White Sox fans are in a real bind and it stinks

These are strange days for White Sox fans. It’s totally OK if you’re a Sox fan and you’re not sure what to think because what we’re seeing in the 2023 season is unprecedented. It leads to a really interesting existential question: What is it that you’re actually rooting for?

Most of the time the objective for a team is very clear. Either you think you are a World Series contender or you don’t. The season is long and full of mirages, but usually fans don’t assign World Series aspirations onto a team that’s unworthy. With this Sox team it’s difficult to find sure footing inside an opinion. 

The way that I see it, Sox fans are stuck rooting for two things: either the Sox are good or the American League Central is so bad that the Sox can manufacture hope. Walking into the season Sox fans were hoping for the former. Since the season has started they’ll settle for the latter. 

It doesn’t feel good to be box score-watching the way that the team, its broadcasters and the fans are at this point. Usually that’s a phenomenon that happens later in a season and is often connected to the team you root for being good enough to take advantage of it. That’s not the case with this year’s Sox team, so far. There have been plenty of nights that the entire division has lost a game and everyone stays status quo. The beginning of this week saw the Tigers sporting a nine-game losing streak and the Royals losing six in a row. The type of incompetence that the AL Central has shown would be hilarious if it wasn’t so damn sad. 

Enter the White Sox.

Despite the fact that the Sox are well below .500, they can legitimately say that they’re in the race for the division title. It seems silly to me. It might seem silly to you, but if I were on the team in any capacity, I would see hope. I want the Sox to play that way, like there’s something to be gained, but it all feels so hollow. 

Sox fans deserve a team that’s good, not a team that’s barely hanging on because the division leader can’t stay above .500 for more than a couple of days. It’s frustrating when the Sox give you glimpses of what they can be. Last week, their five-game win streak lent credence to the idea that the division could be had. Alas, the Sox have run into problems that have been all too familiar to its leadership and fans: an inconsistent bullpen, lack of hitting and injuries. 

The injuries have been the biggest nemesis for the Sox over the last few seasons. It’s become so predictable, that Sox fans fear anytime a player is listed as “day-to-day.” Why? Because it usually turns into a long IL stint. 

The worst part of the injury bug for the Sox is the lack of organizational depth. That makes for hard choices for the front office. Think about how many players have come back from an injury too soon. Maybe the player isn’t in any danger of hurting themselves further, but they’re clearly not 100 percent. The choice the Sox seem to keep making is playing a player at 75 percent because it’s probably better than playing their replacement. 

Rehabbing an injury at the major league level is folly. I struggle with judging players too harshly when they return because they clearly don’t look like themselves. It becomes unfair to the player at a certain point too. The player sells out to get back as soon as possible and when they struggle, they catch our wrath. Just once I’d love to hear one of these players defend themselves and say that they’re stuck in baseball’s version of the “Kobayashi Maru” exercise. For those of you who don’t speak geek, it’s Star Trek’s way of saying no-win. 

Personally, I’d rather the Sox be good; fighting and clawing their way to relevance, but we’re all stuck rooting against the rest of the division because it allows the Sox to stay in striking distance. It just doesn’t feel very good. Strange days indeed.

You can hear Laurence Holmes talk Chicago sports Monday to Friday from 10 a.m. to2 p.m. on 670 The Score with Dan Bernstein.