Добавить новость
smi24.net
The New Republic
Февраль
2024
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11
12 13 14 15 16 17
18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29

There Will Never Be Another Magazine Like Vice

0

Last week Vice, the media company where I frittered away a third of my life, announced that it was essentially shutting down its editorial operations. This meant several hundred people would lose their jobs—a practically weekly occurrence in journalism these days—and that I had to spend an annoying amount of time archiving the portfolio-worthy stories I wrote or edited there. Collapsing media companies, and there are a lot of them right now, sometimes delete their websites. Vice insists it will maintain its website, but if one day it changes its mind—because maintaining even a dormant site costs considerable money—then all evidence that I did anything productive during the 2010s would disappear.

That little digital archive is sitting on my computer now, a few feet away from the stacks of physical Vice magazines I worked on. These battered glossies are going to outlive the company that published them, which is ironic since Vice the company spent years running away from Vice the magazine and its sordid reputation. In my 12 years at Vice, I watched it grow up, hire people who weren’t skaters or cokeheads, and gentrify just like the Williamsburg neighborhood surrounding its office. Vice was intent on becoming a mainstream news organization, which meant an unslakable thirst for investors, comically inflated valuations, and the inevitable succession of expansions, “pivots,” and cutbacks.

In hindsight, Vice’s death was foretold by that ambition. Had it remained a niche print magazine, it might still be alive today.

Stories about the end of Vice tend to lump it in with other failing digital media brands. And it’s true that Vice suffered from the same ailments facing companies like BuzzFeed and G/O (formerly Gawker): an ad market that’s been in a long slump, social media traffic to news sources cratering, and overpaid, incompetent leadership. Cory Doctorow, the pioneering blogger, copyright activist, and science fiction author, portrayed Vice’s end in familiar terms: Hardworking, passionate journalists are producing incredible, important investigative work, but are betrayed by corrupt, greedy executives. Vice’s founders, he wrote, “built a massive, highly lucrative media empire on [young people’s] free labor.” Doctorow praised Vice’s tech coverage team in particular (they were pretty great), and declared, “Whatever problems Vice had, they weren’t problems with Vice’s workers—it was a problem with Vice’s bosses.”

Doctorow meant to be scathing, but if anything he was too generous. Vice was only “highly lucrative” in the sense that it had a lot of money sloshing around. It had a big fancy Brooklyn headquarters, a dozen or more international offices, and hundreds of people on the payroll, some of whom would fly around the world to report from conflict zones. As it grew, it founded a record label and an ad agency, acquired smaller media companies like Refinery29 and i-D, and had TV shows on MTV and HBO before getting its own cable channel. The company even bought a bar and started brewing its own beer, called Old Blue Last, which tasted like the tail end of a long night out. During one holiday party, co-founder Shane Smith handed out envelopes to employees containing $1,500 in cash.

But upon what was that excess built? It wasn’t all those award-winning journalists—they got hired, for the most part, after Vice was already on the rise. It wasn’t that Vice went through a period of gangbusters profitability—the most optimistic insiders only ever claimed “intermittent” profitability. In reality, it was bankrolled almost entirely by investors who believed that it was poised for world domination. There was such optimism among these funders that in 2017 Vice was valued at $5.7 billion, to which a reasonably plugged-in Vice employee might have responded, “with a B?”

These investors believed in Vice because they believed in Smith, who had Trumpian talents of self-conviction and bluster. He sold them on the idea that Vice had a unique, unbreakable connection to millennials (who were then young people) and that it was the future of news, destined to destroy CNN. And at least when Smith started making this pitch, the thing backing him up was the reputation of the irreverent, caustic, irresistible magazine.

“We do stupid smart and smart stupid” was how my first boss at Vice summed up the magazine’s ethos. It was stunt journalism, and arguably not even journalism, but it was daring and provocative. Before I got there, the staff all went to a Native American reservation and edited and wrote all the articles from there (including some by reservation residents). There was a “gross jar” that was a jar filled with gross stuff; this was a recurring column. We had a whole series where we’d give someone acid, send them somewhere weird, and film them. We dressed dogs up in bondage gear for one fashion shoot, and sent models down to Occupy Wall Street for another. We had a try-anything writer who cooked and ate her own vaginal discharge for one article, and covered herself in live raccoons for another.

We published fiction and photo essays and incomprehensible screeds and things that probably shouldn’t have been published. One cover was adorned with a photo of a dildo by renowned Italian artist Maurizio Cattelan, covered by a sticker that said “DILDO.” The DOs & DON’Ts, where editors and comedians roasted people in photos submitted by readers, were both hilarious and, by today’s standards, unforgivably vicious. The magazine was stupid, and especially during the tenure of founding editor Gavin McInnes—who would go on to found the Proud Boys — it could be racist, sexist, and cruel. But it touched a chord, as did some of Vice’s early videos. If you smoked a ton of weed in the 2000s, you probably ended up in someone’s ratty apartment watching either Smith’s visit to North Korea or the Epicly Later’d skate documentaries.

The coverage of Vice’s demise rarely mentions this era of the company, a convenient omission for a lot of people. The serious journalists Vice hired in droves starting around 2014 (when Vice News was launched as a standalone brand) understandably didn’t want to be associated with McInnes or magazine features like “Paintballing With Hezbollah.” The company spent years polishing its image, beginning in 2008, when it cut ties with McInnes (when it became clear that his ironic racism wasn’t all that ironic). If the company got a lot of search traffic from “How to Suck Your Own Dick”—an all-time SEO headline—the story it wanted to tell to its own employees, media reporters, and especially investors was that it was a global news organization.

The change accelerated in the mid-2010s. The website and magazine were redesigned, and the fashion photo spreads—once the lavish centerpieces of every issue—were discontinued, the overworked fashion editor laid off. The weird stuff began to be marginalized. In 2018, the magazine’s frequency dropped from monthly to quarterly, ending the photo and fiction issues. A subsequent tweak to the website removed the issue-by-issue magazine archive; old articles are still online, but in most cases their formatting has degraded and the images have disappeared. You can only find the DOs & DON’Ts through Google. A skeleton crew of staffers did keep the print product going, though the magazine was barely acknowledged by the company that owned it. It even came back after a pandemic-related hiatus, producing a few issues in 2021 helmed by editorial director Kate Dries. (The last-ever issue was called “The Indulgence Issue.”)

In ditching its original identity, Vice gained respectability but couldn’t make respectability work for it. How, as a former Vice executive told New York magazine in 2018, “do you scale the essence of a punk-rock magazine into a multibillion-dollar media company? There is no real answer. At some point, what got you there isn’t what you are.” If Vice needed to evolve in order to grow and attract investment, the digital media company it evolved into had serious flaws. Its in-house tech products all sucked, as anyone who ever used its CMS can attest. It was among the first companies to produce truly high-quality videos for the web, but squandered that advantage by pivoting to television and film instead of the short-form content that has since taken over social media. Its traffic numbers were inflated and sometimes outright fake.

Vice journalists did great work and garnered accolades, but that was no great achievement on the company’s part—hire journalists and you’ll get journalism. Where was the business plan? In 2014, Smith predicted Vice would bring in $1 billion in revenue by 2016; in 2022, it was only earning $600 million, $100 million below its target. By then, Smith had left his CEO post following scandals involving sexual harassment and the underpayment of female employees. But his departure didn’t change the company’s downward trajectory. How could it have, when the company was built on his otherworldly powers of spin?

Vice needed to change, of course, and not just for cynical, cozying-up-to-investors reasons. Misogyny, racism, and nihilism were ingrained in the magazine from the get-go. Could you have cut out the toxicity without losing what made Vice compelling to so many readers? Could the company have evolved not into a vaporware global news organization but a different kind of small, weird magazine? Maybe. Jesse Pearson, who was the editor in chief when I was an intern, quit to start a magazine called Apology (get it?) and it might not be famous, but it’s still going.

The simplest way to understand Vice is not as a media company but a zero interest-rate phenomenon, a property investors made speculative bets on because they had to make bets on something. A scam, in so many words, but an unusually fruitful one. Not entirely on purpose, Vice produced some exceptional journalism. It launched careers (including mine). In its corporate era, it paid quite generous salaries to some C-suiters who couldn’t save the company (assuming they were even trying to). Smith walked away with $100 million, which is an unfathomable sum to me but not all that much money, really, given Vice’s rosy picture a decade ago. Me? I’ve got an archive of web stories on my computer desktop, and some old magazines on my shelves.








Аналитика МТС Банка и Ozon fresh: россияне все чаще предпочитают занятия спортом, активный отдых и протеиновую продукцию

В сервисном локомотивном депо «Иваново» Северного филиала компании «ЛокоТех-Сервис» автоматизируют рабочие процессы

Уникальные водные виллы Angsana Velavaru

К нам любят возвращаться!


At Hewlett Packard Enterprise, CEO Antonio Neri is facing off against an activist investor with a history of forcing out chief execs

The shopping wars are heating up this July as Dollar General and Walmart offer discounts ahead of Amazon's Prime Day

Official: Torino purchase Anjorin from Empoli, with Chelsea making profit

Stocks hit another record as House sends Trump $4.5 trillion bill to kick off July 4 weekend


Адаптация сценария. Адаптация сценария под полнометражный фильм.

На пути к государственной границе пойман зампред Челябинского заксобрания и вице-​президент Союза промышленников и предпринимателей

По факту гибели двух человек на трейле под Мурманском завели дело

Дроны парализовали аэропорты РФ: 150 рейсов отменили за сутки в Шереметьево


100 Дверей - Побег из Тюрьмы 3.7.0

Ballz 2 Beat 1.1.9

Arkane Studios founder slams Microsoft for its Game Pass focus: 'At some point reality has to hit'

Hideo Kojima's mysterious OD reportedly escapes the cancellation axe at Microsoft



Аналитика МТС Банка и Ozon fresh: россияне все чаще предпочитают занятия спортом, активный отдых и протеиновую продукцию

Аделина Панина: 10 заставок для телефона, которые зарядят вашу жизнь на успех и помогут найти любовь

Электрокоагуляция по науке: Алексей Горшков о роли гидроксида алюминия в очистке воды

Рубрика "Есть два стула..."


Создание Музыкального Лейбла. Создание собственного Музыкального лейбла.

Фейк кремлевских СМИ: в Париже найден мертвым хирург, собиравшийся рассказать «правду» об операции по смене пола Брижит Макрон

Утренние рейсы задержаны в аэропорту Томска после коллапса в столицах

Адаптация сценария. Адаптация сценария под полнометражный фильм.


Южный зной. Что за «ялтинские ночи» в Москве, и как это отразится на погоде

Кучно пошли: экс–замглавы Генштаба ВС России Арсланову дали 17 лет

SHOT: Девушка Старовойта перебралась из Курска в Москву около года назад

Столкнувшийся с одноклубником Литвинов избежал сотрясения мозга


Теннисист Хачанов стал первым четвертьфиналистом Уимблдона

Арина Соболенко вышла в 1/4 финала Уимблдона

Теннисист Алькарас назвал Рублева одним из самых сильных игроков в туре

Теннисист Андрей Рублев проиграл Алькарасу в 1/8 финала Уимблдона


Хибла Герзмава не выступит на фестивале в Кургане из-за задержки рейса

«Всё для Победы!» — трёхлетие движения, объединившего страну

Гимн земледелию и любви к Родине

Память о монорельсе и трамваи будущего. Последние новости транспорта Москвы


Музыкальные новости

Депутат ЗСК Виктор Тепляков принял участие в заседании политсовета «Единой России»

Лазарев, Басков ездят по России в рамках «Ну-ка, все вместе! Народный кастинг»

Последний концерт Оззи Осборна: как проводили легенду Black Sabbath

Суд еще раз взыскал долг по оплате коммунальных платежей с Тимати


Аделина Панина: 10 заставок для телефона, которые зарядят вашу жизнь на успех и помогут найти любовь

Ограничения в работе аэропортов коснулись Сыктывкара

Электрокоагуляция по науке: Алексей Горшков о роли гидроксида алюминия в очистке воды

QR-платежи: от простого к сложному — полный гид по современным способам оплаты


Звезды эстетики: мастер-класс Натальи Рябиновой на Beauty Олимпиаде

«Daily Express», Великобритания. Путин тонко подколол Трампа, высмеяв День независимости США

"Спартак" сыграл вничью с "Крыльями Советов" благодаря двум голам за две минуты

Суд оштрафовал Смолова за неуплату прошлогоднего штрафа


Память о монорельсе и трамваи будущего. Последние новости транспорта Москвы

ГАИ: мужчина погиб на МКАД после двойного наезда автобуса и "Газели"

Сотрудники вневедомственной охраны Главного управления Росгвардии по городу Москве оказали помощь гражданину, у которого заглох автомобиль.

В Люберцах планируется изъятие земельных участков для государственных нужд


Путин: артисты из стран БРИКС подтвердили участие в «Интервидении»

Путин подписал закон о новом порядке расчета компенсаций за нарушение интеллектуальных прав

«Всё для Победы!» — трёхлетие движения, объединившего страну

Путин подписал закон о новой категории оружия — «гражданское экспортное» только для зарубежных поставок




Группа «Самолет» провела серию донорских акций в Москве и Подмосковье 3 июля

Аналитика МТС Банка и Ozon fresh: россияне все чаще предпочитают занятия спортом, активный отдых и протеиновую продукцию

Врач-косметолог Зухра Балакеримова: можно ли справиться с пигментацией

Собянин: В Москве открыто еще шесть центров женского здоровья


СМИ: В Киеве царит атмосфера заговоров из-за Ермака

В Раде поставили под сомнение стремление Киева к миру


Киберспортсмены Хакасии завоевали серебро чемпионата России

Звезды эстетики: мастер-класс Натальи Рябиновой на Beauty Олимпиаде

Аналитика МТС Банка и Ozon fresh: россияне все чаще предпочитают занятия спортом, активный отдых и протеиновую продукцию

Военнослужащие и сотрудники Росгвардии обеспечила безопасность культурно-массовых и спортивных мероприятий в Москве


Тихановский не набрал донатов на свержение Лукашенко. Жена зовет на помощь Трампа


Собянин рассказал о благоустройстве территорий городских больниц

Сергей Собянин открыл шесть центров женского здоровья

Сергей Собянин рассказал, каким будет новый детский сад в районе Внуково

Сергей Собянин рассказал, каким будет национальный центр «Россия» на Пресне


Зной идет из Африки. Метеоролог Вильфанд: аномальная жара смертельно опасна

Электрокоагуляция по науке: Алексей Горшков о роли гидроксида алюминия в очистке воды

Синоптик Позднякова предупредила об аномальной жаре в Москве

Ученые МГУ: Таяние вечной мерзлоты на Колыме ускорилось на 50% за 20 лет


Останется инвалидом. Подробности о ребенке, впавшем в кому после зубного

Столкнувшийся с одноклубником Литвинов избежал сотрясения мозга

Героическое участие армян в СВО. Часть пятнадцатая

Хибла Герзмава не выступит на фестивале в Кургане из-за задержки рейса


Ефимов: в Москве благоустроят набережную Захарковского карьера

Отключения коммунальных услуг в Архангельске 8 июля 2025 года

Заммэра Москвы Ефимов сообщил о благоустройстве набережной Захарковского карьера

Ливни, грозы, шквалистый ветер и град обрушатся на 20 регионов России


Кто в Симферополе и Севастополе зарабатывает больше всех

Поезда из Москвы в Крым изменят расписание осенью

Глава Крыма заявил о готовности аэропорта Симферополь к открытию

ВТБ: Ялта вошла в топ-5 самых дорогих городов РФ по расходам туристов


Названа возможная причина смерти сотрудника Росжелдора в Москве

Политолог Марков заявил, что убийство Старовойта могли замаскировать под суицид

Гимн земледелию и любви к Родине

Доктор Мясников назвал простые правила контроля давления














СМИ24.net — правдивые новости, непрерывно 24/7 на русском языке с ежеминутным обновлением *