Shoppers Say This $8 Concealer ‘Worked Much Better Than Department Store Brands’ to Cover Dark Circles

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.

If you’ve ever stood under the harsh glow of a department store mirror wondering if $42 concealer is just your fate now, good news. According to loyal fans, Physicians Formula Gentle Full Coverage Concealer Stick is doing the most for tired under-eyes and stubborn dark circles, all for under $8.

Let’s start with the basics: this concealer comes in a non-drying stick form that glides on like a dream and blends seamlessly with your sponge or fingers. “It really helps to lighten the area and make those under the eye bags less noticeable,” one shopper shared, adding that it “blends right in with my beauty sponge.” The creamy, fragrance-free formula is designed with sensitive skin in mind — no irritation, no clogged pores, and definitely no crepey dryness.

And while it’s technically a drugstore find, reviewers insist the creamy under-eye concealer outperforms pricier picks. One wrote, “I have very dark, under-eye circles. Nothing worked. The Physicians Formula products have been a lifesaver! Worked much better than department store brands & was less than 25% of the price.” Not only is it budget-friendly, it’s also been vetted by people with decades of skin-care trial and error under their belts: “Been using for decades. Still great for me!”

Shopper also say that the concealer’s stick formula is surprisingly versatile. Fans love that it doesn’t melt off midday and plays nicely with both bare skin and makeup, even in less-than-ideal conditions. “Works pretty well in high humidity as long as you apply in a cool room initially,” one reviewer advised. Plus, the “light” tone adapts to seasonal skin shifts, from winter pallor to a summer tan.

If you’re eyeing the yellow-toned version, reviewers say it’s especially great for counteracting the bluish tones of dark circles. “I bothered with buying multiple concealers. But truth be told, I only needed the yellow under-eye concealer stick,” one user wrote, praising it as “affordable” and “also quality.”

Or, as another fan put it plainly: “This is by far the best concealer for dark under eyes… even very expensive brands! You will not be disappointed!”

If that sounds like a promise your under-eyes need to hear, it might be time to give Physicians Formula Gentle Full Coverage Concealer Stick a try.

Before you go, check out our slideshow below: