Добавить новость
smi24.net
World News in Dutch
Май
2016

Report: The UN failed to protect one of Southeast Asia's most persecuted minorities

0

The United Nations failed to protect the human rights of the persecuted Rohingya minority in Myanmar, according to documents leaked to VICE News.

The papers also indicate that UN officials on the ground disregarded multiple recommendations on the rights and security of the group.

The Rohingya, a predominantly Muslim ethnic minority from Myanmar's western Rakhine state, have been subjected to decades of persecution in the Buddhist-majority nation, culminating in massacres in 2012. The violence of that year was described by Human Rights Watch as a campaign of "ethnic cleansing," which involved "crimes against humanity" perpetrated by local mobs, at times with the support of state agencies. A 2015 report prepared by a team at Yale Law School for the NGO Fortify Rights found "strong evidence that genocide is being committed" against the Rohingya.

Myanmar's government confines more than 140,000 Rohingya, who were rendered homeless by the violence four years ago, to squalid camps. Across the state, basic rights such as freedom of movement and access to healthcare are severely curtailed by government measures, while apartheid-like conditions further limit the prospects of the group in the highly militarized northern Rakhine region.

Stripped of their citizenship rights in 1982, the minority are among the world's largest stateless populations. Last year, their plight caught the attention of the international press when boats full of Rohingya and some Bangladeshi passengers were abandoned on the open seas by human traffickers, and mass graves of many of the same "boat people" werefound in Thailand.

Perhaps the most damning charge contained in the cache of documents obtained by VICE News is found in a report commissioned by the UN to review the "human rights implications" of the world body's recent record in Rakhine state. The independent study, titled "A Slippery Slope: Helping Victims or Supporting Systems of Abuse?" and meant for an internal UN audience, concluded that the "situation in Rakhine state is forcing international institutions into complicity with systematic abuses" against the Rohingya, partly due to "excessive self-censorship" on rights.

The "current UN strategy of emphasizing development investment as the solution to the problems in Rakhine state," the study said, "fails to take into account that development initiatives carried out by discriminatory state actors through discriminatory structures will likely have a discriminatory outcome." In other words, pouring money into "development" without changing the government-imposed structures that oppress the Rohingya will not solve the problem. The paper added that such schemes are "aimed at mollifying" hostile populations that have targeted the Rohingya with acts of violence in the past.

The authors of the report, which is marked "confidential" and was prepared in late 2015, had access to a raft of internal documents, and they conducted private interviews with dozens of staffers from the UN and international NGOs. It is perhaps the most thorough internal review of the UN's Rohingya policy to date.

The findings of the paper are particularly damning in light of repeated internal warnings about the inadequacy of the UN response, contained in material seen by VICE News.

Youtube Embed:
http://www.youtube.com/embed/dVvntQNKZa0
Width: 800px
Height: 450px

A report produced by the Office for the High Commission for Human Rights or OHCHR, the UN's leading rights watchdog, in November 2014 observed that serious abuses such as "killings, torture, rape" were "ongoing," and called for "concrete action" to stop them, including the establishment of a UN-designed "human security" system which could prevent future atrocities.

A document from the same time, also obtained by VICE News and marked "confidential," contains the minutes of a meeting of the UN's "Senior Action Group," a high-level body including representatives from leading UN agencies and the Deputy Secretary General, Jan Eliasson.

The 2014 memo records that Eliasson "stressed the need to prioritize preventative efforts... [and] taking a firm stance on Human Rights Up Front," while a specialist within the organization identified "some risk factors associated with genocide" with regard to the Rohingya.

The UN established the "Human Rights Up Front" initiative in response to a damning internal inquiry into its failure to prevent mass atrocities in Sri Lanka during the end of the country's civil war in 2009. Launched by Secretary General Ban Ki-moon in 2013, the strategy "encourages staff to take a principled stance and to act with moral courage to prevent serious and large-scale violations" of human rights, and suggests a series of actions that can be taken to ensure this.

The "Slippery Slope" review paper, however, describes Myanmar as a near-rerun of the Sri Lanka crisis, albeit with very different circumstances. "[T]he dynamic of passivity and complicity with state strategies of abuse... is being repeated in Myanmar to an alarming level," it notes in its conclusions.

A section in the document that deals specifically with Human Rights Up Front lists the requirements set out by the initiative in a table, finding that the UN at the ground level had yet to properly fulfill its obligations in every single category.

An end-of-assignment report written by a veteran UN staff member who worked in Myanmar, leaked to VICE News by sources in the US, lays the blame for these failings largely at the door of the country's resident coordinator, or RC. The resident coordinator is the highest in-country role a UN official can occupy, and is comparable to a country's ambassador.

The end-of-assignment report, which takes the form of a letter directed at the author's former colleagues, notes that "I had to conclude time and time again that the RC discarded or simply ignored information that underscored the seriousness of the situation" for the Rohingya. It alleges that the coordinator instructed her staff to undermine other UN agencies that were taking a stronger line on Rohingya rights.

While the letter does not explain why the RC allegedly behaved in such a way, the "Slippery Slope" report observes that the UN country team led by the RC pursued a strategy that valued quiet diplomacy and the belief that "development investment itself will reduce tensions" in Rakhine state, an approach that drew criticism from other agencies in the organization.

REUTERS/Soe Zeya Tun

The author of the end-of-assignment report goes on to allege in the letter that the Coordinator was insistent on pursuing the strategies she favored and would engage in "bullying, intimidating and discrediting people that had a different view."

At one point, the author claims that the RC told them "repeatedly to find out when the Head of OCHA [Office for Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs] and / or OHCHR staff in the country was NOT available... so she could organize meetings at that time without having to listen to [their views]," which did not agree with hers.

The ex-employee's end-of-assignment report also claims that attempts to uphold Human Rights Up Front and the establishment of a human security system as other UN officials had requested were "put in the bottom drawer," as "the RC did not review and/or release the information and analysis provided."

This allegation is seemingly supported by broader observations contained in the "Slippery Slope" paper, which noted that there had been a "failure to implement a system-wide protection strategy," an outcome that suggests a "lack of the kind of teamwork and collaboration demanded by Human Rights Up Front."

The letter also referred to a "prevailing atmosphere of intimidation, non-accountability, and manipulation of information," which worsened in the aftermath of an alleged massacre in early 2014 near Maungdaw in Rakhine state. This event was likewise described in the "Slippery Slope" review as a turning point, which noted that "when the government disputed the facts and denied the massacre, the Resident Coordinator took a more cautious approach, no longer standing by the original allegation."

What followed this reversal, the official contends in the letter, was that OHCHR was effectively blamed for the "tense relation[ship] with the Government," due to its explosive claims of a massacre. This occurred, despite the RC's strong support for the OHCHR report which was privately retracted only after the publication came out.

"I was instructed to rewrite history," the author of the letter complained, referring to a "lesson learned" document drafted in the aftermath of the fallout over the massacre; a section of the piece which dealt with the RC's initial response was allegedly excised on the orders of the coordinator herself.

Youtube Embed:
http://www.youtube.com/embed/HmO7351fNFQ
Width: 800px
Height: 450px

When the official confronted the RC about this, a threat was issued: they were told "never to raise this again with her or anyone else 'if you want to continue your career at the UN.'"

"The discrediting of OHCHR continued throughout 2014 and the truth was often distorted vis-à-vis senior officials," the former official further alleged.

Michael Shaikh, the author of an initial UN report into the alleged massacre, told VICE News that he stands by his work. In his view, the UN changed its position on the incident because it "prioritized its relationship with the government over the people that it was in the business of protecting."

Speaking to VICE News, Renata Lok-Dessalien, the resident coordinator referred to in the end-of-assignment report, denied allegations that the UN was failing to uphold human rights. "I don't think anyone has spoken out as loudly as the UN on rights violations," she said. In response to allegations of complicity in abuses, she added that there had been "absolutely no complicity whatsoever."

However, the claim on outspokenness over rights is contradicted by the testimony of a former senior-level UN representative. Tomas Ojea Quintana, special rapporteur for human rights in Myanmar until last year, recalled that Lok-Dessalien had asked him personally not to be so vocal on the issue of Rohingya rights, and even not to visit Rohingya displacement camps.

"She advocated for another approach, which did not include a big focus on human rights but more on development and so on... her advice was not to be so outspoken or to visit Rakhine state," he recalled.

Other UN veterans feel that a critical focus on the actions of the in-country team is misplaced, and view failures at the central level in New York as far more significant. Charles Petrie, whose 2011 report into Sri Lanka helped spur Human Rights Up Front, and who was himself Myanmar's resident coordinator between 2003 and 2007, is among them.

"I see a lot of parallels with what happened in Sri Lanka," he said. "One of the the major problems then was the dysfunctionality of the UN system at the level of headquarters in New York. Everyone became engaged with the crisis, but no one took overall responsibility to come up with a common vision of what needed to be done. The same thing is happening in Myanmar."

A spokesperson for the office of the Secretary General of the UN in New York told VICE News that, contrary to some of the allegations above, "[t]he UN has systems in place that aim to respond effectively to serious human rights violations, as well as to prevent them," and that Rohingya rights abuses were a serious concern, adding "we have proactively spoken up on this issue both publicly and in our official contacts."

However, sources within the NGO community close to events, who wish to remain anonymous due to the risk to their careers, maintain that deep divisions remain over how best to deal with the crisis in Rakhine state.

Those sources also said that the organization has initiated what they called an internal "witch hunt" in response to the VICE News documentary Left For Dead: Myanmar's Muslim Minority, which featured some of the material cited in this story.

NOW WATCH: Doctors now say this type of cancer isn’t actually cancer — and the new classification is changing thousands of lives








Рилсмейкер. Услуги Рилсмейкера. Рилсмейкер в Москве. Стоимость работы Рилсмейкера.

Звезды тогда и сейчас: как выглядят самые красивые женщины Голливуда

«Анька Михалкова – лучшая, у нее самые нежные поцелуи»: Гоша Куценко рассказал в «Шоу Воли» на ТНТ, с кем из актрис ему понравилось целоваться

Арбуз, кукуруза и холодные напитки: диетолог Садыков назвал продукты, которые портят ваш сон летом


Tourism is increasing over prepandemic levels, overwhelming popular destinations

Why Juventus spent 111m this summer for only one new player

The founder of Deliciously Ella started a blog when suffering from severe chronic pain. Now, her multimillion-dollar snack empire is going global

OpenAI warns that its new ChatGPT Agent has the ability to aid dangerous bioweapon development


В МГУ создали ИИ-алгоритм для поиска скрытых форм молекул

На пожаре в частном доме обнаружили тела мужчины и женщины

В Курской области мужчина напал на полицейского

Axenix выводит бизнес-аналитику на новый уровень с ИИ-ассистентами в платформе In.Plan


Microsoft warns of 'active attacks' on its government and business server tech, with one cybersecurity expert claiming that they should 'assume that you have been compromised'

Bungie promises to fix Destiny 2's new metroid-style morph ball as it makes players sick and glitches out on ultrawide monitors

The dairy industry would like Gen Z to drink more milk, so they made a Fortnite diner tycoon game

'I destroyed months of your work in seconds' says AI coding tool after deleting a devs entire database during a code freeze: 'I panicked instead of thinking'



Хаски на Summer Sound – выиграй билеты на Like FM

Аделина Панина: как силой мысли заставить человека написать или позвонить

В регионах Центральной России продолжается ведомственная акция «Каникулы с Росгвардией»

Нам есть чем гордиться: каким будет Национальный центр «Россия» на Краснопресненской набережной


Лео Канделаки и Анжелика Стубайло сыграют в новую трэвел-игру «Кто куда» на ТНТ

Новое оборудование Dekree: грохоты с высокой пропускной способностью

Герман Стерлигов посоветовал россиянам запастись гробами

Хаски на Summer Sound – выиграй билеты на Like FM


Тропический ливень топит столичный ТЦ «Кунцево Плаза»

В Москве готовятся к первому фестивалю вьетнамской культуры

«Автостат»: Импорт новых легковушек в Россию рухнул на 63 процента

«Она была блестящим юристом с безупречной репутацией»


Рублев уступил в полуфинале теннисного турнира в Лос-Кабосе.

Архангельская теннисистка завершила выступление на турнире WTA 250 в Яссах

Мирра Андреева из России удерживает пятую позицию в рейтинге WTA.

Румынская теннисистка Бегу выиграла турнир в Яссах.


В Москве стартовала уличная фотовыставка "Герои нашего времени"

Заглянуть в мастерскую сценографа, слепить скульптуру и попробовать итальянский пирог — куда пойти после работы

Государственная Дума утвердила законопроект о штрафах за рекламу VPN-сервисов.

Сенатор Шейкин: штрафы за поиск экстремистских материалов не коснутся случайных переходов по ссылкам


Музыкальные новости

Таджикистан на «Интервидении» представит Фаррух Хасанов, спевший с Бастой

Собчак прокомментировала смерть Оззи Осборна

На концерт классической музыки «Мне дорог Бах…» приглашают псковичей

Менеджер Артиста. Менеджер по работе с артистами.


Кайрат Бермуканов поддержал Петра Яна перед боем в Абу‑Даби

Аделина Панина: как силой мысли заставить человека написать или позвонить

Хаски на Summer Sound – выиграй билеты на Like FM

Нам есть чем гордиться: каким будет Национальный центр «Россия» на Краснопресненской набережной


Брянские спортсмены победили на Чемпионате России по сверхлегкой авиации

Собянин: противовоздушная оборона сбила еще один беспилотник, летевший к столице

Рилсмейкер. Услуги Рилсмейкера. Рилсмейкер в Москве. Стоимость работы Рилсмейкера.

Собянин: еще два беспилотника, летевших на Москву, были ликвидированы


На МКАД из-за аварии образовалась пробка длиной в три километра

Москвичей предупредили о задержках наземного транспорта из-за ливня

Сильный ливень заблокировал людей в авто в центре Москвы

25 июля пилотажная группа "Звезда" пролетит над пробками на шоссе под Москвой


Путин выразил соболезнования семье председателя Верховного суда Подносовой

Министр юстиции поделился информацией о роли адвокатов в специальной военной операции.

Путин отметил победу синхрониста Мальцева на чемпионате мира в Сингапуре.

Путин отметил успехи российских школьников на математической олимпиаде.




Собянин: создание 5 центров женского здоровья завершат в этом году

Офтальмолог Кирилл Светлаков: секреты здоровых глаз для тех, кто носит контактные линзы

«Я на инвалидном кресле, он на «Тесле»: что случилось с блогером Мариш Мариш

Уже не крепкий орешек: как Брюс Уиллис живет с неизлечимой болезнью


Пока вы не уснули: открытая поддержка Алиевым Киева и «подзатыльник» Зеленскому от Трампа

«СТРАНА.ua»: Зеленский раскритиковал ЕС за непредоставление обещанной помощи


В Москве впервые пройдет фестиваль экстремальных видов спорта

Кайрат Бермуканов поддержал Петра Яна перед боем в Абу‑Даби

KENGURU GAMES в Звенигороде звенели на всю страну

Парк Юрия Лужкова стал ареной для главного события уличного спорта – фестиваля The BOWL


Юрист Трампа Коул рассказал, как пил водку с Лукашенко в Минске

Посланник Трампа рассказал, как «неформально» договаривался с Лукашенко: после нескольких тостов Минск освободил политзаключенных

Лукашенко призвал белорусских нефтяников «не раскачиваться, а бурить и бурить»

Вячеслав Федорищев и Александр Лукашенко наметили направления развития сотрудничества Самарской области и Беларуси


Более 800 спортивных площадок обновят и обустроят в Москве - Сергей Собянин

Более 800 спортивных площадок обновят и обустроят в Москве — Сергей Собянин

Сергей Собянин открыл школу на 1100 мест в стремительно растущей Коммунарке

Собянин: Модернизация двух корпусов ГКБ имени Вересаева завершится в этом году


Собянин рассказал, как Москва заботится о природе при строительстве метро

Россияне рассказали, по каким критериям выбирают квартиру для покупки в 2025 году

Уже 59 орловчан решили побороться за просветительскую награду «Знание. Премия»

Зарядки для электромобилей «Энергия Москвы» станут платными


Экс-советник ЦРУ: США следует «дружить» с Россией, чтобы вместе противостоять Китаю

«Она была блестящим юристом с безупречной репутацией»

Врач Штань: Способный победить деменцию препарат создали в России

Заглянуть в мастерскую сценографа, слепить скульптуру и попробовать итальянский пирог — куда пойти после работы


Республика Алтай вошла в десятку регионов России по развитию ипотеки

Собянин: Первый участок Рублево-Архангельской линии метро полностью пройден

Архангельская область - не самое перспективное место для трудоустройства

Центр подготовки личного состава Северо-Западного округа Росгвардии пополнили призывники


В Симферополе наградили юных крымчан за отвагу и решительность

Поезда "Таврия" по-прежнему задерживаются из-за ЧП в Ростовской области

Актуальная информация о задержке поездов в Крым и обратно

"Гранд сервис экспресс" сообщил о задержках 16 поездов в Крым и из Крыма


Сотрудники Росгвардии задержали мужчину, подозреваемого в угоне в Подмосковье

«Автостат»: Импорт новых легковушек в Россию рухнул на 63 процента

Сенатор Шейкин: штрафы за поиск экстремистских материалов не коснутся случайных переходов по ссылкам

В Москве готовятся к первому фестивалю вьетнамской культуры














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *