Scientists Want to Mark New Epoch of Human Impact on Earth in Canadian Lake
A geologic task force recommends marking this new epoch's start in the deep, pristine Crawford Lake outside Toronto, Canada, with a “golden spike.” The start of the human epoch is sometime around 1950 to 1954. The specific date will be determined soon, probably by levels of plutonium in new measurements from the bottom of the lake.
"It's quite clear that the scale of change has intensified unbelievably and that has to be human impact," said University of Leicester geologist Colin Waters, who chaired the Anthropocene Working Group, which is making the recommendation. "It's no longer just influencing Earth's sphere, it's actually controlling."
The burning of coal, oil and gas that's changing Earth's climate and atmosphere, nuclear bomb detonations spotted in soil around the globe, plastics and nitrogen from fertilizers added on land, and dramatic changes to species that make up the rest of the Earth characterize the new epoch, scientists said.
The idea of the Anthropocene was proposed at a science conference more than 20 years ago by the Nobel Prize-winning chemist Paul Crutzen. Teams of scientists have debated the issue for decades.
A special committee was set up to examine whether the designation was needed, when it would start and where a golden spike would be placed to commemorate the start. Such spikes commemorate new geologic time periods across the Earth.
Distinct and multiple signals starting around 1950 in Crawford Lake show that "the effects of humans overwhelm the Earth system," said Francine McCarthy, a committee member who specializes in that site as an Earth sciences professor at Brock University in Canada.
Because Crawford Lake is 24 meters (79 feet) deep but just under 2,400 square meters (25,800 square feet) in area, the layers on the lake bottom are pristine, showing what's in the air and on Earth each year, scientists said.
"The remarkably preserved annual record of deposition in Crawford Lake is truly amazing," said U.S. National Academies of Sciences President Marcia McNutt, who is not part of the committee. "It is just as important to the beginning of an era dominated by one category of Earth species as it is to mark the end."
The Anthropocene — derived from the Greek terms for “human” and “new” — shows the power and the hubris of humankind, several scientists told The Associated Press.
"The hubris is in imagining that we are in control," former U.S. White House science adviser John Holdren, who was not part of the working group of scientists and disagrees with its proposed start date, suggesting it should be much earlier. "The reality is that our power to transform the environment has far exceeded our understanding of the consequences and our capacity to change course."
Jurgen Renn, who directs the Max Planck Institute for the History of Science in Berlin and was not part of the study group, said humans also "need that power, our knowledge, our technologies, but also our capacities of making better societies" to lessen and adapt to the worst consequences of our actions.
This puts the power of humans in a somewhat similar class with the meteorite that crashed into Earth 66 million years ago killing off dinosaurs, starting the Cenozoic Era and what is sometimes called the age of mammals. But that meteorite started a whole new era, and scientists are now proposing humans started a new epoch, which is a much smaller geologic time period.
Geologists measure time in eons, eras, periods, epochs and ages. They propose we have moved from the Holocene Epoch, which started about 11,700 years ago at the end of an ice age, to the Anthropocene Epoch.
It also starts a new age. It's named Crawfordian, after the lake chosen as the starting point, and ends the Meghalayan Age that started 4,200 years ago, Waters said.
The proposal needs to be approved by three different groups of geologists and will ultimately need to be signed off at during a major conference next year.
The reason geologists didn't make it a bigger time period change is that the current Quaternary Period is based on permanent ice on Earth's poles, which still exists. But in a few hundred years, if climate change continues and those disappear, it may be time to change that, Waters said.
"If you know your Greek tragedies, you know power, hubris and tragedy go hand in hand," said Harvard science historian Naomi Oreskes, a working group member. "If we don't address the harmful aspects of human activities, most obviously disruptive climate change, we are headed for tragedy."