High-yield savings account vs. money market account: Which is best for growing your savings?

With traditional savings accounts earning just 0.47% on average, the potential for stronger returns of 5% or higher on your nest egg have set high-yield savings accounts and money market accounts back in the spotlight. Both accounts are safe, stable spots for storing your money and growing your savings — about 10 times the interest than you’d earn with an everyday account.

Among the many similarities shared by these two popular deposit accounts are slight differences that come down to how — and how often — you can access your money. Compare these two savings options to leverage historically high rates to best fit your budget and financial goals.

What is a high-yield savings account?

A high-yield savings account — commonly called an HYSA — is a deposit account that earns a higher rate of interest on your money than with a traditional savings account. The rate of interest is expressed as the APY, short for annual percentage yield, which is the earnings you can expect on your savings in a year, including compound interest. Generally, the higher your APY, the faster your money can grow.

The interest rate on an HYSA is variable, meaning it fluctuates depending on market conditions, much like a traditional savings account. And while these accounts used to limit withdrawals to six per month, the Federal Reserve suspended that limitation during the pandemic, resulting in flexible access to your money without penalties or fees on most accounts.

You can open a high-yield savings account with most banks and credit unions, though you’ll find today’s highest rates with online or digital banks. These banks partner with in-network ATMs that accept deposits and allow you to link external accounts — an everyday checking or savings account, for instance — for easy electronic transfer of your money.

As with a traditional savings account, your deposits are insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per bank, by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) or the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA), depending on where you bank.

Many high-yield accounts allow opening deposits as low as $100 — or none at all — though with rates at historic highs, some HYSAs require a high opening deposit to earn the highest advertised APY, so you’ll want to carefully read the fine print when comparing options.

Benefits of a high-yield savings account

• High APYs. Earn more than 10 times the national average when compared to a traditional savings account.

• No or low fees. The best high-yield savings accounts come with few fees and low minimum deposit requirements, making it easy to maintain your account.

• Federally insured up to $250,000. High-yield savings account deposits are insured by the FDIC or the NCUA for up to $250,000 per person, per account.

Drawbacks of a high-yield savings account

• Not a checking account. While most HYSAs allow you to withdraw or add to your money as needed, you’ll need to transfer money to a checking account for everyday banking.

• Transfers may not be instant. You may need to wait up to three days for transfers to or from your account to clear, depending on the bank or account.

Dig deeper: High-yield savings account vs. CD: What to know when rates are high

What is a money market account?

A money market account – or MMA — is a savings account that offers a high rate of return on your deposit with the benefits of a checking account, though with limited flexibility. Like a high-yield savings account, the interest you earn with an MMA is expressed as a variable APY, which means it can increase or decrease at any time, depending on the market.

You can open a money market account as you would a traditional or high-yield savings account at most banks and credit unions — and here, too, rates tend to be higher with a digital or online bank. Some MMAs pay different APYs depending on your total account balance through tiered rates — effectively, the higher your balance, the better your rate of return. But you can find many accounts requiring low or no minimum opening deposits, making high upfront amounts a thing of the past.

A money market account typically comes with a debit card and check-writing capabilities for paying bills, gifting cash and automatic online payments. Some accounts limit withdrawals to six per month, though many others have relaxed restrictions. If there are limitations, they typically don’t apply to in-person or ATM withdrawals, so you’ll want to read your account’s fine print. Most online banks partner with nationwide ATM networks and allow you to link everyday accounts for convenient banking.

Deposits in your MMA are insured up to $250,000 by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) or the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA).

Benefits of a money market account

• High rates of return. Strong potential yields are like those of a high-yield savings account — considerably higher than you’ll earn with a traditional savings account.

• Debit and check-writing privileges. Unlike an HYSA, MMAs tend to offer a debit card and checks, which can be useful for accessing or moving your money.

• Insured by the FDIC. Money market accounts are insured by the FDIC or NCUA for up to $250,000 per person, per account.

Drawbacks of a money market account

• Earnings may be tiered. Money market accounts often require higher balances to earn the highest advertised rates.

• Potential withdrawal limits. Some money market accounts limit withdrawals to six a month, which means you might need a traditional checking account for everyday banking.

High-yield savings account vs. money market account: How they compare

High-yield savings accounts and money market accounts are deposit accounts that offer more similarities than differences. Both extend significantly higher rates of return than a traditional savings account. And while APYs for MMAs used to beat those of HYSAs, today’s high-rate environment means you can find competitive rates of up to 5% APY and higher, no matter which account you choose — especially when comparing digital or online banks.

Most HYSAs and MMAs won’t require a minimum opening deposit or high account balances to earn strong yields, though for both accounts, carefully read the terms and conditions before signing up to make sure a high opening deposit isn’t required to earn the best advertised APY.

Differences between these two account types come down to the way you can access your money and how interest is earned. Money market accounts often come with a debit card and allow limited check-writing, which you won’t find with a high-yield savings account. And some MMAs come with tiered interest rates that earn you stronger yields the larger your balance — great for big savers, though something you’ll want to understand before you open an account.

Both of these savings accounts offer a safe, secure way to grow your nest egg without risk. Yet neither are likely to offer the highest returns when compared to riskier investment products like stocks, ETFs and mutual funds.

Sources

National Rates and Rate Caps, FDIC. Accessed March 27, 2024.