Добавить новость
smi24.net
News in English
Май
2024

Exposed to Agent Orange at U.S. bases, veterans face cancer without VA compensation

0

A soldier participates in the Norwegian Foot March at Fort Ord National Monument, in Monterey County, California, in a 2022 file photo. Mounting evidence shows that to kill pervasive poison oak and other weeds at Fort Ord — a former Army base that closed in 1994 — the military sprayed and experimented with the powerful herbicide combination Agent Orange as far back as the 1950s.

Winifred Brown/U.S. Army

As a young GI at Fort Ord in Monterey County, California, Dean Osborn spent much of his time in the oceanside woodlands, training on soil and guzzling water from streams and aquifers now known to be contaminated with cancer-causing pollutants.

“They were marching the snot out of us,” he says, recalling his year and a half stationed on the base, from 1979 to 1980. He also remembers the poison oak pervasive across the 28,000-acre installation that closed in 1994. He went on sick call at least three times because of the overwhelmingly itchy rash.

Mounting evidence shows that as far back as the 1950s, in an effort to kill the ubiquitous poison oak and other weeds at the Army base, the military experimented with and sprayed the powerful herbicide combination known colloquially as Agent Orange.

While the U.S. military used the herbicide to defoliate the dense jungles of Vietnam and adjoining countries, it was contaminating the land and waters of coastal California with the same chemicals, according to documents.

The Defense Department has publicly acknowledged that during the Vietnam War era it stored Agent Orange at the Naval Construction Battalion Center in Gulfport, Mississippi, and the former Kelly Air Force Base in Texas, and tested it at Florida’s Eglin Air Force Base.

According to the Government Accountability Office, however, the Pentagon’s list of sites where herbicides were tested went more than a decade without being updated and lacked specificity. GAO analysts described the list in 2018 as “inaccurate and incomplete.”

Fort Ord was not included. It is among about four dozen bases that the government has excluded but where Pat Elder, an environmental activist, said he has documented the use or storage of Agent Orange. Those sites also include Chanute Air Force Base, which is about 15 miles north of Champaign and closed in 1993.

An entomology expert who served at Chanute in 1963 and 1964 told the Illinois Environmental Protection Agency in 2013 he used the herbicides. However, sampling of wells in the area between 1998 and 2001 had detected only trace levels likely due to “instrument noise” and were not a health concern, according to a 2002 Illinois Department of Health report that the state EPA cited in 2013.

At Fort Ord, the use of Agent Orange herbicides led to a “drastic reduction in trainee dermatitis casualties,” according to a 1956 article in the journal The Military Engineer.

“A well-organized chemical war has been waged against this woody plant pest,” the article noted.

Boarded-up barracks are seen at Fort Ord in Monterey County, California, in this 1993 photo. The Army base closed in 1994.

Marvin Hamburger

‘The Most Toxic Chemical’

Agent Orange is a 50-50 mixture of two ingredients, known as 2,4-D and 2,4,5-T. Herbicides with the same chemical structure slightly modified were available off the shelf, sold commercially in massive amounts and used at practically every base in the United States, says Gerson Smoger, a lawyer who argued before the U.S. Supreme Court for Vietnam veterans to have the right to sue Agent Orange manufacturers. The combo was also used by farmers, forest workers and other civilians across the country.

The chemical 2,4,5-T contains the dioxin 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo-p-dioxin or TCDD, a known carcinogen linked to several cancers, chronic conditions and birth defects. A recent Brown University study tied Agent Orange exposure to brain tissue damage similar to that caused by Alzheimer’s. Acknowledging its harm to human health, the federal Environmental Protection Agency banned the use of 2,4,5-T in the United States in 1979. Still, the other weed killer, 2,4-D is sold off-the-shelf today.

“The bottom line is TCDD is the most toxic chemical that man has ever made,” Smoger says.

For years, the Department of Veteran Affairs has provided disability compensation to vets who served in Vietnam for diseases considered to be connected to exposure to Agent Orange for military use from 1962 to 1975.

Decades after Osborn’s military service, the 68-year-old veteran, who never served in Vietnam, has battled one health crisis after another: a spot on his left lung and kidney, hypothyroidism and prostate cancer, an illness that has been tied to Agent Orange exposure.

He says many of his old buddies from Fort Ord are sick as well.

“Now we have cancers that we didn’t deserve,” Osborn says.

The VA considers prostate cancer a “presumptive condition” for Agent Orange disability compensation, acknowledging that those who served in specific locations were likely exposed and that their illnesses are tied to their military service. The designation expedites affected veterans’ claims.

But when Osborn requested his benefits, he was denied. The letter said the cancer was “more likely due to your age,” not military service.

“This didn’t happen because of my age. This is happening because we were stationed in the places that were being sprayed and contaminated,” he says.

Studies show that diseases caused by environmental factors can take years to emerge. And to make things more perplexing for veterans stationed at Fort Ord, contamination from other harmful chemicals, like the industrial cleaner trichloroethylene, have been well documented on the former base, landing it on the EPA’s Superfund site list in 1990.

In February, the VA proposed a rule that for the first time would allow compensation to veterans for Agent Orange exposure at 17 U.S. bases in a dozen states where the herbicide was tested, used or stored.

Fort Ord and Chanute are not on that list, because it’s based on the Defense Department’s 2019 update.

“DoD’s review found no documentation of herbicide use, testing or storage at Fort Ord. Therefore, VA does not have sufficient evidence to extend a presumption of exposure to herbicides based on service at Fort Ord at this time,” VA press secretary Terrence Hayes wrote.

The Documentation

Yet environmental activist Elder, with help from toxic and remediation specialist Denise Trabbic-Pointer and former VA physician Kyle Horton, compiled seven documents showing otherwise. They include a journal article, the agronomist report and cleanup-related documents as recent as 1995 — all pointing to widespread herbicide use and experimentation as well as lasting contamination at the base.

They routinely cite the combination of 2,4-D and 2,4,5-T. A “hazardous waste minimization assessment” dated 1991 reported 80,000 pounds of herbicides used annually at Fort Ord. It separately lists 2,4,5-T as a product for which “substitutions are necessary to minimize the environmental impacts.”

The poison oak “control program” started in 1951, according to a report by Army agronomist Floyd Otter. He detailed the use of these chemicals alone and in combination with diesel oil or other compounds, at rates generally between “one to two gallons of liquid herbicide” per acre.

“In conclusion, we are fairly well satisfied with the methods,” Otter wrote.

An article published in California Agriculture more than a decade later includes before and after photos showing the effectiveness of chemical brush control used in a live-oak woodland at Fort Ord, again citing both chemicals in Agent Orange. The Defense Department did not respond to questions sent April 10 about the contamination or say when the Army stopped using 2,4,5-T at Fort Ord.

A 1962 article in California Agriculture includes before and after photos showing the effectiveness of chemical brush control used in a live oak woodland at Fort Ord, citing 2,4-D and 2,4,5-T, the chemicals in Agent Orange.

Provided by the Regents of the University of California

“What’s most compelling about Fort Ord is it was actually used for the same purpose it was used for in Vietnam — to kill plants — not just storing it,” says Julie Akey, a former Army linguist who worked at the base in the 1990s and later developed the rare blood cancer multiple myeloma.

Akey, who also worked with Elder, runs a Facebook group and keeps a list of people stationed on the base who later were diagnosed with cancer and other illnesses. She has tallied more than 1,400 former Fort Ord residents who became sick.

Elder’s findings have galvanized the group during a public comment period for the VA’s proposed rule. Of 546 comments, 67 are from veterans and others urging the inclusion of Fort Ord. Hundreds of others have written in regarding the use of Agent Orange and other chemicals at their bases.

While the herbicide itself sticks around for only a short time, the contaminant TCDD can linger in sediment for decades, says Kenneth Olson, a professor emeritus of soil science at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign.

A 1995 report from the Army’s Sacramento Corps of Engineers, which documented chemicals detected in the soil at Fort Ord, found levels of TCDD at 3.5 parts per trillion, more than double the remediation goal at the time of 1.2 ppt. Olson calls the evidence convincing.

“It clearly supports the fact that 2,4,5-T with unknown amounts of dioxin TCDD was applied on the Fort Ord grounds and border fences,” Olson says. “Some military and civilian personnel would have been exposed.”

The Department of Defense has described the Agent Orange used in Vietnam as a “tactical herbicide,” more concentrated than what was commercially available in the United States. But Olson says his research suggests that even if the grounds maintenance crew used commercial versions of 2,4,5-T, which was available in the federal supply catalog, the soldiers would have been exposed to the dioxin TCDD.

The half dozen veterans who spoke with KFF Health News say they want the military to take responsibility.

The Pentagon did not respond to questions regarding the upkeep of the list or the process for adding locations.

In the meantime, the federal Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry is studying potential chemical exposure among people who worked and lived on Fort Ord between 1985 and 1994. However, the agency is evaluating drinking water for contaminants such as trichloroethylene and not contamination or pollution from other chemicals such as Agent Orange or those found in firefighting foams.

KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism on health issues.








Любовь в сердце и в «Тропикана Парк»

Арбуз, кукуруза и холодные напитки: диетолог Садыков назвал продукты, которые портят ваш сон летом

Раздвигая горы - к единству и созиданию! Манифест лезгинского народа (письменное обращение, воззвание программного характера)

Доктор на старом пожелтевшем снимке


Tourism is increasing over prepandemic levels, overwhelming popular destinations

The founder of Deliciously Ella started a blog when suffering from severe chronic pain. Now, her multimillion-dollar snack empire is going global

OpenAI warns that its new ChatGPT Agent has the ability to aid dangerous bioweapon development

Why Juventus spent 111m this summer for only one new player


Кайрат Бермуканов поддержал Петра Яна перед боем в Абу‑Даби

Зима в Ленинградской области

Нацпроектстрой изготовил уникальное оборудование для столичного моста парус

Это провал? Как прошёл старт продаж новой Лады Искры в России


'I destroyed months of your work in seconds' says AI coding tool after deleting a devs entire database during a code freeze: 'I panicked instead of thinking'

Microsoft warns of 'active attacks' on its government and business server tech, with one cybersecurity expert claiming that they should 'assume that you have been compromised'

The dairy industry would like Gen Z to drink more milk, so they made a Fortnite diner tycoon game

Настройки GameHub и Winlator для игры в Prey (2017) на Android



Кайрат Бермуканов поддержал Петра Яна перед боем в Абу‑Даби

Движение к победе: в России стартует премия «Мы верим твердо в героев спорта»

Нам есть чем гордиться: каким будет Национальный центр «Россия» на Краснопресненской набережной

Аделина Панина: как силой мысли заставить человека написать или позвонить


Собянин: создание пяти центров женского здоровья планируется завершить в этом году

Протест против закона о поиске экстремистских материалов: в Москве прошли задержания активистов у Госдумы

А икра с крабами — по режиму? Что продают донским зэкам в тюремных лавках

В регионах Центральной России продолжается ведомственная акция «Каникулы с Росгвардией»


Лавров провел переговоры с главой МИД Мозамбика в Москве

Эксперт отмечает, что хвастовство Трампа скорее не привлечет внимание Нобелевского комитета.

Как быстро систематизировать бизнес: инструменты и сервис ABR PRO

В Подмосковье отметили вклад сотрудников спецподразделения в патриотическое воспитание молодёжи


Рублев уступил в полуфинале теннисного турнира в Лос-Кабосе.

Новак Джокович проводит 900-ю неделю в топ-10 рейтинга ATP

Андреева сохранила пятое место в рейтинге WTA, Александрова вошла в Топ‑15

Рублев прокомментировал вылет с турнира в Лос-Кабосе


Врач Поляков: Киркоров рискует сойти с ума из-за препарата для похудения

Кайрат Бермуканов поддержал Петра Яна перед боем в Абу‑Даби

Новое оборудование Dekree: грохоты с высокой пропускной способностью

Высокопроизводительные электродвигатели от компании JackShaft


Музыкальные новости

Алексей Парамонов о скандале: отмена концерта Валерия Гергиева в Италии

Певица Клава Кока стала послом конкурса "Интервидение"

Главные фермеры шоу-бизнеса: Джиган и Самойлова приехали на фестиваль в повозке с сеном и овощами

Клипмейкер. Лучший Клипмейкер. Клипмейкер в Москве.


Движение к победе: в России стартует премия «Мы верим твердо в героев спорта»

Кайрат Бермуканов поддержал Петра Яна перед боем в Абу‑Даби

Летняя школа Русского дома приняла детей из Карабаха

Аделина Панина: как силой мысли заставить человека написать или позвонить


Инсайдер Карпов: "Спартак" предложил "Динамо" Мх за Пальцева 250 млн рублей

Уже не крепкий орешек: как Брюс Уиллис живет с неизлечимой болезнью

Россияне рассказали, по каким критериям выбирают квартиру для покупки в 2025 году

Аранжировка Песен. Аранжировка Музыки. Создание Аранжировок.


Рискнул на 100 тысяч рублей: инженер из Смоленска купил более 1,7 тысячи лотерейных билетов и выиграл автомобиль от «Национальной Лотереи» и РОЛЬФ на VK Fest

Сильный ливень заблокировал людей в авто в центре Москвы

На МКАД из-за аварии образовалась пробка длиной в три километра

Москвичей предупредили о задержках наземного транспорта из-за ливня


Министр юстиции поделился информацией о роли адвокатов в специальной военной операции.

Нам есть чем гордиться: каким будет Национальный центр «Россия» на Краснопресненской набережной

Путин отметил победу синхрониста Мальцева на чемпионате мира в Сингапуре.

Путин выразил соболезнования семье председателя Верховного суда Подносовой




Уже не крепкий орешек: как Брюс Уиллис живет с неизлечимой болезнью

«Я на инвалидном кресле, он на «Тесле»: что случилось с блогером Мариш Мариш

После вспышки инфекции на теплоходе «Леонид Красин» начали расследование

Офтальмолог Кирилл Светлаков: секреты здоровых глаз для тех, кто носит контактные линзы


Пока вы не уснули: открытая поддержка Алиевым Киева и «подзатыльник» Зеленскому от Трампа

«СТРАНА.ua»: Зеленский раскритиковал ЕС за непредоставление обещанной помощи


KENGURU GAMES в Звенигороде звенели на всю страну

В Москве впервые пройдет фестиваль экстремальных видов спорта

Движение к победе: в России стартует премия «Мы верим твердо в героев спорта»

Уже 59 орловчан решили побороться за просветительскую награду «Знание. Премия»


Лукашенко призвал белорусских нефтяников «не раскачиваться, а бурить и бурить»

Вячеслав Федорищев и Александр Лукашенко наметили направления развития сотрудничества Самарской области и Беларуси

Куда Лукашенко хочет пристроить лишних дипломатов

Посланник Трампа рассказал, как «неформально» договаривался с Лукашенко: после нескольких тостов Минск освободил политзаключенных


Сергей Собянин открыл школу на 1100 мест в стремительно растущей Коммунарке

Собянин: Модернизация двух корпусов ГКБ имени Вересаева завершится в этом году

Более 800 спортивных площадок обновят и обустроят в Москве - Сергей Собянин

Более 800 спортивных площадок обновят и обустроят в Москве — Сергей Собянин


Россияне рассказали, по каким критериям выбирают квартиру для покупки в 2025 году

Фестиваль «Сады и цветы»: как Москву превращают в городской оазис

Уже 59 орловчан решили побороться за просветительскую награду «Знание. Премия»

Собянин рассказал, как Москва заботится о природе при строительстве метро


Высокопроизводительные электродвигатели от компании JackShaft

Кайрат Бермуканов поддержал Петра Яна перед боем в Абу‑Даби

«Желание посеять панику»: в Варшаве призвали поляков покинуть Россию

Летняя школа Русского дома приняла детей из Карабаха


Центр подготовки личного состава Северо-Западного округа Росгвардии пополнили призывники

Республика Алтай вошла в десятку регионов России по развитию ипотеки

Девочка упала при посадке на теплоход в порту Архангельска

Собянин: Первый участок Рублево-Архангельской линии метро полностью пройден


В Симферополе на базе «Клинического госпиталя для ветеранов войн» функционирует гериатрический центр для пожилых людей с возрастными нарушениями

В Симферополе наградили юных крымчан за отвагу и решительность

Актуальная информация о задержке поездов в Крым и обратно

Поезда "Таврия" по-прежнему задерживаются из-за ЧП в Ростовской области


Герман Стерлигов посоветовал россиянам запастись гробами

Под Тамбовом пройдёт фестиваль авторской песни "Там, под Лысой Горой"

Как быстро систематизировать бизнес: инструменты и сервис ABR PRO

Высокопроизводительные электродвигатели от компании JackShaft














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *