Добавить новость
smi24.net
News in English
Август
2023

No Final Draft

0
Doug Bandow









Washington is fighting aproxy war‐​plus with Russia, threatening China over Taiwan, mobilizing troops to confront Iran, and promising to use nuclear weapons to defend South Korea. Yet the Pentagon is failing to recruit sufficient numbers of men and women. As the all‐​volunteer force runs short on manpower, some policymakers are thinking the once unthinkable, areturn to conscription.



,






A half‐​century ago, Richard Nixon ended the draft and withdrew the last combat forces from South Vietnam. Despite arough start, the all‐​volunteer force delivered the highest quality military that America ever fielded. President George W. Bush’s Iraq debacle sapped popular enthusiasm for joining the armed forces, making it harder for the Pentagon to attract recruits, but the numbers returned to health as that conflict ended. Alas, rising demographic and budget problems today likely will prove more difficult to solve.

Relatively few 18‐​year‐​olds are qualified to serve—increasing obesity is one challenge—and interested in joining. Only the Marine Corps, the second‐​smallest branch of the military, is expected to make its objective this year. Both the Army and Air Force likely will be about 10,000 people short, and the Navy figures it will be 6,000 behind. Last year the Air Force missed its manpower target by 25 percent.



,











It would be easier to ask America’s young to defend ademocratic republic than to advance areckless empire.







,






These estimates likely underestimate the gap between military wishes and recruit realities. Knowing that it will be hard to find sufficient new accessions, as enlistees are termed, encourages military leaders to trim their manpower objectives. Two years ago Army Chief of Staff Gen. James McConville admitted that he wanted to add 70,000 to the force of nearly 485,000. Instead, he reduced the number by 12,000.

The Army vice chief of staff, Gen. Randy A. George, believes the solution is selling the armed services as astep up:



,









The trouble is, many Americans don’t realize it or believe it. Military service, to many people, seems like alife setback. In reality, it’s alife accelerator. That has certainly been my experience since Ienlisted as aprivate right out of high school. It’s agreat team with an important mission and ample opportunity to learn, grow and make an impact. And we have to get that story out.






,






What if potential recruits don’t believe him? It was one thing to join the military to combat the infamous Evil Empire, which seemed to threaten all that mattered. But dying to seize nonexistent nukes in Iraq, remake rural theocracy in Central Asia, and protect agaggle of licentious Mideast royals? Or playing wet nurse to the Europeans, who almost eight decades after the end of World War II still act helpless when confronting Moscow?

Moreover, why would any sensible recruit—speaking as someone whose father, mother, uncle, brother‐​in‐​law, and nephew all served—want to submit to the current political leadership? The egregious Madeleine Albright spoke for America’s arrogant, self‐​serving ruling class when she asked Gen. Colin Powell: “What’s the point of having this superb military you’re always talking about if we can’t use it?” To members of the infamous foreign policy “blob,” those in uniform are but acheap means to an imperial end.

Indeed, the Pentagon’s sales pitch faces surprising opposition from relatives, friends, and even veterans. Reported the Wall Street Journal:



,









The children of military families make up the majority of new recruits in the US military. That pipeline is now under threat, which is bad news for the Pentagon’s already acute recruit problems, as well as America’s military readiness. “Influencers are not telling them to go into the military,” said Adm. Mike Mullen, the former chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, in an interview. “Moms and dads, uncles, coaches and pastors don’t see it as agood choice.”






,






Moreover, enlisted personnel, who make up the bulk of the service, and their families are less likely to recommend that their children volunteer.

Such dissatisfaction reflects multiple causes, including low pay and family stress. Incompetent, stupid wars are another. More than 7,000 US military personnel and nearly 8,000 contractors died in combat since 9/11.Ashocking 30,000 military personnel and veterans of the “Global War on Terrorism” committed suicide over the same period. At least 52,000 service members were wounded in combat. However, the Watson Institute for International and Public Affairs figures that the number harmed “is exponentially larger” since the Defense Department does not count other injuries in theater as well as conditions diagnosed later.

What if Washington is unable to maintain avolunteer military large enough to dominate the globe? It isn’t easy to simultaneously protect wimpy but wealthy Europeans, combat insurgents and terrorists across ever‐​unstable Africa, maintain agaggle of undemocratic Mideast monarchies against their peoples, protect rich friends in Asia, and contain nationalistic China.

Support for conscription ebbed after President Ronald Reagan addressed recruitment problems. Even during the military’s brief Iraq‐​related travails few policymakers advocated adraft. However, the 2020 election featured several Democratic presidential candidates, including now Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg, urging mandatory national service.

More recently the conscription‐​friendly All‐​Volunteer Force Forum held aconference on the issue. Dennis Laich, aretired major general, worried about the flip‐​side of the recruitment problem, that paying higher compensation in response could be too expensive: “There just won’t be enough money to go around.” He also argued, along with another retired Army officer, Larry Wilkerson, that adraft is required “because acombination of ever‐​growing missions for the military and outside pressures on the dollars being spent their [stet] will force it.” Other participants backed various forms of coerced service.

The latest advocate is aretired Marine, Joe Plenzler:



,









We should have our military recruiters sign up new troops for 11 months out of the year, and then have the Selective Service draft the delta between the military’s needs and the total number recruited. This model would alleviate the incredible pressure on our recruiters, lower the cost of finding new troops, and significantly reduce the much decried civilian‐​military gap by subjecting all of America’s youth—rich and poor—to the possibility of military service via the draft.






,






Even limited conscription is an extraordinarily bad idea. It would be wildly unfair to those drafted, taking only afew thousand of the four million Americans who turn 18 every year. Compulsion would foster both avoidance and evasion—remember Dick “I had other priorities” Cheney? That in turn would require an expensive enforcement regime, extravagantly so given the very few people to be impressed. Since conscription would fill any unmet “needs,” the armed services would be tempted to inflate their requirements and devote less effort to meeting recruiting objectives.

Plenzler also tried moral blackmail, arguing that “military service is an important responsibility of citizenship.” Defending the nation might be such aresponsibility, but not patrolling the globe, playing international social engineer, guarding corrupt authoritarians, and using war for mundane economic and political ends, which account for most of the Pentagon’s activities. Moreover, military service isn’t the only way to help protect the homeland. Conscription is the wrong answer to avery simple problem.

Washington expects the armed services to do far too much. The military’s official manpower objectives should not be taken as agiven, as if one of the Ten Commandments. Moving to conscription would make war too easy, allowing any administration to quickly crank up personnel levels to prosecute another unpopular and stupid war, like Vietnam, or more recently Iraq and Afghanistan.

Plenzler’s tiny draft would not inhibit promiscuous war‐​making because so few people would be taken. The likelihood that the children of influential policymakers would be drafted is infinitesimal and would not likely inhibit the foreign policy establishment’s enthusiasm for war. (A better idea would be “a targeted draft enlisting the children of Pentagon brass and members of Congress,” but even that would have to be much broader, dragooning Washington’s most enthusiastic warmongers, to have much effect.)

The best way to address recruiting shortfalls would be to reduce manpower objectives. First, policymakers in both the executive and legislative branches should abandon the pursuit of primacy and shed rather than share burdens best carried by other states. George observed that soldiers are stationed in more than 140 countries. It beggars belief that most or even amajority of these deployments serve an important let alone avital U.S. interest.

Europe is richer and possesses amuch greater population than Russia. The continent should take over its own defense. The Middle East matters less internationally and especially to the U.S. Friendly states, most notably Israel and the Gulf monarchies, should cooperate to balance against potentially more aggressive states, such as Iran. South Korea is well able to defend against its impoverished northern neighbor at least in conventional terms. And friendly Asian states, including Japan and India, are capable of constraining potential Chinese aggression.

Second, Washington should adapt its force structure to changing geopolitics. Army strength should be shifted to reserve units. The likelihood of U.S. involvement in amassive land war in either Asia or Europe is minuscule—at least, launching aground campaign against either China or Russia would be idiotic, even criminal. Genuine defense resources should be concentrated on sea and air power, which are less people‐​intensive. Making such ashift would be difficult politics at home, but perhaps no harder than reinstating conscription.

Third, the American people should decide how much they are prepared to spend and risk to achieve proposed foreign ends. Washington should have the interests of Americans at its core. What potential conflicts are worth fighting, especially ones that could go nuclear? Is anational security state, including coercive military service, consistent with the freedom values that make America worth defending? The costs of one or another endless military interventions likely outweigh any plausible gain. Attracting enough recruits for even amore limited foreign policy might still be difficult and expensive. However, it would be easier to ask America’s young to defend ademocratic republic than to advance areckless empire.

Whatever Washington seeks to do internationally, it requires leaders “who can articulate our purposes both for the American people and the armed forces.” Equally important, those purposes must be legitimate. Dragging one’s countrymen into an unnecessary war is bad. Forcing one’s countrymen to fight in an unnecessary war is unforgivable. Conscription is no solution to the challenges facing the nation’s volunteer military.







Арбуз, кукуруза и холодные напитки: диетолог Садыков назвал продукты, которые портят ваш сон летом

Любовь в сердце и в «Тропикана Парк»

Хаски на Summer Sound – выиграй билеты на Like FM

Интересные каналы в Telegram. Лучшие каналы в Telegram.


Why Juventus spent 111m this summer for only one new player

OpenAI warns that its new ChatGPT Agent has the ability to aid dangerous bioweapon development

The founder of Deliciously Ella started a blog when suffering from severe chronic pain. Now, her multimillion-dollar snack empire is going global

Tourism is increasing over prepandemic levels, overwhelming popular destinations


Хаски на Summer Sound – выиграй билеты на Like FM

Дивеево ..

The sun of the North

Какие зарплаты нужны для получения льготного автокредита в 2025 году


'I destroyed months of your work in seconds' says AI coding tool after deleting a devs entire database during a code freeze: 'I panicked instead of thinking'

Microsoft warns of 'active attacks' on its government and business server tech, with one cybersecurity expert claiming that they should 'assume that you have been compromised'

Настройки GameHub и Winlator для игры в Prey (2017) на Android

The dairy industry would like Gen Z to drink more milk, so they made a Fortnite diner tycoon game



Кайрат Бермуканов поддержал Петра Яна перед боем в Абу‑Даби

Движение к победе: в России стартует премия «Мы верим твердо в героев спорта»

Студия Лебедева запустила образовательный проект, в котором заказчики сами создают свой дизайн

Аудиосказки про Турбозавров теперь на Яндекс Музыке!


T7, T4 и T8. Стало известно, когда в России начнутся продажи кроссоверов Tenet

Лицемерная политика многовекторности. "Улыбается всем": Эрдоган в обход Москвы готов дружить с Баку

Нам есть чем гордиться: каким будет Национальный центр «Россия» на Краснопресненской набережной

Движение к победе: в России стартует премия «Мы верим твердо в героев спорта»


МегаФон увеличил площадь покрытия на 17,4% за полгода

Неваляшки, танцы и футбол: фестиваль «Сады и цветы» продолжает изумлять

Синоптик Тишковец: Пик ливней пройден в столичном регионе

После избиения подростками несовершеннолетнего в Балашихе завели уголовное дело


Теннисистка Мур высказалась о проблемах в антидопинговой системе.

Штаты и расписание: что ждет наших ведущих теннисистов в США

Потапова не прошла во второй раунд турнира в Вашингтоне.

Мирра Андреева из России удерживает пятую позицию в рейтинге WTA.


Мария Шувалова. В столице Татарстана чествовали балетную диву за блистательную «Анюту»

Я слышу голоса: «Т-Технологии» опубликовали ИИ-модель, умеющую троллить мошенников

Где лето? МЧС предупредило москвичей об ухудшении погоды

Синоптик Тишковец: Пик ливней пройден в столичном регионе


Музыкальные новости

В Италии отменили концерт Гергиева 27 июля

Менеджер Артиста. Менеджер по работе с артистами.

Отреставрировать стену Цоя на Арбате к сроку не успели, закончат в ближайшие дни

Певица Клава Кока стала послом конкурса "Интервидение"


Аудиосказки про Турбозавров теперь на Яндекс Музыке!

Движение к победе: в России стартует премия «Мы верим твердо в героев спорта»

Кайрат Бермуканов поддержал Петра Яна перед боем в Абу‑Даби

Студия Лебедева запустила образовательный проект, в котором заказчики сами создают свой дизайн


"Выездные мастер-классы" Межвузовского Чемпионата КВН Санкт-Петербурга

Лео Канделаки и Анжелика Стубайло посетят Казань в новой трэвел-игре «Кто куда» на ТНТ

У России отняли исторический рекорд в фигурном катании и отдали его Америке перед Олимпиадой 2026 года в Италии

Врач Поляков: Киркоров рискует сойти с ума из-за препарата для похудения


Сильный ливень заблокировал людей в авто в центре Москвы

25 июля пилотажная группа "Звезда" пролетит над пробками на шоссе под Москвой

Москвичей предупредили о задержках наземного транспорта из-за ливня

Рискнул на 100 тысяч рублей: инженер из Смоленска купил более 1,7 тысячи лотерейных билетов и выиграл автомобиль от «Национальной Лотереи» и РОЛЬФ на VK Fest


Нам есть чем гордиться: каким будет Национальный центр «Россия» на Краснопресненской набережной

Министр юстиции поделился информацией о роли адвокатов в специальной военной операции.

Путин отметил успехи российских школьников на математической олимпиаде.

Путин отметил победу синхрониста Мальцева на чемпионате мира в Сингапуре.




«Я на инвалидном кресле, он на «Тесле»: что случилось с блогером Мариш Мариш

Уже не крепкий орешек: как Брюс Уиллис живет с неизлечимой болезнью

Офтальмолог Кирилл Светлаков: секреты здоровых глаз для тех, кто носит контактные линзы

Собянин: создание 5 центров женского здоровья завершат в этом году


В центре Киева митингуют против реформ Зеленского

«СТРАНА.ua»: Зеленский раскритиковал ЕС за непредоставление обещанной помощи


Движение к победе: в России стартует премия «Мы верим твердо в героев спорта»

KENGURU GAMES в Звенигороде звенели на всю страну

Уже 59 орловчан решили побороться за просветительскую награду «Знание. Премия»

Кайрат Бермуканов поддержал Петра Яна перед боем в Абу‑Даби


Посланник Трампа рассказал, как «неформально» договаривался с Лукашенко: после нескольких тостов Минск освободил политзаключенных

Лукашенко призвал белорусских нефтяников «не раскачиваться, а бурить и бурить»

Куда Лукашенко хочет пристроить лишних дипломатов


Собянин рассказал, как город заботится о природе при строительстве метро

Собянин: Продолжаем внедрять новый стандарт заботы о женском здоровье в одном месте

Более 800 спортивных площадок обновят и обустроят в Москве - Сергей Собянин

Собянин: Модернизация двух корпусов ГКБ имени Вересаева завершится в этом году


Зарядки для электромобилей «Энергия Москвы» станут платными

Экономист оценил экологический и финансовый ущерб от пластиковых пакетов

Фестиваль «Сады и цветы»: как Москву превращают в городской оазис

Уже 59 орловчан решили побороться за просветительскую награду «Знание. Премия»


Где лето? МЧС предупредило москвичей об ухудшении погоды

Мария Шувалова. В столице Татарстана чествовали балетную диву за блистательную «Анюту»

Москва отменяется: героиня шоу «Мама в 16» дала еще один шанс отцу своего ребенка и возвращается в Симферополь

Мебель, которой доверяют профессионалы — в "Аверсе"


В Нарьян-Маре из-за холодов возобновили подачу отопления в дома

Центр подготовки личного состава Северо-Западного округа Росгвардии пополнили призывники

В Башкирии ревнивец ранил жену шампуром и сдался полиции

Республика Алтай вошла в десятку регионов России по развитию ипотеки


Поезда "Таврия" по-прежнему задерживаются из-за ЧП в Ростовской области

В Симферополе на базе «Клинического госпиталя для ветеранов войн» функционирует гериатрический центр для пожилых людей с возрастными нарушениями

Поезда в Крым и из Крыма следуют с задержками до пяти часов

В Симферополе наградили юных крымчан за отвагу и решительность


«Для нас это тоже чудо»: бегун-юниор Данилов побил рекорд, установленный на Олимпиаде-1980

Мария Шувалова. В столице Татарстана чествовали балетную диву за блистательную «Анюту»

Пост №6137249

Под Тамбовом пройдёт фестиваль авторской песни "Там, под Лысой Горой"














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *