We Found a 4-Pack of Interactive Halloween Cat Toys for Just $10 & Shoppers Say ‘Your Cats Will Be Addicted’

If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.

If your cat has already claimed your jack-o-lantern centerpiece as a scratching post, there’s a less destructive way to get them into the spooky spirit. The Potaroma 4-piece Halloween Cat Toy Set is just under $10 on Amazon, and pet parents say their kitties “went into addict mode” the second these hit the floor.

Each plush toy — shaped like a pumpkin, black cat, skull, and spider — is stuffed with catnip and silvervine, plus crinkle filling for that irresistible crunch. The mix of textures keeps cats engaged, while the glow-in-the-dark stitching makes them easy to spot after a round of 3 a.m. zoomies. One shopper wrote in a review titled “Your Cat Will Be Addicted To These”: “They will go in their toy bin and pick these and play for hours. I’d say be careful with where your cats play with these as they’ve knocked over some glass plates since they’re so focused on the toys.”

For multi-cat households, the four-pack of catnip toys has proven durable enough to survive some serious chaos. One reviewer noted, “Cats love catnip and these did not disappoint! Both cats went into addict mode and played & slobbered on them for a long time… the catnip is still going strong.” That staying power comes down to the sealed bag freshness and reinforced stitching, which buyers say stands up to “ferocious bunny kicking and ravenous biting.”

The Halloween-themed catnip toys are pulling double duty for cats dealing with stress or boredom. A reviewer who picked them up for a jealous kitty after a new roommate moved in said, “These definitely cheered my cat up and I love the designs! Two are already soaking wet from her rolling around and chewing on them.” Another customer added that their older cat surprised them by “playing nonstop for a solid day” — a rare endorsement for any feline toy.

At under $10, this Halloween-themed four-pack of cat toys has quickly become a seasonal staple. Between the crinkle sound, the catnip high, and the ghoulishly cute designs, shoppers are clear: “My cats are obsessed.” If you’re looking for enrichment that actually outlasts a single afternoon, this might be the treat your little monster deserves.

Before you go, check out our slideshow below: