6 Critically-Condemned Christmas Movies That Became Beloved Classics — & Where to Stream

When it comes to critical evaluation, film connoisseurs tend to look for certain indicators of quality cinema — narrative strength, character development, cinematography, thematic resonance, and so forth. While all these facets — when working in harmony — tend to create a “strong” movie, it’s important to remember that the entertainment factor can exist in their absence. Sometimes, we’re just along for the ridiculous ride. Sometimes, we’re okay with quippy banter and unrealistic shenanigans. Sometimes, we don’t mind a little simplicity. Sometimes, a movie can be technically weak but utterly enjoyable. So, with the holiday season upon us, let’s look at some movies that premiered to critical condemnation (or mixed reviews) that have since become beloved holiday classics.

‘The Holiday’ | 2006 | SlingTV

Critics called The Holiday far too predictable to make up for its Love Actually-esque sentimental appeal. Time Out critic Anna Smith said, “The film itself is only gently amusing, often lacking comic timing and relying on Diaz’s trademark high-heeled pratfalls and Winslet’s lovelorn ‘Bridget Jones ’-style routine too heavily.” However, audiences hailed the charming aesthetic, noting the picturesque snowy landscapes of New England and golden-hued images of Los Angeles as the perfect backdrop for the rom-com. 

Audiences also appreciated an all-star cast led by Cameron Diaz, Kate Winslet, Jude Law, and Jack Black — all of whom brought forth relatable and compelling characters. The dialogue is also quite witty (albeit a bit too self-indulgent at times) and the timeless themes of love, friendship, and second chances never go out of style. 

‘How the Grinch Stole Christmas’ | 2000 | Peacock

Critics be damned. Jim Carrey as the green-furred cantankerous, overly-expressive, and mischievous Grinch is a work of art. However, critics noted that even Carrey couldn’t save this film from its “headache-inducing visual overkill.” Variety went as far as to describe it as “shrill, strenuous and entirely without charm.” However, over the years, the film has become a Christmas staple. The film, though straying from Dr. Seuss’s original story, remains true to his imaginative world, providing audiences with costumes and set designs that boast the “wow factor.” The heartwarming message about the true meaning of Christmas shines through, and the film boasts a festive atmosphere with an approach to humor that is suitable for all ages.

‘Four Christmases’ | 2008 | Hulu

Critics panned Four Christmases as an overworked and unoriginal holiday film. They were quick to note that the recurring gags (including baby vomit) didn’t leave much to admire, nor did the overly predictable storytelling and the slapstick moments you could see coming a while away. However, over the years, the movie has snuggled up in our hearts next to some of its superior counterparts. 

With a commendable performance from Vince Vaughn — who’s doing his darndest with what he’s got — and a relatable premise that spotlights how difficult families can be (especially come the holiday season), it’s easy to add this one to the annual Christmas streaming list. It passes the time with worthwhile moments of heart and humor. 

‘Home Alone 2: Lost in New York’ | 1992 | Disney+

The primary critical takeaway: the film gives us a new setting and some higher-stakes hijinks, but it is no more than an inferior reproduction of its predecessor. The thing is — If we’re watching Home Alone 2, that’s probably what we want. Kevin McCallister back in all his glory as the self-reliant schemer is good enough for us. Kevin has to fend for himself in an unfamiliar place, upping the stakes and providing almost as many outlandish chuckles as the original. 

Home Alone 2 is the perfect mix of familiar and inventive, as the premise remains the same but the pranks grow more and more elaborate and clever. Joe Pesci and Daniel Stern reprise their roles as the bumbling burglars, Harry and Marv, and their comedic chemistry and over-the-top reactions to Kevin’s pranks remain a stand-out feature. With a heartwarming resolution and the iconic visuals tied to the Big Apple during Christmastime, Home Alone 2 has since become a beloved Christmas classic. 

‘The Polar Express’ | 2004 | Hulu

The Polar Express, which follows a young boy as he embarks on a magical adventure to the North Pole, loses some of its magic in the uncanny valley (a result of the characters’ waxy animated appearances). Critics were also quick to note that it was way too schmaltzy, with The Guardian critic Peter Bradshaw stating, “The schmaltz content gets higher and higher, as if administered through a drip feed, until by the end we are drowning in sucrose.” However, the movie is far from short on Christmas spirit and has since been deemed perfect for conjuring those warm and fuzzy nostalgic feelings. 

The Polar Express is a tale full of adventure with magical visuals and an unparalleled Tom Hanks voicing multiple characters. It boasts an enchanting atmosphere and universal themes of belief and wonder, faithfully adapting the source material by Chris Van Allsburg. It’s even got the Academy Award-nominated song “Believe” performed by Josh Groban. When it comes to this one, it seems like a handful of critics were responding to the coal in their stockings. 

‘The Family Stone’ | 2005 | Hulu

Critics were quick to judge The Family Stone as a misguided production with a wasted roster of talented actors. They noted that there was far too much going on for the most interesting characters to receive their moment in the spotlight. The plot is a bit contrived and the film feels unsure of the tone it wants to strike. 

However, everyday audiences appreciated the film’s blend of comedy and drama, as well as the chemistry among the many leading players. The family dynamics feel realistic and complex, resonating with viewers who boast similar backgrounds and experiences. And, with a couple of twists and turns, the film keeps viewers engaged via surprise elements.