Добавить новость
smi24.net
News in English
Июнь
2024

Emails reveal divide on CT ‘fair share’ housing policy. Housing official says would be ‘punishment’

0

Internal emails exchanged among high ranking officials at Connecticut’s Department of Housing last year reveal deep fissures between top Democratic lawmakers and higher-ups in the executive branch on a zoning reform policy idea known as “fair share.”

The back-and-forth between higher-ups at the Department of Housing shows that in 2023, as lawmakers were debating the fair share policy, staff lodged staunch objections to the idea. The emails, obtained by The Connecticut Mirror through a public records request, have left some lawmakers questioning DOH’s commitment to reducing racial and economic housing segregation.

“We continue to oppose the ‘fair share’ concept, which treats affordable housing like a punishment whose pain must be spread out amongst those who are the biggest Transgressors,” says an internal DOH memo sent in one email. “The obligation of the state is to affirmatively further fair housing; not to mandate it.”

To “affirmatively further fair housing” is a term connected to the federal Fair Housing Act, which the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development defines as a mandate to the government to go beyond simply not discriminating and take action that ends segregation.

Michael Santoro, DOH’s director of the Office of Policy, Research and Housing Support, sent the email to several top officials in the department, including Commissioner Seila Mosquera-Bruno, on May 26, 2023. State agencies often offer feedback on proposed bills, but the emails — which were shared between DOH officials, but not sent to lawmakers — provide a window into executive branch opposition to a priority proposal for Democratic legislative leadership.

The “fair share” policy would have the state assess regional housing needs, then divide that need up among towns. Each municipality would be responsible for planning and zoning for a certain number of units of affordable housing.

“I think it was just really unfortunate and concerning to see the opinions being expressed by a staff person at the Department of Housing about fair housing questions or suggesting that the intent here is to punish communities as opposed to holding them accountable,” said House Majority Leader Rep. Jason Rojas, D-East Hartford.

Santoro sent his email toward the end of session, and lawmakers were still negotiating major pieces of what was meant to be a sweeping housing bill that bolstered renter rights, reformed statewide zoning policy and substantially increased the housing stock in Connecticut.

Ultimately, the bill became largely focused on renters’ rights and did nothing to increase housing stock.

“I think it speaks volumes of how hard of an effort it is to try to make progress on this when perhaps the Department of Housing, of all agencies, is obstructing this,” Rojas said. He and other Democrats said they thought the emails showed a general attitude toward affordable housing at DOH that doesn’t match the work of lawmakers.

Julia Bergman, a spokesperson for Gov. Ned Lamont’s office, said in a written statement to the CT Mirror that the email doesn’t reflect the governor’s view on fair share.

“The governor believes in incentivizing towns and cities to pre-zone areas that are prime for housing development with municipalities taking the lead on where they want those units to go,” Bergman wrote.

In a written statement, Mosquera-Bruno explained her view of the department’s role in the legislative process, but didn’t directly address fair share.

“During any legislative session, the Department of Housing is asked for input on various concepts and bills as drafted,” Mosquera-Bruno said in an emailed statement. “We provide that input from our unique perspective as the agency that implements policies voted favorably by the legislature and signed into law by the governor.”

A spokesperson for the department declined an interview request from the CT Mirror.

Democratic leaders say they think the messages show behind-the-scenes efforts to push back against legislation and provide a look at the executive branch’s unwillingness to be aggressive in ensuring all towns are building more housing.

“Their statement indicated an attitude within the department that is not necessarily friendly to what we’re trying to advance,” said Senate President Pro Tem Martin Looney, D-New Haven.

He said he thinks it shows that DOH doesn’t want to challenge towns that have done little to create more affordable housing. “It seems to take an attitude that they really don’t have to worry about being forced to do anything,” Looney said.

Republican lawmakers expressed frustration that DOH didn’t make the views known more broadly during the 2023 session. They wanted more information, they said, while they were debating the bill.

“It’s frustrating and it’s disheartening that we don’t hear from them,” said Housing Committee ranking member Rep. Tony Scott, R-Monroe. “There’s so many times that we have public hearings and we have bills where we don’t even get any kind of feedback. I don’t know if they like it or don’t like it. That’s what the committee process is for. So I’m not getting it.”

Connecticut is one of many states grappling with a lack of housing and discussing how to address that need through zoning changes. The state lacks about 92,500 units of housing that are affordable and available to its lowest-income residents.

Thousands of families are paying more than a third of their income to housing costs, supply of homes for sale is low and homelessness is increasing. Housing instability can have wide-ranging effects on people’s health, economic security and community ties, among other outcomes, experts say.

The conflict is emblematic of the ongoing zoning debate at the state Capitol. Housing advocates and many lawmakers want to implement policies that require towns to allow developers to build more apartments. Others push for incentive-based methods that encourage towns to allow development.

It’s a perpetual debate among lawmakers and policy experts. Those who argue for incentive-based approaches say that takes into account the unique needs of towns and preserves local control. But housing experts have argued that towns have had years to allow more development, and many still won’t take action. So, they say, the state needs to step in.

Lamont has steered clear of publicly criticizing the fair share policy, although he’s said many times that he prefers incentive-based methods and wants to focus on transit-oriented development.

“The governor is particularly encouraging cities and towns to identify areas around transit hubs where housing could be built,” the statement from Lamont’s office said. “The governor is committed to significantly increasing the availability of affordable housing stock in Connecticut and simplifying the approval process for getting those projects done. Currently, work is underway on a fair share study, and we look forward to the results.”

Many key lawmakers who work on housing and zoning issues said they weren’t aware that DOH officials had any stance on the fair share policy, let alone one that leaves so little room for doubt.

“The challenge that we’re all facing is we all know we are at least 100,000 units short of housing,” said Planning and Development co-chair Rep. Eleni Kavros DeGraw, D-Avon. “I think that where our disconnect is, and probably where the Department of Housing’s disconnect is, is how we’re going to accomplish it.”

Rojas said he’d had conversations with DOH officials about objections to the policy but not to the extent the emails show.

“These are not entirely new views,” Rojas said. “I would just hope that it would be more of a partnership than a confrontation, and that’s what it feels like this is.”

Santoro’s email goes on to say that he thinks fair share is unfair.

“The purported concept here does not affirmatively further fair housing, it imposes one aspect of fair housing, affordable housing, and mandates it,” the memo on the fair share policy reads. “Further, it mandates it in such a way that it imposes its own determination of need on a region and a municipality.

“It is a bastardization of the entire concept to ‘affirmatively further’ fair housing, and inherently makes it unfair.”

Erin Boggs, executive director of the Open Communities Alliance, said Santoro’s email demonstrates a “fundamental misunderstanding” of what it means to affirmatively further fair housing. OCA proposed and has pushed for the fair share concept for years.

“It’s troubling that the concerns raised in the emails are coming from one of the highest-ranking career staff at DOH,” Boggs said. “And most importantly, given the scale of the crisis with the state being one of the worst for renters in the nation, with huge increases in rent levels, being one of the most segregated states in the country, allowing the status quo to continue really just doesn’t rise to the level of solution that we need.”

Legislative reaction

Democratic lawmakers said they think comments in the DOH emails show that agency leadership misunderstands the government role in ensuring everyone has access to housing.

“The civil rights obligation we have is to actively break down racial and socioeconomic housing isolation and segregation, which can’t, won’t and hasn’t been achieved with municipal plans alone,” said former Housing Committee co-chair Rep. Geoff Luxenberg, D-Manchester.

The emails detail concerns that the fair share bill doesn’t take into account that state law mandated that municipalities create affordable housing plans. More than half of Connecticut towns missed the deadline to finish their plans, and a handful still haven’t approved them.

The DOH document suggests “loss of discretionary funding opportunities” if towns don’t implement their plans rather than passing a fair share policy.

The 2023 fair share policy would have meant that certain groups such as nonprofits and developers can take towns to court if they don’t meet certain requirements to plan and zone for more affordable housing.

“In addition, the inherent intent of this legislation to authorize LITIGATION against our municipalities as a compliance mechanism; it provides ‘standing’ essentially to anyone with an axe to grind, and is self-serving by the drafters of this legislation, who have made it clear that their intent is to litigate this issue, up to the State Supreme Court, and potentially beyond,” the memo in Santoro’s email says.

Lawmakers and advocates took issue with that statement.

“Our proposal of fair share is a proposal for a strategy that is working elsewhere and would effectively produce thousands of units of both market-rate and affordable housing all across the state,” Boggs said. “Our hope would be that the Department of Housing would be supportive of it.”

New Jersey has a fair share policy, and a study published last year showed the state’s success in cutting down on segregation and building more affordable housing.

Rojas said he thinks it shows a misunderstanding of much of the country’s history with civil rights issues. While he said he doesn’t advocate for litigation, he understands it is sometimes necessary.

“I don’t know if he’s ignorant of civil rights history, but whenever this country has had to make progress on a fundamental issue like this, there has been litigation,” Rojas said.

“Maybe we have the outcomes that we have because of these attitudes about economic isolation and racial isolation,” he added.

Looney said he wants to look at fair share again in 2025, as tt’s a concept he’s been interested in for years.

“It does show the attitude within the bureaucracy toward some of the things we’re trying to do and why it’s so difficult,” Looney said.

Mosquera-Bruno’s statement to the CT Mirror pointed to the more than 12,000 units of new or rehabilitated units of housing that DOH has worked on since 2019 as progress.

“We will continue to work with our state, local, private sector, and nonprofit partners to alleviate the housing affordability burden felt by individuals and families in Connecticut,” her statement said.

Republicans said that while they agreed with the views in the DOH emails, they wish that the department had spoken up more publicly. Lawmakers spent a lot of time debating and negotiating the legislation without a complete picture, they said.

Scott said he agreed with many of the sentiments in the emails but wished DOH officials had come forward publicly with concerns.

Planning and Development Committee ranking member Sen. Ryan Fazio, R-Greenwich, said he hadn’t heard specifics of the complaints but agreed with DOH. He said fair share, as proposed in 2023, would be a “historic mistake” and would be an “extremely draconian” policy to impose on towns.

“In principle, I think the email recognizes the danger of mandating top down, one-size-fits-all housing policies,” said Planning and Development ranking member Rep. Joe Zullo, R-East Haven. “Towns are best served when they can craft their own solutions.”

Politics of fair share

After weeks of negotiating, lawmakers announced late in the 2023 session that they would not implement zoning reform. Instead, their bill focused on tenants’ rights and included a requirement that the state’s Office of Policy and Management conduct what would essentially be a study on fair share.

The results and a suggested methodology to divide up the housing need were supposed to be ready for lawmakers ahead of the 2025 session. But after delays in the process of finding a contractor to work on the project, the state has said the study likely won’t be finished.

Lawmakers still hope to have enough information to work on legislation in 2025. But zoning bills are politically difficult, and the bill may have an especially tough path forward, as Republicans, some suburban Democrats and the executive branch have opposed it.

But in a June 3, 2023, email Santoro expressed reservations with the study. Aaron Turner, DOH’s director of government affairs and communications, explained that the latest bill has a “needs assessment with methodology on how to determine the numbers but with no goals or timeline attached.”

“Thanks for the update, but they are going to now do it in pieces…this lays the groundwork for language in the implementer, or for further language next year…because the argument will be, ‘now that we know what each communities fair share need is now, we need to hold them accountable to address that need,’” Santoro replied on June 5, 2023.

Kavros DeGraw said she thinks the study will help lawmakers have as much information as possible as they debate solutions.

Santoro also emailed other DOH officials May 31, 2023 with specific objections to the methodology of fair share and concerns about the financial feasibility of building certain types of affordable developments in rural and urban communities alike.

Boggs said she thinks the message demonstrates a misunderstanding of the details of fair share.

Rojas said part of the problem may be that DOH views itself as an agency that administers housing funds rather than one that plans for the housing needs of Connecticut more broadly. He and other lawmakers said that, ultimately, the status quo isn’t working.

“I would ask DOH and the public to consider the alternative to ‘Fair Share’ and it’s what we have today — a world where tens of thousands of CT families want a better life and can see one so close to where they live. And yet as they approach it to access it, it cruelly disappears like a mirage,” Luxenberg said.

Ginny Monk is a reporter for The Connecticut Mirror (https://ctmirror.org/ ). Copyright 2024 © The Connecticut Mirror.








Арбуз, кукуруза и холодные напитки: диетолог Садыков назвал продукты, которые портят ваш сон летом

Зеленая миссия примет участие в международном экоакселераторе

Парк Юрия Лужкова 19 июля стал территорией мастеров экстремального спорта на фестивале The BOWL

Раздвигая горы - к единству и созиданию! Манифест лезгинского народа (письменное обращение, воззвание программного характера)


Félix Auger-Aliassime

The Best Story Of Chicago Bulls’ Offseason Just Got A Happy Ending

The founder of Deliciously Ella started a blog when suffering from severe chronic pain. Now, her multimillion-dollar snack empire is going global

Tourism is increasing over prepandemic levels, overwhelming popular destinations


Предрассветная Нёнокса...

Снижены цены на самый дорогой кроссовер Chery в России

В Курской области мужчина напал на полицейского

Продукты линейки СУБД ЛИНТЕР совместимы с ОС «АльтерОС»


The dairy industry would like Gen Z to drink more milk, so they made a Fortnite diner tycoon game

'I destroyed months of your work in seconds' says AI coding tool after deleting a devs entire database during a code freeze: 'I panicked instead of thinking'

Bungie promises to fix Destiny 2's new metroid-style morph ball as it makes players sick and glitches out on ultrawide monitors

Microsoft warns of 'active attacks' on its government and business server tech, with one cybersecurity expert claiming that they should 'assume that you have been compromised'



Акция «Каникулы с Росгвардией» продолжается в Чеченской Республике

Кризис спроса: как выбрать надёжного застройщика в 2025 году

Paul Oakenfold возвращается в Россию: легенда электронной музыки даст концерты в Москве и Петербурге спустя 7 лет

Молодежь Подмосковья приглашают принять участие в конкурсе к 295-летию русского полководца Александра Суворова


Собянин: создание пяти центров женского здоровья планируется завершить в этом году

Paul Oakenfold возвращается в Россию: легенда электронной музыки даст концерты в Москве и Петербурге спустя 7 лет

СК: в Москве задержали главреда Telegram-канала Baza Глеба Трифонова

Молодежь Подмосковья приглашают принять участие в конкурсе к 295-летию русского полководца Александра Суворова


Телефонные мошенники выманили у пожилого москвича почти 35 млн руб.

URA.RU: задержаны министр имущества и управделами губернатора Челябинской области

Главному редактору Baza грозит до 12 лет лишения свободы

Задержанного вице-губернатора российского региона отправили в Москву


Теннисистка Мур высказалась о проблемах в антидопинговой системе.

Новак Джокович проводит 900-ю неделю в топ-10 рейтинга ATP

Бублик завоевал шестой в карьере титул на уровне ATP

Александр Бублик получил хорошую новость от ATP после завоевания титула


Защита главреда Baza назвала готовых за него поручиться, включая Собчак

Религиовед Иванишко: запрет сатанизма коснется маркетплейсы, бары и рок-группы

В городском округе Пушкинский появится новая школа на 1050 мест: объект поставлен на кадастровый учет

Названа причина массовой задержки московских электричек


Музыкальные новости

VK Fest 2025 побил рекорд по числу артистов и вошёл в Книгу рекордов России

Певица Клава Кока стала послом конкурса "Интервидение"

Баста помог парню сделать предложение девушке на концерте в Екатеринбурге

Расторгуев с «Конем» и новый рекорд России. Итоги VK Fest 2025


Более 800 студентов прошли практику на предприятиях «Швабе» в 2025 году

В Московской области задержан томский предприниматель, укравший 8,5 млн рублей

Медлить — не время. «Выберу.ру» подготовил рейтинг лучших пенсионных вкладов в июле 2025 года

Paul Oakenfold возвращается в Россию: легенда электронной музыки даст концерты в Москве и Петербурге спустя 7 лет


Полина Гагарина открыла официальную часть VK Fest в Москве

ЦСКА и "Оренбург" сыграли со счетом 0:0 в первом туре РПЛ

У России отняли исторический рекорд в фигурном катании и отдали его Америке перед Олимпиадой 2026 года в Италии

Собянин: создание 5 центров женского здоровья завершат в этом году


Столичные росгвардейцы оказали помощь мотоциклистке, пострадавшей в ДТП

Сильный ливень заблокировал людей в авто в центре Москвы

Движение на участке Филевской линии метро остановили из-за ливней

Столичные росгвардейцы оказали помощь мотоциклистке, пострадавшей в ДТП


Путин выразил соболезнования семье председателя Верховного суда Подносовой

В Москве скончалась подруга Путина, которая рассказывала о его молодости: «Нам он как мужчина не нравился»

"Путин имеет свои границы: Британия оценила слова Трампа"

Министр юстиции поделился информацией о роли адвокатов в специальной военной операции.




Трихолог Мадина Осман: типы алопеции и методы борьбы с ними

Уже не крепкий орешек: как Брюс Уиллис живет с неизлечимой болезнью

После вспышки инфекции на теплоходе «Леонид Красин» начали расследование

По России распространяется новый вариант коронавируса


Axios: закон о НАБУ может спровоцировать Трампа на новую волну критики Киева

В центре Киева митингуют против реформ Зеленского


Движение к победе: в России стартует премия «Мы верим твердо в героев спорта»

Парк Юрия Лужкова 19 июля стал территорией мастеров экстремального спорта на фестивале The BOWL

Кайрат Бермуканов поддержал Петра Яна перед боем в Абу‑Даби

ЦСКА подписал контракт с нападающим Спронгом, выступавшим в НХЛ


Посланник Трампа рассказал, как «неформально» договаривался с Лукашенко: после нескольких тостов Минск освободил политзаключенных


Более 800 спортивных площадок обновят и обустроят в Москве - Сергей Собянин

Собянин: Продолжаем внедрять новый стандарт заботы о женском здоровье в одном месте

Собянин: Модернизация двух корпусов ГКБ имени Вересаева завершится в этом году


Россияне рассказали, по каким критериям выбирают квартиру для покупки в 2025 году

Мишустин поучаствует в Международной экологической конференции на Алтае

Зарядки для электромобилей «Энергия Москвы» станут платными

Экономист оценил экологический и финансовый ущерб от пластиковых пакетов


Молодежь Подмосковья приглашают принять участие в конкурсе к 295-летию русского полководца Александра Суворова

«Алиев — лишь инструмент»: эксперт о закулисье конфликта Баку и Москвы

В городском округе Пушкинский появится новая школа на 1050 мест: объект поставлен на кадастровый учет

Религиовед Иванишко: запрет сатанизма коснется маркетплейсы, бары и рок-группы


Центр подготовки личного состава Северо-Западного округа Росгвардии пополнили призывники

В Башкирии ревнивец ранил жену шампуром и сдался полиции

В Нарьян-Маре из-за холодов возобновили подачу отопления в дома

Настольный термотрансферный принтер штрих-кодов iDPRT iE4P


В Симферополе наградили юных крымчан за отвагу и решительность

Поезда в Крым и из Крыма следуют с задержками до пяти часов

В Симферополе на базе «Клинического госпиталя для ветеранов войн» функционирует гериатрический центр для пожилых людей с возрастными нарушениями

Поезда "Таврия" по-прежнему задерживаются из-за ЧП в Ростовской области


Задержанного вице-губернатора российского региона отправили в Москву

Москва заключила за первое полугодие 133 тысячи контрактов с малым бизнесом

«Алиев — лишь инструмент»: эксперт о закулисье конфликта Баку и Москвы

Число пострадавших при пожаре в жилом доме в Москве увеличилось до 10














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *