Добавить новость
smi24.net
News in English
Декабрь
2023

An Estate That Divides: Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’s Appropriate

0

Plenty of therapists will tell you: When you have the urge to say but, pause and replace it with and. It sounds a little hokey, but — and — it’s a small, shockingly easy-to-open door into spaces of greater complexity. Those spaces can be terrifying to enter — people structure their whole lives so as to avoid acknowledging the existence of the door — and if we forced ourselves over the threshold more often, we might live in a different world altogether. I love you and you’re hurting me. He’s suffering and what he’s done isn’t okay. Violent antisemitism is real and once again rising in the world, and Israel is acting indefensibly in Palestine.

Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’s writing lives entirely and electrically in the space of “and.” The cataclysms he builds toward are the result of simultaneous truths — every one of them unfaceable, identity-destroying, or even, in plain fact, fatal for someone — crowding and thickening the atmosphere like gas slowly leaking from a stove, until at last the igniter sparks. In Appropriate, the air is so clotted it’s barely breathable. Jacobs-Jenkins’s 2013 play takes place during a queasy reunion of three adult siblings at the former plantation in Arkansas that belonged to their recently deceased father — and, if anything, the past ten years have only taken a whetstone to the story’s blade. “There was a big debate about whether to update it,” Jacobs-Jenkins told the New York Times. “I didn’t think I could, because these people would look like true idiots if they had not paid attention to what everyone else has paid attention to since then.” Although that makes sense, what’s striking is that the play doesn’t sound like a smart period piece. The voices Jacobs-Jenkins has fashioned for his cast of white characters — all talking like white people around other white people, in their private home, in the South — are still devastatingly credible, even after that decade of cultural shift. In the sensitive hands of director Lila Neugebauer and her top-notch cast, these people are complicated and they’re blinkered, monstrous and pitiable, trying and failing, not individually hateful and collectively matured in a slow cooker of unexamined bias and malice.

First, there’s Toni (the absolutely fearsome Sarah Paulson), eldest of the Lafayette siblings. With a bitter divorce and a messy job loss right in the rearview mirror, Toni has arrived in Arkansas in a righteous fury, dragging her teenage son, Rhys (Graham Campbell), in her wake and determined to organize the estate sale and auction of her father’s house herself (“Mom fired the estate people,” Rhys dully informs one of his uncles). In from New York are the Kramer-Lafayettes: Toni’s brother Bo (a perfectly pitched Corey Stoll); his wife, Rachael (Natalie Gold); and their kids, 13-year-old Cassidy (Alyssa Emily Marvin, wonderful in her repeated frustrated howls of “I’m almost an adult!”) and 8-year-old chaos-rocket Ainsley (I saw Lincoln Cohen, who alternates with Everett Sobers in the role). And if that’s not enough personality already packed into the old plantation, the estranged youngest sibling, Franz (Michael Esper), has just snuck in through the window with his willowy, sage-burning, part-time-vegan-chef fiancée, River (Elle Fanning, making her Broadway debut with serene “She’s making jewelry now” energy).

Jacobs-Jenkins, who often speaks of his fascination with the 19th-century melodramatist Dion Boucicault (and whose stupendous adaptation of Boucicault’s The Octoroon won him the 2014 Obie, jointly with that year’s Off Broadway premiere of Appropriate), knows how to build an intricate structure on top of a land mine. The Lafayette siblings and their various familial appendages are already bringing enough of their own combustible material onto the stage to power a three-act play, but we know from the beginning that the clamor of their bickering will be dwarfed inside a greater symphony of nightmarish uproar. We know because the first thing we hear, as soon as the theater goes dark, is the droning of cicadas, rising and warping until sound designers Bray Poor and Will Pickens have our brains vibrating with the shrieking cacophony — part mesmerizing and part horrible, like so many banshees. (The play’s opening stage directions specify that this “incessant chatter” should go on long enough to make the audience wonder, Is this it? Is this the whole show?) “Spirits are as real as we are,” warns River, and she’s more right than she knows. The Lafayette homestead has blood in the floorboards, in the lake, in the trees. The cicadas are the hum of all this unacknowledged carnage, all this buried history — and, in their mating dance, they’re also the hum of desire, the desperate struggle of something new trying to be born. Their song softens but never goes away (Is this the whole show? No and yes). It’s always in the background — and in the moments when the characters have the wool ripped from their eyes, it surges like a cresting wave.

“What are you — Oh my God,” says Rachael, distractedly grabbing something Ainsley has pulled off a shelf somewhere in the big old house. It’s the bomb we’ve been waiting for: an old photo album full of pictures of the lynched bodies of Black people. Rachael drops it as if it has just emerged from a 500-degree oven. It lies there smoking. Now, for the rest of the play, the family will play a particularly grisly game of hot potato. That Jacobs-Jenkins recognizes and structures the consequent appalling events with such ludic precision is part of what makes his play so sharp: He’s using the building blocks of comedy, even farce, to reveal a smoldering chasm of cruelty, cowardice, equivocation, and shame. It is funny, and it does burn.

Crucially, though, it’s not played for laughs. Neugebauer understands that the layer Jacobs-Jenkins is adding to the conventional undulations of melodrama — a family with damning secrets, a haunted estate on the brink of loss, a plot full of gaspy twists — is to turn its stock cutouts into people, catastrophic failings and all. In 2014, my predecessor, Jesse Green, disagreed: He saw the Lafayettes as nasty and flat. I can’t speak to that production, but I can imagine an Appropriate that pushes too hard for morbid humor, that tries to send up its floundering souls — which is a way of saying, “Look at these fools; we know better” — rather than granting them, however unearned, a measure of grace. Neugebauer has bravely steered in the opposite direction. She and her actors are taking the risk of taking these people seriously.

And it is a risk. The Lafayettes are those other white people, exactly the ones we — and here I mean we lefty white theatergoing folks, in all our anxious 2023 hyper-self-awareness — want to distance ourselves from. But Paulson, Stoll, Esper, and their castmates are all doing their goddamned job, which is to make it hard, despite everything, for us to dismiss them and their pain out of hand. “I believe that everyone onstage is suffering,” Jacobs-Jenkins told the Times. “They all believe they are suffering. But how do we judge — how can we judge — someone else as suffering or not?” When Franz crumples in agony, shouting, “It’s been ten years! How much more am I supposed to suffer for my mistakes, Toni?! … Why won’t you let me be different?,” we know the nauseating depths of Franz’s “mistakes,” and yet we have to consider the question. To Franz’s siblings, he’s “Frank,” and River admits to Toni that her given name is Patricia. Their desire for total transformation becomes a real ethical quandary: They say they want to change — should they be allowed to? Who grants permission? Whose forgiveness is needed?

“That apology isn’t yours!” shrieks Toni at her brother Bo as he half-heartedly moves to accept an “I’m sorry” from wayward Franz. “That apology isn’t for you to accept! That forgiveness isn’t for you! It’s for me! It’s mine!” Paulson’s voice hoarsens and cracks; fury leaks out of her pores. She’s enacting the tragedy of the play’s double-edged title: Its root words mean to own. The verb “to appropriate” still carries its etymology more overtly, but the adjective is what’s interesting — something is “appropriate” if it feels comfortably ownable, if we want to acknowledge and possess it. It’s “inappropriate” if we don’t want to associate with it, if we refuse to lay claim to it. Descended from enslavers, the Lafayettes are still as brutally certain of what is theirs — “that apology,” “a third of this house,” “my daddy” — as what absolutely isn’t. “Who is Emmett Till?” asks Cassidy, Googling around on her phone. “I don’t know,” replies River. “I didn’t enslave anybody!” screams Bo, his reasonable façade finally crumbling into the jagged shards of shortsighted white resentment.

Neugebauer is doing fine work with the whole ensemble, and Paulson and Stoll provide a supercharged core. He tries to stay rational and cool while she runs molten hot, but even as Toni may seem like the most closed off of the three siblings, the most resolutely in denial of the accumulating facts, what’s really going on is thornier than that — and sadder. “Wasn’t I doing what I was supposed to be doing?” she asks wretchedly. “Taking care?” She’s the “crazy” person, the “bitch,” the “sabotaging fucking cunt” — and she meekly asks her teenage son for a hug every time she talks to him. In a moment of deadly calm, she says to her brothers, “You know what I just realized? I’ve known both you idiots your whole entire lives … I remember holding both of you … There’s no one alive who’s held me … And think whatever you want about him now, but Daddy held me.”

Toni sees herself as having spent her life caring for others. She sees her father as having cared for her. It’s not that she’s in denial over the photos, the history, the facts — it’s that she’s incapable of prioritizing them above her own emotional experience. Horribly, both are the truth.

In the introduction to James Baldwin’s play Blues for Mister Charlie — which is distantly based on Emmett Till’s murder — he described how he long avoided sitting down to write the piece because he feared he wouldn’t be able to create a true picture of the murderer. “In life,” he wrote,

obviously, such people baffle and terrify me and, with one part of my mind at least, I hate them and would be willing to kill them. Yet, with another part of my mind, I am aware that no man is a villain in his own eyes. Something in the man knows — must know — that what he is doing is evil; but in order to accept that knowledge the man would have to change … The human being, then, in order to protect himself, closes his eyes, compulsively repeats his crimes, and enters a spiritual darkness which no one can describe.


But if it is true, and I believe it is, that all men are brothers, then we have a duty to try to understand this wretched man; and while we probably cannot hope to liberate him, begin working toward the liberation of his children.

In this schema, the Lafayette siblings are both parent and child, and it’s not their active malevolence that has begun to trickle down to the younger generation but their selfishness and unconcern. Things come out of Rhys’s and Cassidy’s mouths that give the lie to Richard Rodgers’s optimistic lyric “You’ve got to be carefully taught.” The dreadful truth is that it’s just the opposite: The teaching is automatic, easy — the poison enters by osmosis. What really takes care is the unlearning. But that is a house that the Lafayettes haven’t yet acknowledged they own.

Appropriate is at the Hayes Theater.

Related








Баскова, Киркорова и Лазарева погнали с экранов: попались на непотребщине

Оркестр полиции Республики Сербской впервые выступит на фестивале «Спасская башня» в Москве

Мичков внесен в Книгу знаменитых людей Кунгура, сообщил директор кунгурского музея: «Никаких его трофеев в музее пока нет, к сожалению»

В мэрии назвали условия присвоения Элджею звания почётного жителя


UFC Abu Dhabi live blog: Shara Bullet vs. Marc-Andre Barriault

The Great Indian Kapil Show: Raghav Chadha reveals telling Parineeti Chopra to manifest he will never become the PM; says ‘Yeh jo bolti hai wo ulta hota hai’

Chat log from R20 of 2025: Richmond vs Collingwood

Juventus and Roma weigh up McKennie & Cristante swap


422 л.с., полный привод: этот кроссовер стоит дешевле 3 млн рублей

стела Освободителям Ростова

Вечером в Орле сгорели два автомобиля

Как начать петь. Как начать петь песни. Как начать петь с нуля


«Если бы у Наруто и AC Shadows был ребёнок»: Разбор англоязычной версии Where Winds Meet

Первый трейлер Battlefield 6

Brütal Legend is free in honor of Ozzy Osbourne, but only for 666 minutes

Ninja Party можно предзаказать в мобильных маркетах с релизом в конце июля



Возобновлены прямые рейсы из Москвы в Пхеньян

Дорога любви: Жасмин представляет романтичный клип на песню «Ты и я»

Потерянная библиотека, подземный город и бункер Сталина: какие секреты хранит Кремль

Первый прямой рейс Москва – Пхеньян вылетел из Шереметьево


Елена Игоревна Вселенная — писатель, публицист, автор масштабного многотомного проекта «Наследие России»

Специалисты из Москвы помогут родственникам погибших в авиакатастрофе в Приамурье

Пловец из Москвы погиб во время заплыва на Волге

«В августе будет климатическая угроза»: синоптики дали новый прогноз на конец лета


В России с сентября начнут применять критерии изъятия заброшенных участков

Самолет Embraer совершил аварийную посадку в Махачкале после сигнала бедствия

Нутрициолог Порхун назвала опасные для детей продукты

Задержка и отмена рейсов: Калининградский аэропорт "Храброво" сообщает причины


Соболенко — об Уимблдоне-2025: это ужасно, когда твоя жизнь зависит от результата

Теннисист Медведев не прошел в полуфинал турнира ATP в Вашингтоне

Калинская прокомментировала выход в финал турнира WTA в Вашингтоне

Сидоренко из России одержал победу и стал чемпионом по настольному теннису на Универсиаде.


Самолет Embraer совершил аварийную посадку в Махачкале после сигнала бедствия

Самолёт совершил первый прямой авиарейс из Москвы в Пхеньян

Нутрициолог Порхун назвала опасные для детей продукты

Цена ОСАГО оказалась выше средней по стране в 16 регионах России


Музыкальные новости

Фестиваль стыда и "эстрадной мафии" под маской молодёжного праздника: устроили на VK Fest очередной шабаш звезд

Классика лечит: как Моцарт и Бетховен заменяют таблетки

Дорога любви: Жасмин представляет романтичный клип на песню «Ты и я»

Мик Джаггер отпраздновал 82-летие с молодой невестой и их сыном 


Потерянная библиотека, подземный город и бункер Сталина: какие секреты хранит Кремль

Дорога любви: Жасмин представляет романтичный клип на песню «Ты и я»

Как начать петь. Как начать петь песни. Как начать петь с нуля

Возобновлены прямые рейсы из Москвы в Пхеньян


Собянин отметил качество обслуживания в центрах госуслуг Москвы

Росгвардия и МЧС провели совместные учения в Москве

Путин: пять бригад морской пехоты в ближайшее время преобразуют в дивизии

Fix Price подготовил всё необходимое к 1 сентября


ДТП произошло на внешней стороне 26-го километра МКАД

Канал, о котором мечтали несколько веков...

Движение в поселке Восточный ограничили из-за пожара

В Кот-д'Ивуаре в результате аварии с участием автобуса и самосвала погибли 16 человек.


«Подводная лодка, демонтрированная Путину, произвела шок на Западе»

Путин поздравил Жапарова с юбилеем подписания декларации о союзничестве.

Путин в День ВМФ прибыл на территорию Главного Адмиралтейства в Санкт-Петербурге

«Внезапно»: Запад встревожен новым указом Путина


Приговор экс-руководителю компании по производству вакцин против ковида был смягчен.

Профессор Баранова рассказала, кому опасен новый штамм коронавируса



Приговор экс-руководителю компании по производству вакцин против ковида был смягчен.

Пьяный сантехник устроил дебош в столичной студии косметологии из-за жалобы

Клиника гнатологии в Москве

Выбор клиники гнатологии в Москве


Запад ударил Зеленского по самому больному месту – кошельку: Киев показательно лишили 1,5 миллиардов помощи

Зеленский настаивает: встреча с Путиным до конца августа с участием Европы

Киевский режим применил все 18 пакетов санкций ЕС


Круговой оформил дубль за 2 минуты и помог ЦСКА впервые победить в новом сезоне РПЛ

Пловец из Москвы умер во время соревнований в Нижнем Новгороде

Росгвардейцы обеспечили безопасность футбольных матчей в Москве

Канал, о котором мечтали несколько веков...


Лукашенко получил приглашения от стран Латинской Америки и Азии для визитов.

«Беларусь-1»: Лукашенко дал интервью одному из американских СМИ

Лукашенко дал интервью одному из американских СМИ


Собянин: 90 процентов москвичей живут в пешей доступности от зеленых территорий

Собянин поздравил работников центров госуслуг с профессиональным праздником

Сергей Собянин. Главное за день

Собянин: На территории промзоны «Кирпичные улицы» будет создана социнфраструктура


Козлов объявил о возможных прямых рейсах из России в курорт Вонсан, КНДР.

Канал, о котором мечтали несколько веков...

РИА: глава Минприроды Козлов летит первым авиарейсом Москва - Пхеньян

Сняла скальп и утопила на глазах зрителей: как и почему косатка Тиликум начала убивать


Столичные нормы: Минтранс утвердил рекомендации для регионов по управлению парковочным пространством

Цена ОСАГО оказалась выше средней по стране в 16 регионах России

«Поезд разогнали — остановить будет сложно». Известный фермер о самочувствии алтайского семеноводства

В России с сентября начнут применять критерии изъятия заброшенных участков


В Архангельске началось обучение бойцов СВО, сообщил Цыбульский.

Путин дал указание рассмотреть проблемы онкологии в Архангельской области.

В музее-заповеднике «Архангельское» пройдут «Jazzовые сезоны»

70 участников СВО в Архангельске показали мотивацию выше госслужащих — Цыбульский


Губернатор Севастополя поздравил моряков с Днем ВМФ

Прогноз погоды в Крыму на 27 июля

К парню с костылем подошли трое с требованием уступить. Он был готов, но заступилась бабушка по соседству

Крымский мост: информация об очередях на утро воскресенья


Адвокат Тиммы: Седокова могла заставить его подписать контракт приемами НЛП

Задержка и отмена рейсов: Калининградский аэропорт "Храброво" сообщает причины

В России с сентября начнут применять критерии изъятия заброшенных участков

Где тепло в сентябре: 8 направлений, где побывать на море осенью














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *