Добавить новость
smi24.net
News in English
Сентябрь
2023

Political warnings and accusations of misconduct: 6 main themes emerge in Paxton’s impeachment trial

0

By Chuck Lindell

The Texas Tribune

Sign up for The Brief, The Texas Tribune’s daily newsletter that keeps readers up to speed on the most essential Texas news.

"Political warnings and accusations of misconduct: 6 main themes emerge in first week of Ken Paxton’s impeachment trial" was first published by The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan media organization that informs Texans — and engages with them — about public policy, politics, government and statewide issues.

The first week of suspended Attorney General Ken Paxton’s history-making impeachment trial closed Friday with only four prosecution witnesses taking the stand in the first four days.

Even so, the broad strokes of the cases being presented by lawyers for the House impeachment managers and Paxton’s defense team emerged in Tuesday’s opening statements and during frequently tedious, sometimes contentious questioning of witnesses.

Among the many subplots, these themes are likely to guide a trial that could take several additional weeks — ending when senators deliberate in private and emerge to cast votes that will determine whether the three-term Republican will return to work or be permanently removed from office.

Paxton attended the opening hours of his trial on Tuesday, during which senators overwhelmingly rejected his attempts to dismiss the articles of impeachment and his lawyer entered not guilty pleas on his behalf. He was absent the rest of the week.

The trial is set to resume Monday at 9 a.m.

Defense team challenges loyalty, evidence

Under trial rules adopted by the Senate, prosecutors began presenting their case first, and they chose to lead with three former high-ranking officials of the attorney general’s office — all of whom reported Paxton to the FBI on Sept. 30, 2020 before quitting or being fired.

Three Paxton lawyers split cross examination of the opening witnesses, and all three hit on similar themes.

Lead defense lawyer Tony Buzbee equated reporting Paxton to the FBI as an act of betrayal. By going behind the attorney general’s back, he said, Paxton was deprived of the opportunity to answer questions that could have cleared matters up.

“You went to the FBI uninformed, isn’t that true?” Buzbee asked Jeff Mateer, Paxton’s former second in command and the first prosecution witness.

“I would not say that, sir,” Mateer replied Tuesday.

[Who’s who in the Ken Paxton impeachment trial, from key participants to potential witnesses]

Defense lawyer Mitch Little picked up the theme during his aggressive questioning of the third prosecution witness, Ryan Vassar, former deputy attorney general for legal counsel, on Thursday.

In an extensive back and forth, Little suggested that Paxton was due the courtesy of a warning after nurturing Vassar’s career. More importantly, Little added, failing to let Paxton address their concerns left Vassar and other whistleblowers uninformed when they met with FBI agents to accuse Paxton of criminal acts.

Little said the whistleblowers had no direct knowledge, let alone evidence such as invoices, of wrongdoing regarding allegations that Austin real estate investor Nate Paul offered bribes by paying to renovate Paxton’s home and employing the woman Paxton was dating outside of his marriage.

“You went to the FBI on Sept. 30 with your compatriots and reported the elected attorney general of this state for a crime without any evidence, yes?” Little asked.

Vassar tried to qualify his answer several times, but Little repeatedly objected, stating it was a yes or no question.

“That’s right, we took no evidence,” Vassar finally stated.

On Friday, Rusty Hardin, a lawyer for the impeachment managers, sought to clear up the impression left by Vassar.

Vassar said he believed Little was referring to “documents, documentary evidence,” adding that he intended the FBI to find the truth, not conduct his own investigation.

“Did you give the FBI evidence?” Hardin asked.

“Our experience was evidence,” Vassar replied. “But we did not conduct our own investigation to provide documentary evidence of what we had learned. … I believed that I was a witness to criminal activity that had occurred by General Paxton.”

Prosecutors focus on “egregious misconduct”

State Rep. Andrew Murr, R-Junction, gave the opening statement on behalf of the House impeachment managers. He promised senators would hear testimony portraying Paxton as obsessed with helping Paul — who was under state and federal investigation for his business dealings — despite warnings and objections from his top lieutenants at the agency.

Paxton engaged in “egregious misconduct,” he said.

“The state’s top lawyer engaged in conduct designed to advance the economic interests and legal positions of a friend and donor to the detriment of innocent Texans,” Murr said, adding that Paxton “turned the keys of the office of attorney general over to Nate Paul.”

Ryan Bangert, Paxton’s former deputy first assistant attorney general, testified Wednesday and Thursday that Paxton took an unusual interest in matters involving Paul, such as pressing to overrule two agency decisions that denied Paul access to documents related to an active investigation into Paul’s businesses.

“We were devoting far more resources to Nate Paul than we ever should have,” Bangert said.

“I was deeply concerned that the name, authority and power of our office had been, in my view, hijacked to serve the interests of an individual against the interests of the broader public,” Bangert added. “It was unconscionable.”

[“Operation Deep Sea”: How Nate Paul pulled the strings in the attorney general’s office to investigate his enemies]

On Friday, impeachment lawyers called their fourth witness, David Maxwell, Paxton’s former director of law enforcement. Maxwell was out of state when seven senior agency officials reported Paxton to the FBI in 2020. Instead, Maxwell took his concerns to other law enforcement officials and was later fired from the agency.

Maxwell said he found Paul’s complaint to be “absolutely ludicrous,” including claims that search warrants were improperly altered in a web of conspiracy that included a federal magistrate judge.

As a result, Maxwell said, he urged Paxton to drop his interest in Paul. “I told him that Nate Paul was a criminal … and that, if he didn’t get away from this individual and stop doing what he was doing, he was going to get himself indicted.”

Defense: Paxton did not exceed his authority

Defense lawyers, in opening statements and in questions to prosecution witnesses, pushed back on claims that Paxton acted illegally when he pressed his agency’s lawyers and employees to take actions that were helpful to Paul.

When Vassar testified that Paxton broke internal rules on hiring outside lawyers to appoint Houston attorney Brandon Cammack to investigate Paul’s complaint, Little pointed to state law to argue that Paxton — as the elected leader of the attorney general’s office — had the power to approve Cammack’s contract.

Defense lawyer Dan Cogdell, in opening statements Tuesday, said Paxton hired Cammack in understandable frustration because employees of the attorney general’s office “did little to nothing” to investigate Paul’s serious complaint that his home and business had been improperly searched by state and federal officials.

Similarly, several Paxton lawyers disputed allegations that Paxton improperly directed his agency’s lawyers to intervene in an Austin charity’s lawsuit against Paul, arguing that he had clear authority to run his agency.

Prosecutors push back on several fronts

Under questioning from House impeachment lawyer Dick DeGuerin, Maxwell pushed back on claims that Paul’s complaints had been brushed off without proper investigation. A forensic analysis of the search warrants found nothing to support Paul’s claim that the documents had been improperly altered, he said.

After Buzbee opened his case by stating that “nothing of significance” had been exchanged between Paxton and Paul, lawyers for the House impeachment team pressed their witnesses to explain how Paul benefited from Paxton’s repeated interventions.

A legal opinion, published with unusual speed at 1 a.m. on a Sunday in 2020, took a highly unusual position at Paxton’s insistence, Bangert testified. The attorney general’s office had led efforts to reopen Texas several months into the pandemic, yet Paxton demanded that the opinion say local COVID-19 safety rules barred property foreclosure sales.

Only later did it become known that Paul’s lawyer referred to the agency’s opinion letter to avoid foreclosure sales of several Paul properties two days later, Bangert said.

Buzbee warns of potential political consequences

In opening statements laying out Paxton’s case, Buzbee sounded a political warning.

Impeachment could become a common tactic of political retribution if Paxton — a leading conservative legal voice on abortion, immigration and other key issues — were to be convicted and removed from office, he argued.

“Let’s be clear. If this misguided effort is successful … the precedent it will set would be perilous for any elected official in the state of Texas,” Buzbee said.

Buzbee also argued that impeachment thwarted the will of Texas voters.

“Texans chose at the voting booth who they wanted to be their attorney general … but because of what this House has done, only 30 [senators] out of almost 30 million will decide if Ken Paxton is allowed to serve in the office he was voted into,” he said. “That’s not how it’s supposed to work. That’s not democratic.”

Impeachment team counters with its own political focus

Murr rejected arguments that impeachment violated democratic principles, saying the framers of the Texas Constitution did not believe elections alone could protect the public from abusive office holders.

“It’s too easy to use the powers of office to conceal the truth,” Murr said in opening statements. “The voters did not, and do not, know the whole truth” because Paxton went to great lengths to conceal his misconduct, he added.

Impeachment lawyers also focused on the ultraconservative political beliefs held by their first three witnesses — all attorneys who praised Paxton’s priorities that, as one put it, turned the Texas attorney general’s office into a beacon of the conservative legal movement.

Mateer worked on Capitol Hill for two Texas Republican stalwarts, Tom DeLay and Dick Armey, and is now chief legal officer of First Liberty Institute, a Christian legal defense organization that focuses on religious liberty issues. His nomination for federal judge by President Donald Trump was thwarted by controversy over statements critical of transgender youth.

Bangert is a senior vice president for the Alliance Defending Freedom, a legal advocacy group focused on religious freedom and limiting abortion and LGBTQ+ rights, and he had previous ties to the Christian Coalition.

Vassar worked for notable conservative judges, including Don Willett, a former Texas Supreme Court justice named to a federal appeals court by Trump. Vassar also was a summer fellow for former Republican Gov. Rick Perry.

Paxton has blamed the impeachment on political opposition to his deeply conservative principles, but Mateer, Bangert and Vassar testified that they reluctantly took their concerns to the FBI after concluding that Paxton was misusing his authority on Paul’s behalf.








Московские врачи провели младенцу сложнейшую операцию на поджелудочной железе

Ана Каспарян поднимает вопросы Геноцида армян, этнических чисток в Арцахе и роли Израиля в конфликте — в откровенном интервью с Такером Карлсоном. ВИДЕО

В Балаково зазвучало веселое радио

Эксперт по антиквариату и сервировке Регина ван Влит: как отличить антиквариат от ненужного старья


Today in History: July 28, US Army airplane crashes into Empire State Building

Kolo Muani: Juventus prepare new offer but face Man United and Chelsea threat

Chat log from R20 of 2025: Richmond vs Collingwood

Dear Abby: Our son was clean and fit until Emily came along


Эксперт по антиквариату и сервировке Регина ван Влит: как отличить антиквариат от ненужного старья

На Московской столкнулись автобус и легковушка. Пострадала женщина

Под Орлом автомобиль врезался в земляной вал: водитель в больнице

Отечественные технологии для корпоративного рынка: СУБД Nexign Nord получила сертификат совместимости с Astra Linux


Today's Wordle answer for Monday, July 28

Fretless — The Wrath of Riffson — музыка спасёт мир. Рецензия

Quarantine Zone creator reveals 3 reasons the zombie sim went viral on TikTok

Five Nights at Freddy's 2 movie gets its first full trailer for Comic-Con, promising even more animatronic terror



От «Лебединого озера» до «Дон Кихота»: Relax FM приглашает на балет

Клиника гнатологии – лечение ВНЧС и восстановление прикуса

В РПЦ объяснили отсутствие маркировки на святой воде в храмах

Культовый BAW 212 уже в России


"Главпродукт" окончательно перешёл государству

Александр Михайлов (GSOC): «Безопасность IT-экосистемы — это зона нулевого доверия к подрядчикам»

США лишили Путина чёрного пояса: Расплата пришла быстро. Китай — об изощренной мести Кремля

От «Лебединого озера» до «Дон Кихота»: Relax FM приглашает на балет


Школьники из ЯНАО улучшили свои знания на олимпиадной смене в Подмосковье

86-летняя калужанка отдала незнакомцу 1 миллион рублей "на проверку подлинности"

Bloomberg: Пожары в Лос-Анджелесе вызвали небесные убытки по страховкам.

Международная выставка «Вечная Женственность» открылась в Ступине


Россиянка Калинская уступила канадке Фернандес в финале турнира WTA

Калинская поднялась на 17 позиций в обновленном рейтинге WTA

Радукану вспомнила, как предложила Рыбакиной выступить в парном разряде

«Краснодар» — «Локо», UFC и матч Калинской: что посмотреть сегодня


В России ужесточили выдачу микрозаймов

"Аэрофлот" сообщил о возобновлении нормальной работы по расписанию

Росгвардия и МЧС провели пожарно-тактическое занятие в Чеченской Республике

Курьер мошенников похитил у пенсионерки более 300 тысяч рублей: молодой человек заключён под стражу


Музыкальные новости

Келли Осборн вспомнила один из трогательных моментов с Оззи Осборном

Ресторан рэпера Басты откроют в Красноярске

Варвава Визбор рассказала об особом отношении к деду Юрию Визбору

Оззи Осборна решили похоронить в Бирмингеме 30 июля


Слушатели ENERGY отправятся на «Пикник Афиши» в Петербурге

Сотрудница подразделения столичного главка Росгвардии завоевала «золото» на чемпионате войск по легкоатлетическому кроссу

Культовый BAW 212 уже в России

Приключения в Дагестане: Comedy Radio рекомендует «Атель-Матель»


Собянин рассказал о тестировании ИИ-системы для диагностики инсульта

Культовый BAW 212 уже в России

«Марионетка США». Захарова пригвоздила Токио за атаку на Россию и восхитила японцев – изменят ли курс поклонники Обамы?

"Локомотив" обыграл "Краснодар" со счетом 2:1 во втором туре РПЛ


ДТП с участием трех автомобилей произошло на внутренней стороне 104 километра МКАД

Сотрудники ОМОН Росгвардии помогли пострадавшему в ДТП на МКАД

Культовый BAW 212 уже в России

В Москве 2 будет ограничено движение автомобилей


Путин сделал шутку о системе "Оплата с помощью улыбки".

Греф представил Путину отчет о деятельности Сбербанка.

Путин поделился достижениями России в области технологий искусственного интеллекта.

"Ъ": Москва облегчила жизнь молдаванам в России


Новый штамм COVID-19 переносится как легкая форма ОРВИ


Депутата ЗакСа Ленобласти Ивана Апостолевского задержали за пост с Навальным*


Медицинские справки для школьников в центре ВИТА

Клиника гнатологии – лечение ВНЧС и восстановление прикуса

Врач-косметолог Зухра Балакеримова: как замедлить старение кожи

Обрушение в санатории "Москва" в Кисловодске: пострадали двое отдыхающих


Чтобы убрать Зеленского, США достаточно показать ему одну папку: вот почему Киев упал в ноги Трампу


Чемпионат по военно-спортивному многоборью среди росгвардейцев завершился в Грозном

Сотрудница подразделения столичного главка Росгвардии завоевала «золото» на чемпионате войск по легкоатлетическому кроссу

Легкоатлеты из Мордовии показали лучшие результаты мирового сезона на международных соревнованиях в Москве

В День парашютиста героем рубрики «Знай наших» стал сотрудник вневедомственной охраны столичного главка Росгвардии младший лейтенант полиции Александр С.


В Минске готовы активизировать сотрудничество с Эфиопией

Лукашенко сообщил о телефонном разговоре с Путиным

Лукашенко взял на контроль ситуацию с уничтожением БПЛА над Минском


Мэр Москвы рассказал о развитии бывшей промзоны «Кирпичные улицы»

Собянин: Участие москвичей в жизни города — ключ ко всем позитивным изменениям

Собянин рассказал о тестировании уникальной ИИ-системы для диагностики инсульта

Собянин рассказал, как строят станцию «Достоевская» Кольцевой линии метро


Число пострадавших от непогоды автомобилей растет

В Бузулукском бору в эти дни работает смена проекта «Заповедное дело РГО»

Bloomberg: Пожары в Лос-Анджелесе вызвали небесные убытки по страховкам.

Александр Михайлов (GSOC): «Безопасность IT-экосистемы — это зона нулевого доверия к подрядчикам»


Мостовой назвал точный счёт матча «Ростов» - «Спартак»

Шоумен Дмитрий Дибров будет делить с женой Полиной особняк на Рублевке

Володин сообщил о интеграции парламента в стратегию развития России под руководством Путина.

Страховщик заявил о сокращении автоугонов в летний период вдвое


В Архангельске с 29 июля перекрывается движение по участку набережной Северной Двины

Деревенские прогулки...

Туманное утро в Турчасово...

В Архангельске представили киноальманах «Север, я люблю тебя!» по произведениям современных писателей


В Севастополе пройдет масштабная выставка картин Александра Дейнеки

В Крыму из-за дыма от пожара столкнулись девять автомобилей

Прогноз погоды в Крыму на 27 июля

К парню с костылем подошли трое с требованием уступить. Он был готов, но заступилась бабушка по соседству


Курьер мошенников похитил у пенсионерки более 300 тысяч рублей: молодой человек заключён под стражу

Страховщик заявил о сокращении автоугонов в летний период вдвое

Массовая авария парализовала движение на МКАД в Москве

Росгвардия и МЧС провели пожарно-тактическое занятие в Чеченской Республике














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *