Добавить новость
smi24.net
World News in Dutch
Январь
2017

How Trump's pick to head a vaccine safety panel has distorted vaccine science

0

Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said Tuesday that he will head up a panel on vaccine safety for Donald Trump.

The president-elect’s transition team spokeswoman later walked that back, saying that he is “exploring the possibility” of forming a panel on autism, but “no decisions have been made.”

Let’s hope Trump drops any idea of a vaccine panel headed by Kennedy. For more than a decade, Kennedy has promoted anti-vaccine propaganda completely unconnected to reality.

If Kennedy’s panel leads to even a small decline in vaccine rates across the country, it will result in the waste of untold amounts of money and, in all likelihood, the preventable deaths of infants too young to be vaccinated.

That wasted money will largely affect public health departments, whose budgets are already strained. A 2010 study in Pediatrics calculated the public sector expenses of containing a measles outbreak in which 11 children were infected at $124,517, an average of more than $10,000 per infection.

That’s not to say that families won’t be affected as well: During that outbreak, 48 children too young to be vaccinated had to be quarantined at an average cost of $775 per family; medical costs for one infant who was infected were close to $15,000.

But those costs pale into comparison to the loss that will be felt by families who lose children to vaccine-preventable diseases, which typically strike when children are infected while still too young to be vaccinated.

Take pertussis, more commonly known as whooping cough. There have been several dramatic spikes in pertussis infections in the past decade, and in 2012 there were 48,277 reported cases in the US — the most since 1955. More than 87 percent of all of the country’s pertussis deaths from 2000 to 2014 were in infants younger than 3 months, which meant they were too young to have gotten their first pertussis shot.

Kennedy made his name in the anti-vaccine movement in 2005, when he published a story alleging a massive conspiracy regarding thimerosal, a mercury-based preservative that had been removed from all childhood vaccines except for some variations of the flu vaccine in 2001.

In his piece, Kennedy completely ignored an Institute of Medicine immunization safety review on thimerosal published the previous year; he’s also ignored the nine studies funded or conducted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention that have taken place since 2003.

I first wrote about Kennedy and his foray into the anti-vaccine movement in “The Panic Virus,” my book about the persistence of the myth that vaccines can cause autism. Below is a lightly edited version of my chapter on Kennedy, titled “A Conspiracy of Dunces.” REUTERS/Shannon Stapleton

While Kennedy has been brazen in publicizing outright lies, he appears to be less loquacious when faced with skeptical reporters. I attempted to contact Kennedy more than 20 times over an 18-month period. At various points, I was told that he was considering my interview request, that he was on vacation, that he was dealing with a family crisis, that he wasn’t feeling well, that he was behind in his emails, and that he was on the verge of calling me back. (He never did.)

In the summer of 2005, Rolling Stone and Salon simultaneously published “Deadly Immunity,” a 4,700-word story on mercury in vaccines written by Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

Kennedy, the eldest son and namesake of the former attorney general and New York senator, described how he’d come to investigate the issue: “I was drawn into the controversy only reluctantly. As an attorney and environmentalist who has spent years working on issues of mercury toxicity, I frequently met mothers of autistic children who were absolutely convinced that their kids had been injured by vaccines. Privately, I was skeptical.” [Note: Shortly after “The Panic Virus” was published, Salon decided to pull the piece from its site.]

Then, Kennedy wrote, he began to look at the information these parents had collected. He pored over the transcript from the 2000 CDC-organized meeting outside Atlanta and spoke with members of SafeMinds and Generation Rescue, two groups notable for their virulent opposition to vaccines.

He also studied the work of the “only two scientists” who had managed to gain access to government data on the safety of vaccines: Dr. Mark Geier, a frequent paid witness in lawsuits alleging harm done by vaccines, and his son, David. (The Geiers would go on to develop a “protocol” for treating autism that involved injecting children with the drug that is used to chemically castrate sex offenders at a cost of upwards of $70,000 per year.)

It wasn’t long before Kennedy became convinced that he’d stumbled upon “a chilling case study of institutional arrogance, power and greed.” If, as he believed to be the case, “our public-health authorities knowingly allowed the pharmaceutical industry to poison an entire generation of American children, their actions arguably constitute one of the biggest scandals in the annals of American medicine,” he wrote.

Kennedy went on to quote SafeMinds’ Mark Blaxill, whom he identified as the vice president of “a nonprofit organization concerned about the role of mercury in medicine.” Blaxill accused the CDC of “incompetence and gross negligence” and claimed that the damage done by vaccines was “bigger than asbestos, bigger than tobacco, bigger than anything you’ve ever seen.”

In the article’s final paragraph, Kennedy warned his readers of the scandal’s likely effects on the future: “It’s hard to calculate the damage to our country — and to the international efforts to eradicate epidemic diseases — if Third World nations come to believe that America’s most heralded foreign-aid initiative is poisoning their children. It’s not difficult to predict how this scenario will be interpreted by American’s enemies abroad.” In fact, he wrote, he was certain that the failure of a generation of “scientists and researchers … to come clean on thimerosal will come back horribly to haunt our country and the world’s poorest populations.”

In order for what Kennedy was claiming to be true, scientists and officials in governmental agencies, nonprofit organizations, and publicly held companies around the world would need to be part of a coordinated multi-decade scheme to prop up “the vaccine industry’s bottom line” by masking the dangers of thimerosal.

In Kennedy’s telling, the plotting had been going on since the Great Depression, but it had begun in renewed earnest five years earlier “at the isolated Simpsonwood conference center,” a location that Kennedy said was chosen because it was “nestled in wooded farmland next to the Chattahoochee River, to ensure complete secrecy.” (In reality, the location was chosen because a series of previously scheduled conferences had booked up all of the hotel rooms within 50 miles of Atlanta.)

Kennedy relied on the 286-page transcript of the Simpsonwood meeting to corroborate his allegations — and wherever the transcript diverged from the story he wanted to tell, he simply cut and pasted until things came out right. Again and again, he used participants’ warnings about the reckless manipulation of scientific data by people with ulterior motives to do the very thing they were afraid would happen.

REUTERS/Shannon Stapleton

The CDC’s Robert Chen was one of the victims of Kennedy’s approach. His actual quote is as follows:

“Before we all leave, someone raised a very good process question that all of us as a group needs to address, and that is this information of all the copies we have received and are taking back home to your institutions, to what extent should people feel free to make copies to distribute to others in their organization? We have been privileged so far that given the sensitivity of information, we have been able to manage to keep it out of, let’s say, less responsible hands, yet the nature of kind of proliferation, and Xerox machines being what they are, the risk of that changes. So I guess as a group perhaps, and Roger [Bernier, the associate director of science at the National Immunization Program], you may have thought about that?”

In Kennedy’s hands, it became this:

“Dr. Bob Chen, head of vaccine safety for the CDC, expressed relief that ‘given the sensitivity of the information, we have been able to keep it out of the hands of, let’s say, less responsible hands.’”

Even more egregious was Kennedy’s slicing and dicing of a lengthy statement by the World Health Organization’s John Clements. In this instance, Kennedy transposed sentences and left out words. Here is what actually appeared in the transcript, with italics added to indicate the sentences Kennedy used in his story:

“And I really want to risk offending everyone in the room by saying that perhaps this study should not have been done at all, because the outcome of it could have, to some extent, been predicted and we have all reached this point now where we are left hanging . . . There is now the point at which the research results have to be handled, and even if this committee decides that there is no association and that information gets out, the work has been done and through Freedom of Information that will be taken by others and will be used in other ways beyond the control of this group. And I am very concerned about that as I suspect it is already too late to do anything regardless of any professional body and what they say. . . . My message would be that any other study — and I like the study that has just been described here very much, I think it makes a lot of sense — but it has to be thought through. What are the potential outcomes and how will you handle it? How will it be presented to a public and a media that is hungry for selecting the information they want to use for whatever means they have in store for them?”

REUTERS/Shannon Stapleton

In “Deadly Immunity,” that was changed to read:

“Dr. John Clements, vaccines advisor at the World Health Organization, declared flatly that the study ‘should not have been done at all’ and warned that the results ‘will be taken by others and will be used in ways beyond the control of this group. The research results have to be handled.’”

To top it all off, Kennedy married together two separate comments made by the developmental biologist and pediatrician Robert Brent. In the first one, Brent said:

“Finally, the thing that concerns me the most, those who know me, I have been a pin stick in the litigation community because of the nonsense of our litigious society. This will be a resource to our very busy plaintiff attorneys in this country when this information becomes available. They don’t want valid data. At least that is my biased opinion. They want business and this could potentially be a lot of business.”

Thirty-eight pages later, Brent addressed the topic of “junk scientists”:

“If an allegation was made that a child’s neurobehavioral findings were caused by thimerosal containing vaccines, you could readily find a junk scientist who would support the claim with ‘a reasonable degree of certainty.’ … So we are in a bad position from the standpoint of defending any lawsuits if they were initiated and I am concerned.”

In a distortion that the editor of a high school newspaper would have balked at, Kennedy took these two statements, switched their order, and ran them together:

“We are in a bad position from the standpoint of defending any lawsuits,” said Dr. Robert Brent, a pediatrician at the Alfred I. DuPont Hospital for Children in Delaware. “This will be a resource to our very busy plaintiff attorneys in this country.”

 REUTERS/Shannon Stapleton

In the overall scheme of the piece, that type of quote massaging was considered so insignificant that it didn’t warrant inclusion in the more than five hundred words’ worth of “notes,” “clarifications,” and “corrections” that were eventually appended to the piece. (The misuse of Chen’s quote wasn’t acknowledged either.) Among the issues that were addressed were incorrect attributions, inaccuracies about which vaccines contained thimerosal at different points in time, a misrepresentation of the number of shots children had received in the 1980s, and a false claim about a scientist having a patent on the measles vaccine.

None of this put a dent in Kennedy’s conviction that his allegations were valid, and in the weeks and months to come, he kept on repeating many of the errors Rolling Stone and Salon had already publicly acknowledged were wrong.

Just four days after a correction confirmed that his story had misstated the levels of ethylmercury infants had received — it was actually “40 percent, not 187 times, greater than the EPA’s limit for daily exposure to methyl mercury”— Kennedy told MSNBC’s Joe Scarborough, “We are injecting our children with 400 times the amount of mercury that FDA or EPA considers safe.” Kennedy also said on-air that children were being given 24 vaccines and that each one of them had “this thimerosal, this mercury in them.”

Those statements were not even remotely true: In 2005, the CDC recommended that children under 12 years old receive a total of eight vaccines that protected against a dozen different diseases. Only three of those vaccines had ever used thimerosal as a preservative, and all had been thimerosal-free since 2001.

That Scarborough didn’t ask Kennedy to produce evidence supporting his accusations is not surprising: Scarborough had long had a hunch that vaccines were to blame for his teenage son’s “slight form of autism called Asperger’s.” Kennedy’s research, it seemed, had confirmed his suspicions once and for all. “There’s no doubt in my mind,” Scarborough said, “and maybe it’s two years from now, maybe it’s five years from now, maybe it’s ten years from now — we are going to find out thimerosal causes, in my opinion, autism.”

Seth Mnookin is the director of MIT's Graduate Program in Science Writing. His most recent book, "The Panic Virus," is about the vaccine-autism controversy.
This is an opinion column. The thoughts expressed are those of the author.

NOW WATCH: Airplane designers have a brilliant idea for the middle seat








Проазербайджанский агент Сергей Марков в оккупированном Шуши восхищается Алиевым, пока тот унижает Россию: намечается новый «иноагент»?

В сервисном локомотивном депо «Югра» успешно реорганизован цех по ремонту автотормозного и пневматического оборудования по системе 5S

Лео Канделаки и Анжелика Стубайло посетят Казань в новой трэвел-игре «Кто куда» на ТНТ

Актер Корешков объявил о разводе со своей женой Дарьей


Tourism is increasing over prepandemic levels, overwhelming popular destinations

The founder of Deliciously Ella started a blog when suffering from severe chronic pain. Now, her multimillion-dollar snack empire is going global

OpenAI warns that its new ChatGPT Agent has the ability to aid dangerous bioweapon development

Why Juventus spent 111m this summer for only one new player


Пьяный курянин избил супругу и чуть не задушил её штанами из-за ревности

The sun of the North

В Курской области мужчина напал на полицейского

Новая модель Hyundai Elantra уже доступна в России: какие изменения произошли


Microsoft warns of 'active attacks' on its government and business server tech, with one cybersecurity expert claiming that they should 'assume that you have been compromised'

'I destroyed months of your work in seconds' says AI coding tool after deleting a devs entire database during a code freeze: 'I panicked instead of thinking'

Настройки GameHub и Winlator для игры в Prey (2017) на Android

Bungie promises to fix Destiny 2's new metroid-style morph ball as it makes players sick and glitches out on ultrawide monitors



В регионах Центральной России продолжается ведомственная акция «Каникулы с Росгвардией»

В Москве подростки жестоко избили юношу из-за долга

Роскосмос опубликовал снимок циклона, который обрушился на Москву

Хаски на Summer Sound – выиграй билеты на Like FM


Нам есть чем гордиться: каким будет Национальный центр «Россия» на Краснопресненской набережной

Дептранс: из-за осадков перекрыто движение между "Кунцевской" и "Багратионовской"

Летняя школа Русского дома приняла детей из Карабаха

В регионах Центральной России продолжается ведомственная акция «Каникулы с Росгвардией»


МИД Польши обратился к своим гражданам с рекомендацией покинуть территорию РФ

В редакцию канала Baza пришли с обысками

Киностудия Горького отмечает 110-летие: экскурсии, мастер-классы и погружение в магию кино

Депутат Журова: призыв МИД Польши покинуть РФ нужен, чтобы посеять панику


Потапова не прошла во второй раунд турнира в Вашингтоне.

Новак Джокович проводит 900-ю неделю в топ-10 рейтинга ATP

Шаповалов одержал победу на теннисном турнире в Лос-Кабосе.

«Саша забрал корону». ATP отреагировал на триумф Александра Бублика


Путин поздравил российских школьников с успехом на олимпиаде в Австралии

Москвичей призвали во вторник ездить на метро из-за дождя

Pridex запускает гибкий офис в бизнес-центре рядом с "Москва-Сити"

«Нижний Новгород» подписал контракт с игроком из Венгрии


Музыкальные новости

Концертный Директор в тарифе Maxi.

Таджикистан на «Интервидении» представит Фаррух Хасанов, спевший с Бастой

Семеново, Онег, Борисово, Ивановка. Об усадьбах Рахманинова рассказала Наталья Басманова

Менеджер Артиста. Менеджер по работе с артистами.


Роскосмос опубликовал снимок циклона, который обрушился на Москву

В Москве подростки жестоко избили юношу из-за долга

Нам есть чем гордиться: каким будет Национальный центр «Россия» на Краснопресненской набережной

В регионах Центральной России продолжается ведомственная акция «Каникулы с Росгвардией»


Аэропорт Барнаула сообщил о значительных задержках московских рейсов

Овечкин рассказал об открытии в Москве музея в честь своего рекорда в НХЛ

Компрессор по подписке – новая услуга на рынке оборудования

Московское «Динамо» потеряло очки в первом матче сезона с новичком РПЛ


На МКАД из-за аварии образовалась пробка длиной в три километра

25 июля пилотажная группа "Звезда" пролетит над пробками на шоссе под Москвой

«КАМАЗ» на конференции «Литейный интенсив»

Маршруты автобусов № 248 и 732 на западе Москвы изменили из-за упавшего дерева


Путин отметил успехи российских школьников на математической олимпиаде.

Путин выразил соболезнования семье председателя Верховного суда Подносовой

Министр юстиции поделился информацией о роли адвокатов в специальной военной операции.

Путин отметил победу синхрониста Мальцева на чемпионате мира в Сингапуре.




«Я на инвалидном кресле, он на «Тесле»: что случилось с блогером Мариш Мариш

Уже не крепкий орешек: как Брюс Уиллис живет с неизлечимой болезнью

Собянин: создание 5 центров женского здоровья завершат в этом году

Офтальмолог Кирилл Светлаков: секреты здоровых глаз для тех, кто носит контактные линзы


«СТРАНА.ua»: Зеленский раскритиковал ЕС за непредоставление обещанной помощи

Пока вы не уснули: открытая поддержка Алиевым Киева и «подзатыльник» Зеленскому от Трампа

Перед новыми переговорами? Москва отбивается от дронов, в Киеве - «реально ад»


Гафин: предпосылок для возвращения Захаряна в «Динамо» немного

В Москве впервые пройдет фестиваль экстремальных видов спорта

Парк Юрия Лужкова стал ареной для главного события уличного спорта – фестиваля The BOWL

KENGURU GAMES в Звенигороде звенели на всю страну


Посланник Трампа Коул рассказал, как пил водку с Лукашенко с Минске

Вячеслав Федорищев и Александр Лукашенко наметили направления развития сотрудничества Самарской области и Беларуси

«Выпил две рюмки, не вырвало»: юрист Трампа рассказал, как пил водку с Лукашенко ради освобождения заключенных

Лукашенко призвал белорусских нефтяников «не раскачиваться, а бурить и бурить»


Собянин рассказал, как город заботится о природе при строительстве метро

Сергей Собянин открыл школу на 1100 мест в стремительно растущей Коммунарке

Собянин: Москва выделила уже более 20,5 млрд на поддержку производств

Более 800 спортивных площадок обновят и обустроят в Москве - Сергей Собянин


Россияне рассказали, по каким критериям выбирают квартиру для покупки в 2025 году

В фокусе внимания. В Москве эксперты обсудили проекты по экобезопасности

Фестиваль «Сады и цветы»: как Москву превращают в городской оазис

Уже 59 орловчан решили побороться за просветительскую награду «Знание. Премия»


110-летие Михаила Матусовского отметили на арт-фестивале «С чего начинается Родина?» на ВДНХ

Москвичей призвали во вторник ездить на метро из-за дождя

«Нижний Новгород» подписал контракт с игроком из Венгрии

МИД Польши обратился к своим гражданам с рекомендацией покинуть территорию РФ


Собянин: Первый участок Рублево-Архангельской линии метро полностью пройден

Центр подготовки личного состава Северо-Западного округа Росгвардии пополнили призывники

Архангельская область - не самое перспективное место для трудоустройства

Республика Алтай вошла в десятку регионов России по развитию ипотеки


В Симферополе наградили юных крымчан за отвагу и решительность

Поезда в Крым и из Крыма следуют с задержками до пяти часов

Поезда "Таврия" по-прежнему задерживаются из-за ЧП в Ростовской области

"Гранд сервис экспресс" сообщил о задержках 16 поездов в Крым и из Крыма


Новое оборудование Dekree: грохоты с высокой пропускной способностью

Собянин: создание 5 центров женского здоровья завершат в этом году

В Татарстане капитально отремонтировали 132 многоквартирных дома

Москвичей призвали во вторник ездить на метро из-за дождя














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *