Добавить новость
smi24.net
Public Discourse
Июль
2024
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8 9 10 11 12
13
14
15 16 17 18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31

Multigenerational Living: A Step Back to Healthy Communal Life

0

multigenerational household
The love that rebuilds civilization comes when we live together. This is an opportunity to make a serious, radical, countercultural sacrifice of one’s own selfishness, a sacrifice that can change the family culture. It is not an easy decision or an easy life. But it is good.

Surprisingly, multigenerational living is a topic of interest in modern America. Realtors are noticing more buyers seeking homes that accommodate extended family members. Whether the cause of the uptick is the visible crisis of isolated elderly people dying alone in nursing homes during COVID-19, or the economic situation that is making it harder for young people to buy homes and for older people to retire, the topic is trending.

Multigenerational living has been a part of my own life. My aunt and uncle took my aunt’s father into their home when he was no longer able to live on his own. As he lost the ability to drive, prepare food, manage his own daily maintenance, and even remember who his loved ones were, my aunt entertained no thoughts of a nursing home. As my great uncle forgot the names and identities of his family members, as he started experiencing World War II flashbacks in the middle of the night, my aunt continued to make the sacrifices necessary to live with and take care of her father. When asked why, she would say, “That’s what we do.” It was the expectation in my family that, just as parents take care of their weak, inconvenient, vulnerable children for the first years of the children’s lives, grown children have a duty to take care of their weak, inconvenient, vulnerable parents for the last years of the parents’ lives. I’ve seen examples of this cultural expectation in the lives of my friends, colleagues, and neighbors as well.

But reference to such anecdotes risks missing the point. The families I know who live with multiple generations are southern Italian families who immigrated to New York. There is a danger of stereotyping multigenerational living and devotion to parents, as endemic to immigrants (and their descendants) from Mediterranean or Middle Eastern countries. Surely this arrangement is not for us Americans, with our pioneering spirits and rugged individualism.

But the American development of suburban life, coupled with a culture of individualism, is not normal. Most people in most cultures, throughout most of history, lived in a multigenerational family situation. As one immigrant author reflecting on his own family experience put it, “Multigenerational living isn’t immigrant culture. It’s human culture, and always has been. Modern American society is the abnormality in this scenario.” It is only in an immensely wealthy and individualistic world that multigenerational living could seem foreign rather than the norm.

If multigenerational living should be the norm, a question remains. In an age when many now have the means to avoid multigenerational living—to purchase a home in the suburbs to contain just a few people, and to hire outside caretakers to deal with aging and infirm family members—is multigenerational living a positive good to be sought rather than a sometimes useful arrangement? Is this a vision that should be articulated and promoted as normative, as the way people ought to live? While multigenerational living involves personal sacrifice and a serious change in mindset and culture, there are good reasons, both theoretical and practical, that this lifestyle should be restored in American culture.

Restoration of Community

America suffers from extreme individualism, “the idea of the solitary, self-sufficient human self.” Of course, a certain amount of self-reliance is good and necessary; nobody is advocating that adults live in their parents’ basements or expect support from others when they could be caring for themselves. The point is that society breaks down when people see themselves primarily as individuals rather than as a part of various social units with deep connections to, and obligations to care for, others.

I am a husband and father, a son and brother, an uncle. I am an attorney, a writer, a public speaker. I am a Catholic. I am a resident of Pennsylvania and a citizen of the United States. These aspects of my identity come with obligations of care. I am not an individual absolved from social responsibility—I have duties to care for my wife and children, my coworkers, my fellow parishioners, residents, and citizens. Society breaks down when individuals live as if they only had to care and be responsible for themselves. 

Multigenerational living is a healthy antidote to a lack of community, through the bonds of relationship. Too many people live alone. Even those who are married and have children too often live scattered throughout the country or the world, far from their parents, adult children, siblings, cousins, nieces, nephews, and grandchildren. After the nuclear family, the extended family is the next unit of society. Living among extended family creates close ties that bond people to their ancestors, their homes, and their communities. Intentionally choosing to live in the same town as one’s extended family, and particularly in order to have several generations of family members living in the same home or on the same property, is a radical but healthy way to recapture the reality that one exists, thrives, and loves in relationships, not as an isolated individual.

Multigenerational Homes: Practical Living

In the wake of COVID-19, many suffered and died in isolation, away from family and the human connections central to a healthy life. Multigenerational living is a practical antidote to the anti-life culture; while many elderly people do indeed require medical care that goes beyond the ability of their family members to give, it is important to embrace multigenerational living as normal, rather than defaulting to nursing homes as the place for all aging parents to spend their last years. Multigenerational living allows people who have spent their lives working, raising families, and being part of their communities to spend their final years on earth surrounded by love and care.

But while caring for the aged and infirm and keeping them out of nursing homes is certainly a good and healthy trend, it is not the only (or even the primary) reason to embrace multigenerational living. Even if an elderly person is not sick and does not require nursing care, it is simply not good for an elderly personfor any personto live alone. God was very clear about this: He declared in Genesis that “[i]t is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him a helper fit for him,” thus declaring that family life, rather than solitude, is the ordinary and good way for man to live.

Moreover, multigenerational living, especially living with one’s elderly parent(s) in the home, is a matter of both filial piety and justice. What better way to honor father and mother than to live with and care for them in their last years, especially considering that they cared for us when we were at our most vulnerable? This arrangement reveals a beautiful symmetry and order in human life, where the times of vulnerability and care shift as children become adults and adults become elderly. 

While multigenerational living arrangements require a good deal of sacrifice, they also have numerous practical benefits. First of all, shared resources lessen the financial burden on families. An elderly parent living in the house, while he may have only modest savings or a small pension, can contribute to the mortgage, the utilities, or the property taxes. This is especially important in the age of the two-income trap, where many families would like one parent to stay at home to care for and educate the children but can’t afford to sacrifice one income. When more people with income or assets live under the same roof, there is an ability to share expenses, and this allows for greater financial freedom.

People will also highlight the obvious benefit for a young family of having a grandparent live in the house: free childcare. What young parents wouldn’t want a live-in babysitter in the basement, making date nights, evening events, or even just a walk around the block after the kids are in bed easily attainable, without the ordeal of identifying, hiring, and transporting babysitters? But the obvious practical benefitsless need to pay babysitters or daycares, more shared expenses that lower the family budgetcan miss the deeper benefits of living together.

One of the great malformations of modern culture is the age insulation caused by small families and the public school system: kids grow up spending most of their time exclusively with other kids that are exactly their own age. As Ben Sasse pointed out in The Vanishing American Adult, this is an unnatural and problematic way to raise children. As kids grow up, face trials, and experience suffering, they are meant to be exposed to a wide variety of age groups. Kids a few years older can mentor them through the experiences they themselves faced; older people provide wisdom, experience, and calm, a living reminder that the little trials of youth do indeed pass. But when kids face troubles and have only their peers to talk tobecause they don’t have many siblings and don’t live around any adults other than their (busy, working) parentsthey are more likely to face difficulties growing through the trials and rites of passage that lead to healthy adulthood.

Multigenerational living is the healthy, natural, traditional version of “it takes a village to raise a child.” A living arrangement that is open to housing elderly parents or other extended family can be a recipe for raising healthy children. Being part of a multigenerational household allows children to grow up with a natural mix of young and old in their lives; parents have the help of extended family members to deal with their small children; grandparents have the benefit of living their golden years surrounded by youth, by family, by love.

A living arrangement that is open to housing elderly parents or other extended family can be a recipe for raising healthy children.

 

Multigenerational Living Is Good, but Not Easy

A brief note on the challenging realities of multigenerational living is necessary to avoid painting a rosy, unrealistic picture. The multigenerational family situation is good, but not easy or convenient. It is easier to have complete privacy, to have fewer people in the home for whom you are responsible. But family life is not meant to be easy or convenient. No sane parent will say that having children added ease and convenience to his life. Children require sacrifice, flexibility, and infinite patience. Our parents made that sacrifice so that we could be born, formed, and able to live good lives. In turn, multigenerational living involves sacrifices of time, convenience, and space in order to care for others. 

It is important not to romanticize what multigenerational living is really like. First, it is worth noting that in some cases the arrangement is entirely impracticable. Especially today, when the revolution of modernity has swept through so many lives and families, bringing all kinds of sins, vices, and problematic ways of living, this arrangement is just not always possible. Some family members, even one’s parents, may have habits and issues that make it impossible for them to live healthily in a multigenerational family community. While the modern world may overemphasize the importance of asserting “boundaries” in unhealthy relationships, in some cases, such boundaries are needed.

When it is feasible, people should seriously consider adopting this family- and community-centered life over the American “get out on your own and be your own man” individualistic mentality. Overall, the movement toward multigenerational living is where restoration of community and the end of loneliness becomes possible. This may be a radical proposition to American ears, but the radical isolation and loneliness plaguing today’s culture need a radical remedy. For conservatives who speak often about rebuilding community, restoring the centrality of the family, and rebuilding culture: this is where the rubber meets the road. Restoration comes through love and friendship. The love that rebuilds civilization comes when we live together. This is an opportunity to make a serious, radical, countercultural sacrifice of one’s own selfishness, a sacrifice that can change the family culture. It is not an easy decision or an easy life. But it is good.

Image by Nina L/peopleimages.com and licensed via Adobe Stock.







Письмо генеральному прокурору и отмена выборов - чем может обернуться избрание нового главы города Сочи?

Заведующий рефракционным отделением клиники микрохирургии глаза АйМед Кирилл Светлаков: как снизить нагрузку на глаза при работе с гаджетами

РОССИЯ ПРОВЕРИТ ЦРУ И СЕКРЕТНУЮ СЛУЖБУ США?!

Выборы мэра Сочи могут отменить из-за нарушений


Что ваши соски говорят о вашем здоровье? Известный врач дал им классификацию, рассказав как сохранить грудь здоровой

Итоги конкурса красоты «Miss Beauty World 2024»

Красочная фотозона и «Дискотека Детского радио» для гостей фестиваля «Вкус Лета»

Итоги прошедшей недели восточной культуры "Караван Парад"


UFC Denver video: Abdul Razak Alhassan vs. Cody Brundage ends in no-contest after illegal blows

Bears Reportedly Played A Big Part In Giants Losing Saquon Barkley

Faculty of International Journalism and Mass Communications Eurasian International University is conducting an additional intake of applicants!

Warner will not be considered for 2025 Champions Trophy: Bailey


Закат на Жеребцовой горе....

Портативный сканер штрих-кодов Heroje C1271 промышленного класса

Маэстро.

Доля ремонтов по ОСАГО упала почти в 2,5 раза


I didn't expect my favorite cozy MMO to do a crossover with a Finnish children's series

Двадцать пять человек за одним столом под звуки караоке – это было шедеврально!

Yesterday I ignored 10 tornado warnings to finish a Destiny 2 raid, didn't get the exotic drop, and disappointed my fiancée. Is there some sort of lesson here?

CD Projekt's Pawel Sasko tells the inspiring tale of how an Estonian beet farmer in Australia became a senior quest designer on The Witcher 4


Фотомагазин PYN: ваш надійний партнер у світлі та фотографії


Опубликован рейтинг упоминаемости и активности политиков в Telegram каналах за июнь 2024 года

Выборы мэра Сочи могут отменить из-за нарушений

Жаркий движ «Браво, артист» на Черноморском побережье

Письмо генеральному прокурору и отмена выборов - чем может обернуться избрание нового главы города Сочи?


Заведующий рефракционным отделением клиники микрохирургии глаза АйМед Кирилл Светлаков: как снизить нагрузку на глаза при работе с гаджетами

Депутат МГД Козлов обсудил с застройщиком благоустройство в Сосенском

Владислав Овчинский: жители дома на Радужной улице начали переезд в новостройку по программе реновации

Суд в Москве вынес приговор американцу по делу о наркотиках


Московский суд приговорил к 13 годам колонии экс-десантника ВС США за наркотики

В Петербурге стартовали съемки продолжения «Казановы»

Суд Москвы признал оскорблением чувств верующих туалетную бумагу с деньгами

Двухлетняя девочка неделю проходила с проволокой в горле в Подмосковье


Карлос Алькарас за день до финала Уимблдона играл в гольф

Алькарас обратился к Джоковичу после финала Уимблдона

Уроженка Самарской области выступит на Олимпиаде в Париже

Рублева призвали успокоиться


Суд Москвы признал оскорблением чувств верующих туалетную бумагу с деньгами

В Петербурге стартовали съемки продолжения «Казановы»

Министром по конкурентной политике Подмосковья стала Светлана Журавлева

В Москве мигрант чуть не убил беременную, но его не лишат гражданства - закон на его стороне


Музыкальные новости

В СВАО на фестивале можно попить чайку под музыку Вивальди

Жена Басты раскрыла секрет похудения. Результаты уже заметны

Компания ICDMC приняла участие в XIV Фармацевтической конференции «Зелёный крест»

VK Fest 2024 – все. Рекорды и яркие моменты главного фестиваля страны, закончившегося в Москве


Жаркий движ «Браво, артист» на Черноморском побережье

Опубликован рейтинг упоминаемости и активности политиков в Telegram каналах за июнь 2024 года

Выборы мэра Сочи могут отменить из-за нарушений

Владислав Овчинский: жители дома на Радужной улице начали переезд в новостройку по программе реновации


Канадец Фроз из «Вегаса» стал хоккеистом «Локомотива»

"ИЗВЕСТИЯ": Бывший министр обороны Армении Аршак Карапетян — о потере Карабаха, политике Пашиняна и костюме в кредит

Гаджиев назвал низкими шансы "Динамо" из Махачкалы побороться за тройку РПЛ

Жителям юга России ограничили электроснаблжение из-за сбоя на Ростовской АЭС


Ульяновский росгвардеец несколько километров тащил на буксире автомобиль из Москвы

«Мосавтодор» устранит последствия урагана «Эдгар» в Воскресенске

ДЕТИ ВОЕННОСЛУЖАЩИХ И СОТРУДНИКОВ РОСГВАРДИИ ОТМЕТИЛИ ДЕНЬ РИСОВАНИЯ НА АСФАЛЬТЕ В САРАТОВЕ

Исследование: Москва стала лидером по числу ДТП с участием велосипедистов


В Кремле исключили связь слов Трампа о Путине и заявления России после покушения

Представители муниципалитетов Псковской области окончили федеральную «Школу мэров»

Москва глазами художников

Автостопом через всю Россию. В Бурятии встретили отважного путешественника из Приморья


Новая пандемия может разразиться из-за патогена искусственного происхождения

«Возникнет форс-мажор»: что будет с выборами в США, если Байден не перенесет COVID-19



«Возникнет форс-мажор»: что будет с выборами в США, если Байден не перенесет COVID-19

Главный врач клиники "Мегастом", стоматолог Владимир Лосев: какую зубную пасту предпочесть

В мастер-классе ко Дню рисования на асфальте приняли участие пациенты Детской клинической больницы

В Москве врачи спасли двухлетнюю девочку с застрявшей в горле проволокой


Зеленский намерен отобрать государственные награды у Азарова, Табачника, Ефремова. Напуганный Бойко - за

Зеленский поставил крест на последней надежде Киева: попытки Рады развернуть соратника Трампа в свою сторону обречены на провал

"Умерили амбиции": Провал "саммита мира" вынудил Зеленского призвать к переговорам, заявили во Франции

МИД РФ: Вашингтон дал Киеву карт-бланш на удары по российской территории


Ковшом и ножом. Экскаваторщик-гольфист вытворяет умопомрачительные финты

Мужской волейбольный клуб "Держава" оказался в семёрке сильнейших команд России

Письмо генеральному прокурору и отмена выборов - чем может обернуться избрание нового главы города Сочи?

Выборы мэра Сочи могут отменить из-за нарушений


Олег Кожемяко и Александр Лукашенко обсудили создание морского порта в Приморье


В двух колледжах Москвы пройдет комплексное обновление — Собянин

Сергей Собянин: Создаем комфортные условия для учебы

Собянин принял решение о реконструкции корпусов двух колледжей Москвы

Мэр Москвы сообщил о подписании 22 офсетных контрактов


У российской ИТ-компании "Рексофт" появилось сразу несколько стратегических партнеров

Гидролог раскрыл, является ли Москва-река чище Сены

Сертификаты Wildberries в подписке от Инго Экосистемы

В Москве из-за аномальной жары появились осы пелопеи и сколии-гиганты


Министром по конкурентной политике Подмосковья стала Светлана Журавлева

В Москве мигрант чуть не убил беременную, но его не лишат гражданства - закон на его стороне

В Петербурге стартовали съемки продолжения «Казановы»

В Москве суд приговорил гражданина США к 13 годам колонии за сбыт наркотиков


Премьера документального фильма о Мосеевом острове состоится в Архангельске в ноябре

Пассажир самолета в Пулково открыл аварийный люк из-за жары в салоне

ТСД SAOTRON RT41 GUN: практичный, производительный, надёжный

АО «Транснефть - Север» в I полугодии 2024 года выполнило диагностику более 1 тыс. км трубопроводов в 4 регионах


Люди в тюрьмах на жару в Крыму не жалуются

Краеведческое посвящение «Здесь артековская слава начинала свой поход»

Час духовности «Приняла крещенье Русь»

В рейтинге городов России по объемам ввода жилья Севастополь на 29 месте, Симферополь — 73


Московский суд приговорил к 13 годам колонии экс-десантника ВС США за наркотики

В Москве суд приговорил гражданина США к 13 годам колонии за сбыт наркотиков

Суд Москвы признал оскорблением чувств верующих туалетную бумагу с деньгами

15 художников из Белоруссии и городов России приехали на пленэр в Псковскую область














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *