия»: объединяя бизнес, государство и спорт


Лукашенко потребовал к осени убрать в Белоруссии все бревна с лесных опушек

Тихановский не набрал донатов на свержение Лукашенко. Жена зовет на помощь Трампа


Собянин сообщил о лидерстве "Технополиса Москва" в рейтинге эффективности ОЭЗ

Собянин рассказал, какие масштабные проекты реализуют рядом со станциями метро

Собянин: Технополис Москва вновь лидирует среди инновационных зон России

Собянин: 250 млрд рублей вложат в развитие рабочих мест у метро Москвы


360.ru: в период аномальной жары важно надевать светлую, свободную одежду

Барнаул оказался в хвосте рейтинга российских городов по отраслевым зарплатам

Аномальная жара 30+ градусов задержится надолго: Вильфанд дал реальный прогноз по России

Синоптик Ильин: Аномальная жара в Москве и МО может сохраниться до конца июля


С начала года столичная «Система-112» приняла около четырех миллионов вызовов

Почему игра в городки становится популярной

Победительница «Голоса» показала в Кремле татуировки

ДТП в Подмосковье: 15 пострадавших после переворота автобуса близ Старой Ситни


Владимир Ефимов: В столице благоустроят набережную Захарковского карьера

Заммэра Москвы Ефимов сообщил о благоустройстве набережной Захарковского карьера

«Надо поднапрячься и тушить»: Глава Бурятии поручил увеличить силы для борьбы с огнем

Отключения коммунальных услуг в Архангельске 8 июля 2025 года


Симферополь частично остался без света

Поезда из Москвы в Крым изменят расписание осенью

Кто в Симферополе и Севастополе зарабатывает больше всех

Какой сегодня праздник: 5 июля


Летний отдых по-московски: горожан ждут фестивали «Дачное Царицыно» и «Сады и огороды»

Каникулы с Росгвардией

Собянин: 250 млрд рублей вложат в развитие рабочих мест у метро Москвы

ДТП в Подмосковье: 15 пострадавших после переворота автобуса близ Старой Ситни














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *