Добавить новость
smi24.net
News in English
Август
2023

A Different Kind of College Ranking

0

Over the past year, a steady flow of institutions of higher education have withdrawn from U.S. News & World Report’s increasingly troubled college rankings. First, in November 2022, several prestigious law and medical schools departed, including Stanford, Yale, Penn, and Harvard. Then, this past winter and spring, four well-regarded colleges—Bard, Stillman, Colorado College, and Rhode Island School of Design—announced that they would no longer cooperate with the magazine’s rankings. And finally, in June, Columbia became the first top university to stop participating in the undergraduate rankings, expressing concern about their “outsize influence.” The latter wasn’t the brave stand that it might have seemed—Columbia had fallen 16 places in the prior year’s list after one of its professors revealed that administrators had been juking the stats—but no matter: After years of criticism over U.S. News’s unreliable, prestige-obsessed reign over American higher ed, an exodus has begun. 

What are these schools rebelling against? In their announcements, similar phrases pop up again and again: “outsize influence,” “the tyranny of rankings.” College administrators clearly resent the power that U.S. News has over how they run their institutions. But there was another current within the flood of “Dear John” letters, a sense that the rankings’ priorities are hindering, not helping, schools’ professed commitment to public service. Take Harvard, which objected that U.S. News’s methodology makes it harder to “enhance the socioeconomic diversity of our classes” and “allocate financial aid to students based on need.” Or take RISD, which complained that the metrics are “unambiguously biased in favor of wealth, privilege and opportunities that are inequitably distributed.” To be sure, Harvard and, to some degree, RISD also embrace policies that are “unambiguously biased” toward the rich and powerful. (Legacy admissions, anyone?) But their paeans to the cause of inclusion speak to a broader shift in public opinion, a disgust with the self-serving institutions of the elite that can no longer be ignored.

The clamor for these changes is so loud that even U.S. News is listening. In May, the publication announced that it would begin tracking colleges’ success in graduating students from diverse backgrounds and remove alumni donations and class sizes as factors in its rankings, among other measures. Small changes, but a recognition, at last, that something is fundamentally off.

Now more than ever, we need a better set of benchmarks for what “excellence” is in higher education, ones that measure what colleges do for their country, instead of for themselves. The Washington Monthly’s college rankings try to do just that, by rating institutions on their commitment to three goals: social mobility, public service, and research. Rather than laud the universities that mostly cater to the sons and daughters of the wealthy, we reward those that welcome students from everyday and low-income backgrounds and help them to graduate on time, with good jobs and low debt. Rather than rely on vague surveys of institutions’ “reputation” for academic prowess, we measure hard data on research spending, faculty awards, and rates of PhD attainment among graduates. And instead of boosting universities for how generous their alumni are in giving to their endowments, we rank the generosity of alumni toward their community: How many join the Peace Corps and the military, or pursue careers as social workers or teachers?

This year, the top performers in the Monthly’s rankings once again highlight this difference in priorities. Some traditionally prestigious names appear on our list of 442 national universities—at first place, followed by Stanford and MIT, is Harvard, with its exceptionally high graduation rate, its cheap net cost for students from middle-to-low-income families (fourth best in the nation, at an annual $1,758), its prize-laden faculty, and a comparatively high rate of graduates sent into AmeriCorps, the Peace Corps, and ROTC programs. But we also recognize public universities that, without cracking that “elite” echelon, elevate students of humble backgrounds into community-minded graduates with strong economic prospects—like 19th-ranked Florida International University, a perennial leader in our list that goes underrecognized in the other one (where it was tied for 151st last year). FIU rose 13 places in our 2023 rankings, fueled by its continued commitment to enrolling Pell Grant students, shepherding them through at a low cost that’s comparable to what much richer universities can afford, and graduating them into jobs with respectable incomes. Another such school is California State University, Fresno, tied for 250th on the other list but ranked 26th on ours, ahead of Dartmouth and the University of Chicago. Located in the continental U.S.’s third-largest majority-Hispanic city (Miami, home of FIU, is fourth), Cal State Fresno costs about the same, net, as Princeton, which has $35.8 billion to splash on its undergraduates. At the same time, the NorCal state school graduates more Pell recipients than the New Jersey Ivy, both in absolute terms and compared to predicted numbers.

Brown University, as wealthy and selective as they come, rises only as far as number 43. Despite being fairly affordable for those who make it through its iconic wrought-iron gates, the Providence school makes very little effort to enroll students who actually need the help. Its graduates enter national and military service at abysmally low rates for an institution of its reputation (128th and 205th), and comparatively few pursue service-oriented majors. Meanwhile, Brown spends much less on research compared to its peers. 

Harvey Mudd tops our list of liberal arts schools this year, whereas under the prevailing orthodoxy it typically trails the leading pack. We rank the Claremont science and engineering college so highly because it leads in two key categories—the actual versus predicted earnings of its recent graduates, and the number who go on to earn PhDs. Right behind it is a perennial Monthly favorite, Berea College, which is the best in the nation at enrolling low-income students, and among the best at getting them to the podium on Commencement Day—at exceptionally low cost. Sought-after Carleton College ranks only 36th out of 199; it costs a pretty penny, is far worse at getting its students to complete their degrees than you might expect, and sends them on to surprisingly low-paying jobs in the decade after graduation. (Although they do pursue advanced degrees at a high rate, which could partially explain the lagging post-college income.)

Each year we rank roughly 850 bachelor’s and master’s institutions, as well. Many, like Elizabeth City State University, a historically Black college in North Carolina that ranks second among bachelor’s-granting schools, go unheralded by the prestige measurers even as they quietly graduate thousands of underprivileged students into well-paying jobs. Since 2021, ECSU has climbed 11 places thanks to its incredibly low cost to students and its efforts to enroll Pell recipients and keep them in school, which it does at a rate only 5 percent below the mean. SUNY Geneseo tops our master’s list, ahead of no fewer than seven Cal State campuses in the top 11. The Finger Lakes–area school excels in our research and service metrics, sending an extraordinary number of students on to doctoral degrees and the Peace Corps. Meanwhile, Cal State Northridge, the third-ranked master’s school, graduates more Pell recipients each year—3,779—than the entire Ivy League combined, and charges them about what Cornell and Dartmouth do, while splitting its $203.5 million endowment among 36,000 students and somehow also managing to rank eighth in research spending among its peers. Near the bottom is DeVry University in Ontario. This California campus of the for-profit chain charges an arm and a leg to low-income students—$28,207 a year—who go on to underperform their peers’ incomes by nearly 25 percent, a significant problem with all that tuition to pay off.

The other big news this year has been the growing conservative attack on higher education. Several GOP governors, most prominently Florida’s Ron DeSantis, have been cracking down on academic freedom in their state universities in the name of fighting “woke” values. Such tactics might bring short-term political gains, James Fallows argues in this issue, but are self-defeating in the long run (“What’s the Matter With Florida?”). They appeal to a shrinking number of noncollege-educated voters, while alienating a growing mass of voters with college degrees. They also sap the vitality of institutions that are major drivers of a state’s economic growth—Florida, for instance, is experiencing record-high numbers of faculty resignations and departures from its universities. DeSantis’s relentless campaign against higher education might well be weakening institutions like FIU that serve the working-class people he claims to champion.

Meanwhile, this summer, the Supreme Court’s conservative supermajority struck down affirmative action, leaving in place legacy admission for wealthy whites while reversing precedent that had allowed schools to prioritize spots for minorities. But as several writers note in this issue, the dream of diversity isn’t dead. As Monthly editor Will Norris reports, the military has long run preparatory schools that help underprepared minorities boost their academic scores so they can gain admission to elite officer training academies like West Point without lowering standards—a strategy selective civilian colleges and universities should adopt (“How the Military Can Save Affirmative Action”). Meanwhile, Jamaal Abdul-Alim tracks the growth of “direct admission” programs, which reduce barriers for low-income and first-generation students, many of them people of color, by encouraging colleges to proactively notify qualified candidates of their acceptance—before they’ve even applied (“When Colleges Apply to Students”). Anne Kim casts a jaundiced eye on certificate programs offered by tech giants like Google that allegedly can land high-paying jobs for workers without a full degree (“Google’s Participation Trophies”). And finally, Raquel Rall, Demetri Morgan, and Richard Chait pull back the curtain on university boards, which claim to care about the diversity of their students but keep their own diversity numbers secret—until now (“Does Your Board of Trustees Reflect Your Student Body?”). 

The day after the affirmative action decision, the Court also blocked President Joe Biden’s effort to forgive $430 billion in student loans. “The fight is not over,” Biden said that day. He has since launched another debt forgiveness measure under different legal authority and a new income-based repayment plan that would greatly lower monthly payments and eventually forgive some principal for lower- and middle-income borrowers. Both plans face likely court battles. As the historian Jonathan Zimmerman chronicles in “Higher Ed’s Founding Promise,” the struggle to enshrine college as an affordable public good is as old as the republic. Another president, George Washington, willed a portion of his estate to create a national university for the benefit of all (his wishes were thwarted by political chicanery), and later, Justin Morrill, the architect of the 19th-century land grant universities, desired that they should be “accessible to all, but especially the sons of toil.” 

Here at the Monthly, we’re proud to contribute to that struggle with our annual college guide, which aims to hold institutions—and the governments that fund them—to their promises of affordability and public service. Let’s say the exodus from U.S. News continues. What happens if, instead of competing to rise in its rankings, colleges vie to do well in ours? With the reader’s indulgence, we might imagine this utopia. Here, colleges strive to let in more low- and middle-income students, instead of courting the privileged offspring of wealthy donors. Administrators encourage their undergraduates to spend at least part of their careers serving others as teachers or soldiers, instead of plunging directly into investment banking and private equity. They fall over one another to fund research into climate solutions. They make it as easy as possible for their students to vote. They fight to reverse the reigning system of inequality, rather than perpetuate it through the relentless pursuit of wealth and prestige.

A pretty picture. For now, the sons and daughters of toil can only dream of it.

The post A Different Kind of College Ranking appeared first on Washington Monthly.








Арбуз, кукуруза и холодные напитки: диетолог Садыков назвал продукты, которые портят ваш сон летом

В студии Детского радио прошла церемония гашения почтовой марки

Состоялось открытие фотовыставки «Особенная красота»

Раздвигая горы - к единству и созиданию! Манифест лезгинского народа (письменное обращение, воззвание программного характера)


Adil Rami carga contra Lamine: "No puedo ni verlo, que le den..."

Brit Who Fought Usyk Calls For Daniel Dubois To ‘Leave The Sport’ After Staying Down In Rematch

Las 'Guerreras del Agua' se dan un baño de bronce en el Mundial de Singapur

Why Juventus spent 111m this summer for only one new player


Возбуждено первое в России уголовное дело о дропперстве

Игровые терминалы в ТЦ: союз ради будущего

НПС построит новые съезды с Северо-Восточной хорды

«Деловые Линии» сократили сроки авиаперевозок по более чем 4400 направлений по России


'I destroyed months of your work in seconds' says AI coding tool after deleting a devs entire database during a code freeze: 'I panicked instead of thinking'

Brütal Legend is free in honor of Ozzy Osbourne, but only for 666 minutes

Краткая биографическая справка о центральных персонажах Mafia: The Old Country

Microsoft warns of 'active attacks' on its government and business server tech, with one cybersecurity expert claiming that they should 'assume that you have been compromised'



В Москве завершился сбор с руководителями финансово-экономических подразделений Центрального округа Росгвардии

В Третьяковке на Кадашевской набережной открылся концертный зал

Оркестр полиции Республики Сербской впервые выступит на фестивале «Спасская башня» в Москве

«Каникулы с Росгвардией» проходят в регионах Центральной России


Работа над качеством: цифровой аудитор внедрен на горячей линии московских судов

В студии Детского радио прошла церемония гашения почтовой марки

Оркестр полиции Республики Сербской впервые выступит на фестивале «Спасская башня» в Москве

Вредоносный код в Firefox: атака на цепочку поставок через NPM-пакеты


Ветеринары напомнили жителям Подмосковья о необходимости вакцинации питомцев

Врач Галлямова: сухие шампуни могут навредить коже головы

Патрушев: Британия пыталась провокацией на Балтике сорвать переговоры РФ и США

Ошибка Баку: На "красивый кавказский обычай" нашлась русская пословица


Россиянин Сидоренко выиграл соревнования по настольному теннису на Универсиаде‑2025

Фриц пробился в четвертьфинал турнира в Вашингтоне.

Теннисистка Саккари спасла жука во время матча на турнире в США

Винус Уильямс — самая возрастная победительница матча WTA с 2004 года


В Самарской области за полгода открыто 410 вакансий для сисадминов, что на 22% меньше, чем годом ранее

Ошибка Баку: На "красивый кавказский обычай" нашлась русская пословица

Патрушев: Британия пыталась провокацией на Балтике сорвать переговоры РФ и США

Врач Щетинина: натуральные соки могут навредить здоровью пожилых


Музыкальные новости

Баста трогательно поздравил жену с днём рождения: «Вечная любовь»

Симона Юнусова честно высказалась о популярности своего сына Тимати

В сквере Цоя на Зверинской сделали граффити с Оззи Осборном

Скандальный Сергей Шнуров неожиданно снял стильный путеводитель по Костроме


В Москве завершился сбор с руководителями финансово-экономических подразделений Центрального округа Росгвардии

Оркестр полиции Республики Сербской впервые выступит на фестивале «Спасская башня» в Москве

В Третьяковке на Кадашевской набережной открылся концертный зал

Оркестр полиции Республики Сербской впервые выступит на фестивале «Спасская башня» в Москве


«Спартак» - «Балтика»: прогноз + статистика встреч

Модель Анастасия Решетова перенесла вирус с осложнениями

Движение к победе: в России стартует премия «Мы верим твердо в героев спорта»

Невозможное возможно: две подопечные фонда «Жизнь в Движении» с ограниченными возможностями покорят вершину Эльбруса


На МКАД в Москве произошло массовое ДТП, движение затруднено

Несколько автомобилей столкнулись на внешней стороне 92-го км МКАД

В Москве росгвардейцы оказали помощь пострадавшей в ДТП мотоциклистке (видео)

Водитель Audi сбил трех пешеходов, переходивших дорогу на западе Москвы


Соболезнования в связи с авиакатастрофой в Амурской области выразили зарубежные лидеры

В сентябре Путину будет представлена обновленная программа строительства кораблей для ВМФ.

"Ультиматум Трампа: потенциальные последствия для Путина"

У Путина есть роскошный подарок для Китая: США схватились за голову, узнав о нем


Обнаружен новый штамм коронавируса: он очень заразный и забирает голос

Депздрав: новый штамм коронавируса «стратус» фиксируют в Москве с мая

Новый штамм коронавируса "стратус" фиксируют в Москве с мая

Депздрав Москвы оценил ситуацию с распространением нового штамма коронавируса



Фитнес-марафоны на паузе: суд продлил домашний арест блогеру Лерчек

Депздрав Москвы: новый штамм коронавируса "стратус" фиксируют в Москве с мая

Пластический хирург Софья Абдулаева: подтяжка груди нитями - эффективно ли это

Новый штамм коронавируса "стратус" фиксируют в Москве с мая


Британский журналист: Зеленский - мелкий жулик и крыса, которому «недолго осталось» в этом мире


«Каникулы с Росгвардией» проходят в регионах Центральной России

Пять земельных участков для размещения НКО доступны на городских торгах

"Монсон о спортсменах, которые меняют гражданство в сложный период для России"

Две трети россиян считают, что спортсмены зарабатывают слишком много


Лукашенко заявил, что в Белоруссии «на всякий случай» готовятся к войне

Лукашенко поделился мнением о самой идеальной профессии.

Лукашенко с иронией отнесся к санкциям, запрещающим ему въезд в Эстонию

Лукашенко посоветовал не злить его и не допускать падежа в животноводстве


Сергей Собянин осмотрел Дом-музей Федора Конюхова

Сергей Собянин поздравил москвича — победителя международной олимпиады по физике

Мэр Москвы: Улучшим транспортную доступность Южного и Северного Бутова

Сергей Собянин. Главное за день


Исследование выявило снижение инвестиций в экологически чистую энергетику США.

6 лет вместе. В Москве пройдет выставка, посвященная пандам Жуи и Диндин

Детеныш краснокнижной боливийской обезьяны появился на свет в Московском зоопарке

Московские студенты начали исследовать влияние климатических изменений на сток рек Ямала


Врач Галлямова: сухие шампуни могут навредить коже головы

Пенсионерам с 26 июля поступит на счет разовая выплата с четырьмя нулями

Ветеринары напомнили жителям Подмосковья о необходимости вакцинации питомцев

Участник ЛизаАлерт из Бурятии помог спасти мужчину в лесу подмосковья


В Нарьян-Маре из-за холодов возобновили подачу отопления в дома

70 участников СВО в Архангельске показали мотивацию выше госслужащих — Цыбульский

В Архангельске началось обучение бойцов СВО, сообщил Цыбульский.

Путин дал указание рассмотреть проблемы онкологии в Архангельской области.


В Симферополе на базе «Клинического госпиталя для ветеранов войн» функционирует гериатрический центр для пожилых людей с возрастными нарушениями

Россияне выбирают Крым для отдыха с детьми – названы города-лидеры

"Россия дала мне возможность быть счастливым": Джефф Монсон в Крыму

Лавандовое поле горит в Симферопольском районе Крыма


Врач Галлямова: сухие шампуни могут навредить коже головы

Ошибка Баку: На "красивый кавказский обычай" нашлась русская пословица

Пир на Волге и новый штамм ковида: главные новости Ярославля за 24 июля

Врач Щетинина: натуральные соки могут навредить здоровью пожилых














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *