Shoppers Say This ‘Refreshing’ $9 Cream Is a Must to ‘Tighten & Brighten’ Your Under Eyes

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.

Let’s be honest: most of us have made peace with a little under-eye drama. But when puffiness and dark circles start staging a full-blown rebellion, the right product can make a difference — and according to hundreds of reviewers, the Physicians Formula RefreshMint Cucumber & Bamboo Eye De-Puffer Stick is punching way above its $9 price tag.

This solid gel stick isn’t flashy. It doesn’t promise to erase every sign of fatigue or turn you into a porcelain doll overnight. What it does offer is a refreshingly simple solution to tired, puffy eyes — one that shoppers swear “tightens and brightens” without irritating sensitive skin. One longtime fan shared, “This is my third time buying this product… It has a cooling minty refreshing effect on your eyes. It leaves that area soft and refreshed.”

Packed with peppermint, cucumber, and aloe, the formula delivers a soothing chill that kicks in on contact. A quick swipe under the eyes in the morning — or anytime you look like you lost a round with a pollen bomb — and you’re back in business. One reviewer raved, “Reduced puffiness on first use… It’s sheer, not white and hazy like other depuffers, so it doesn’t show up in fine lines. I’m sold!”

Even skeptical users were surprised by the visible effects: “At first I didn’t feel like it did much, but I started applying a more generous amount and I can feel it tighten and brighten. A great find!” That gentle tightening comes courtesy of skin-refreshing bamboo and glacial mineral water, while the balm’s stick format means no greasy fingers or product waste.

Sensitive skin? No problem. Multiple reviewers praised the de-puffing stick formula’s “non-existent” scent and smooth texture. “It absorbs well and does not feel sticky,” one shopper noted, calling it their new go-to for both AM and PM use. Another said, “I don’t usually buy eye creams under $20… but I took a stab at this and I have absolutely no regrets.”

If you’re looking for a no-fuss fix to fake eight hours of sleep, the under-$10 cult favorite that is Physicians Formula RefreshMint Cucumber & Bamboo Eye De-Puffer might just earn a permanent spot in your fridge and skincare routine.

Before you go, check out our slideshow below: